Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter for the latest tips and offers Sign up to the Independent's betting newsletter
Roy Keane has called Manchester United winger Ashley Young “an absolute disgrace” for his dive in Tuesday night’s Champions League win over CSKA Moscow.
The 30-year-old has received widespread criticism for going to ground easily after minimal contact from defender Georgi Shchennikov in the penalty area.
Young, who has earned a reputation for diving over the last few years, failed to convince the referee Szymon Marciniak he deserved a spot-kick but escaped a caution for simulation.
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratingsShow all 11 1 /11Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings David De Gea: 7 out of 10 Constantly a figure of eminent composure and calm at the back. Had very little to do but was able to stop Doumbia from one on one late in the second half. Without it, United may well have gone on to lose the game.
2015 Getty Images
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Ashley Young: n/a out of 10 A horrible dive in the second half means that Young shouldn’t even be dignified with a rating. As good a footballer as he can be, his tendency to flop like a salmon embodies a scourge on the game that needs to be wiped out.
2015 Manchester United FC
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Chris Smalling: 6 out of 10 A topsy turvy night for the England defender; wasted a golden free header in the first half. However, his intervention late in the second was worth a goal in itself.
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Daley Blind: 7 out of 10 The modicum of cool; Blind is a figure who can read the game better than most. Has he ever made a mistake? Probably not. Didn’t have to do much, but what he did do was outstanding.
2015 Manchester United FC
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Marcos Rojo: 5 out of 10 A constant menace down the left wing, he combined wonderfully with Lingard all night. Yet, he missed two of United’s best chances and a horribly executed rabona cross when it was still goalless emphasised the vacuousness of some of the Argentinian’s decision making.
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Bastian Schweinsteiger: 6 out of 10 Combining with Carrick all evening Schweinsteiger was a comfortable orchestrator of United’s attack. When United looked good so did he, but for all the good; United were too lackadaisical for half of the match.
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Michael Carrick: 7 out of 10 Almost broke the deadlock with one rasping volley, it was another cultured performance from Carrick. His cross instigated the Rooney goal and his all-round composure is second to none in the team.
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Jesse Lingard: 7 out of 10 Didn’t look out of place at all in his starting debut. For much of the game he was one of the biggest threats, an energetic performance combined with some neat touches. He will surely be retained for the West Brom game.
2015 Manchester United FC
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Juan Mata: 6 out of 10 Buzzed around and was a threat but didn’t do enough to influence the game. Perhaps he couldn’t escape the CSKA bus but it wasn’t a convincing display.
2015 Manchester United FC
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Anthony Martial: 5 out of 10 Boos rang out in a disgruntled cacophony as he as subbed for Fellaini. Whilst the United fans weren’t happy, Martial was hardly present in the game. Van Gaal will be praying the Liverpool defeating player he bought turns up soon.
2015 Getty Images
Manchester United 1 CSKA Moscow 0 player ratings Wayne Rooney: 6 out of 10 The goal was so Rooney-esque; popping up just when he’s needed. But a striker and goalscorer he did not appear to be. Dropped deep far too often looking for the ball and was unable to grab the game by the scruff of the neck.
2015 Manchester United FC
Keane, commenting on the incident as a pundit for ITV, joined Paul Scholes, Gary Lineker and thousands on social media in condemning the former England international’s playacting.
"If he’s a Manchester United player, I’m a Chinaman,” Keane said. “It's absolutely disgraceful.
"The senior players need to get hold of him. That shouldn't be accepted at Manchester United.
"That's not leaving your leg in. That's different. It's the somersault he does, it's an absolute disgrace."
Manchester United winger Ashley Young goes over in a challenge against CSKA Moscow (Getty Images) Young’s tendency for theatrics was publicly criticised by both Sir Alex Ferguson and David Moyes during their respective times in the Old Trafford dugout.
"Maybe once or twice can be seen as a mistake. But he's done it nine or 10 times and he's done it at his previous clubs." added Keane, who was once sent off after diving during a Premier League fixture against Blackburn Rovers in 1995.
On the night of the game, Scholes, a former teammate of both Young and Keane, was equally as critical and described Young’s conduct as “embarrassing”.
"Ashley needs to stop doing this. He knows that himself, but it's just a habit and he can't get rid of it,” he said, speaking as a pundit on BT Sport.
"It's so obvious and he just needs to get this out of his game. It is embarrassing and Ashley knows it."
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies