Nani red card: Law is there in black and white... and grey
Uncertainty over interpretation of rules in controversial sending off
Wednesday 06 March 2013
At the risk of coming over all Alan Partridge, it's there in yellow, blue and black on pages eight and nine of the 81-page booklet dealing with Law 12 (fouls and misconduct). That's Fifa's colour coding not mine. There is a colour missing, though, and that is grey.
Was Nani careless, reckless or using excessive force? Careless and it's a free-kick, reckless add a yellow card. Red is appropriate if "the player has far exceeded the necessary use of force and is in danger of injuring an opponent".
Nani's challenge could clearly have injured his opponent but did he exceed the necessary use of force? It's more than possible for Cuneyt Cakir to make that case amid the hurly-burly of the contest on seeing, at first glance (which is the only glance a referee gets) Nani's boot in Alvaro Arbeloa's chest. Former referee Dermot Gallagher pointed out that a referee can only follow the guidelines laid out for him and, according to those, Cakir is not wrong and Roy Keane's lonely stance in saying the referee got it right is right. But then Gallagher said he would not have dismissed Nani; he would have interpreted the guidelines differently. Different referees from different footballing cultures will come to different conclusions. There are always shades of grey.
Simon Calder looks at communities fighting back against the poachers
Arsenal 1 Everton 1: Substitute equalises with six minutes to go
Latest in Sport
Sam Wallace: David Moyes is paying the price of United’s virtual abstinence from top-level transfers since 2006. Can he refire their ambition?
Arsenal 1 Everton 1 match report: Gerard Deulofeu provides late sucker punch after Mesut Ozil's opener
I will not be forced into panic buys at Manchester United, says David Moyes
Gerard Deulofeu - Why Barcelona chose Everton to educate their latest prodigy
Ashes 2013-14 match report: Another woeful display sees England lose to Australia by 218 runs to go down 2-0
- 1 Turning up the voice of America
- 2 The poorest pay the price for austerity: Workers face biggest fall in living standards since Victorian era
- 3 The man who made Femen: New film outs Victor Svyatski as the mastermind behind the protest group and its breast-baring stunts
- 4 An obsessive’s documenting of Israeli war crimes in Lebanon can show us how the West lost respect for international law
- 5 Mass murder in the Middle East is funded by our friends the Saudis