Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Gareth Southgate's second-string side raises concerns over England depth

Marcus Rashford and Danny Rose stake claims to be included in the first team, but the same cannot be said for the rest of the players

Mark Critchley
King Power Stadium
Tuesday 11 September 2018 22:36 BST
Comments
Gareth Southgate with Danny Welbeck as he's substituted off in the second half
Gareth Southgate with Danny Welbeck as he's substituted off in the second half (Getty)

Gareth Southgate made no apologies for getting the gang back together when he announced his squad for these September internationals.

There would be an early-autumn reprise of the joyous summer just gone, even if it might end in a dispiriting, back-to-school September comedown. The players who achieved England’s best finish at a World Cup in 28 years would be largely retained, despite several suffering from a lack of playing time at club level and perhaps not warranting the recall. “I did not think to jettison a group who got to the semi-final would be fair,” Southgate admitted.

The King Power Stadium, pre-match, was full of that same sentimentality. A big-screen video, set to Black Rebel Motorcycle Club’s ‘Spread Your Love’, told the story of England’s tournament with the same joy and energy of those few weeks but also a newly-added wistfulness.

The persistent chanting of the Atomic Kitten-inspired ‘Southgate, You’re The One’ carried a similar sense of bittersweet longing. The World Cup is England’s recent past, but the past all the same. What of this team’s future?

Southgate, in fairness, added an important caveat when defending his decision to keep faith in his World Cup players. “Next month and the months coming, we will have to take a view on that,” he warned. “We will be going into matches where fitness levels are important for one and form will be key.”

This narrow, low-key and often-imperfect win over Switzerland was therefore the opportunity for several of England’s second-string – the summer’s unused and under-used – to cement their place for October’s Nations League trips to Croatia and Spain, no matter what struggles they face at club level over the next few weeks.

Marcus Rashford, England’s goalscorer, is the only bit-part player who will return to his club totally assured of his place. Despite only managing 121 minutes for Manchester United so far this campaign and being suspended for their next three domestic games, he is proving himself to be more-than-adequate back-up to Harry Kane.

His breakthrough – a simple finish through Yann Sommer’s legs – was his second goal in as many games after his opener against Spain on Saturday. His profligacy in that defeat and long spells of inaction here are unlikely to count against him.

Danny Rose’s place is newly under threat after the emergence of debutant Ben Chilwell, but the Tottenham Hotspur full-back’s persistence down the left flank earned him the official man-of-the-match award and he will surely remain in Southgate’s thoughts.

Elsewhere, though, there was evidence to support the concerns about a lack of strength in depth and enough reason for the England manager to experiment when selecting his next squad. Danny Welbeck started as Rashford’s strike partner, having not been trusted in Russia, but did little to earn such trust again.

Ben Chilwell made his England debut at his home ground (AFP/Getty Images)

Ruben Loftus-Cheek enjoyed a few bright moments and may, in future, offer an answer to the questions regarding the centre of England’s midfield, but he did not impress enough to allay the doubts over his playing time at Chelsea. The same could be said for Fabian Delph, who is yet to feature for Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City.

It was telling that when the raft of substitutions came on the hour mark, it was Welbeck, Loftus-Cheek and James Tarkowski – the only starter not to travel to Russia, and one who suffered an awkward opening half-hour in the centre of defence – that were replaced. Delph followed shortly after.

Jack Butland played the duration but still has cause to worry. Southgate is uneasy to pick Championship players and the Stoke City goalkeeper – the only representative from the second tier – looked equally uncomfortable at times, particularly with one early misplaced pass across the face of his own goal.

For Butland and for several others who started this game, there would always be a question mark against their continued involvement unless they produced. Not enough of them did in what was ultimately an unremarkable victory. The nation’s love for them may still be strong, but some of these summer boys could soon be gone.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in