Comment: Alan Pardew is just a stooge for Mike Ashley who runs Newcastle like his shops – cheap foreign imports and a tame manager

The Newcastle manager has collaborated in the club’s decline under Mike Ashley, writes Ian Herbert

Click to follow
The Independent Football

The takeover of Newcastle United was as mindless as the running of the club would prove to be.

Follow Newcastle vs Hull live here

Sir John Hall, who was selling up, was planning to meet a group of Malaysians at 11am on a Monday morning in May 2007 when agents telephoned on behalf of an Icelandic Bank which was funding Mike Ashley and insisted on meeting Hall off the King’s Cross train at 10am. They whisked him into offices – the Freshfields law firm off Fleet Street – and offered him a premium on his shares, there and then. Ashley was not even at the meeting.

The retail magnate did not even seek to do due diligence on the £55m deal to buy the Hall family stake. He just wanted the club to provide what Hall was informed would be “a form of shop window” for his Sports Direct chain and its goods. It was a way to reach the marketplace that excited him most: the Far East. “Newcastle were a global brand, big fanbase. He had a strategy,” Hall said of Ashley’s motivation. It was a breeze for a man who had netted £929m by selling 43 per cent of Sports Direct on the Stock Exchange. 

The utter insignificance of the city of Newcastle and supporters to this owner has been fundamental to the club’s catastrophic last few years, which will reach a new low before the home game with Hull when a group of supporters issue 30,000 A4 cards and 100 banners calling for Alan Pardew to be dismissed. The manager’s record has been dismal – five wins in the last 24 league games since beating Stoke 5-1 on Boxing Day, 15 points out of the last 72 – though he made the usual noises on Friday. “You don’t expect me to wave to the crowd and say, ‘Hi everyone, I’m happy, how are you today?’ That’s not happening,” he said. “But this can also make you stronger.”

Newcastle fans are planning a protest


Pardew has been the stooge for an owner who has handled the replenishment of the first-team squad in the summer as he would the freshening up of his stock – seeking cheap foreign imports with a re-sale profit potential and a manager tame enough not to stand in his way.

The dislocation between Newcastle – the world’s ninth biggest club in terms of income, who attracted an aggregate 100,000 to this season’s first two home games – and its supporters is charted impeccably by journalist Michael Walker in a new book, Up There: The North-East Football Boom and Bust, which tells the Ashley takeover story and reveals the myriad ways in which the club has become a clothes horse.


There are some wretched details – of how Ashley had plastered 137 Sports Direct logos across St James’ Park by the end of last season. They include the 18 on the top of the home dugout seats, 13 above the away bench and one glued on top of the Newcastle equivalent of Liverpool’s “This is Anfield” sign in the tunnel. “Buy something from the club shop and the till receipt will inform you that it is registered in Nottinghamshire, where Sports Direct has a base,” writes Walker.

The supply line of cheap foreign imports has reached the realms of the ridiculous, while the club’s profits have grown – to £9.9m last year, with a wages/earnings ratio of 64 per cent, below a Premier League average of 70 per cent. New Argentine striker Facundo “Chucky” Ferreyra has “never been seen in public,” as Newcastle’s Evening Chronicle put it this week and appears to have been signed because he is a friend of captain Fabricio Coloccini. He started only 13 games for Shakhtar Donetsk last season and it is understood some Newcastle players consider his signing to be a joke.

“The club are allowed to get away with so much because the national spotlight is not the same up here,” says Mark Jensen, editor of The Mag fanzine. “People just think ‘same old Newcastle, same old pantomime’. If it happened in London it would be different.”  Not that there is no questioning of a club which lurches from one shabby controversy to another. The Newcastle board have postponed next week’s fans’ forum until 20 October, though the Newcastle United Supporters’ Trust has been banned from the forum since last year releasing their own interpretation of answers the club has provided in the past.

Newcastle United owner Mike Ashley


When journalists challenge Ashley, the club goes to war with the press, too. For a time this week, a story about the Daily Telegraph’s latest ban received greater prominence on the club website than the illness of winger Jonas Gutierrez, who is undergoing treatment for testicular cancer in Argentina. Ashley is directing a public-relations disaster.

Jensen is among many who argue that Pardew is culpable and that Saturday’s protests are justified because he takes the Ashley shilling, refuses to challenge the mess and is managing a dreadful team. “He collaborates in this facade of saying everything is great, when we’ve lost more players in the summer than we’ve brought in,” Jensen said. No-one has forgotten Pardew dedicated last November’s 2-0 home win over Chelsea to Ashley. He severely undermined his position further by thrusting his head into the jaw of Hull City’s David Meyler in March and throwing a vilely abusive comment at Manchester City manager Manuel Pellegrini last season.

With foreign imports all the rage, the club’s link to locally developed players has also died. There have been none since Andy Carroll and Steven Taylor. “The area hasn’t changed in its love for football. It is a religion,” Michael Carrick’s father, Vince, who runs the legendary Wallsend Boys Club, told Walker. “But the standards have changed. The level is lower. Foreign players and managers are contributing factors. Newcastle have 10 Frenchmen.”

Walker points out that the Halls and their associate Freddy Shepherd took millions out of Newcastle, just like Ashley, though observes that they did have the ambition to win things. “Cold support for Newcastle was not one of their faults,” he writes. “Yes, they did buy and they did bring [Kevin] Keegan and Sir Bobby [Robson] in to manage the club,” Jensen says of Hall and Shepherd. “They knew how to create a good feeling. They understood that they could be pulling up at a petrol station somewhere around here and encountering fans. Ashley never will.”

Keegan faced protests, too. Hundreds of fans massed at St James’ in 1995 when he sold Andy Cole to Manchester United. “I went out to speak to them and offered to resign there and then. But after four or five minutes of talking to them the mood changed,” Keegan later recounted. “Effectively we had an open board meeting with the board at the back and I said to Terry [McDermott], ‘This is why this is such a great club’. People sometimes think the fans don’t know what the game is about. They know more, sometimes, than the people in the club. So we got them back onside.” What wouldn’t the supporters give to have those days back?

Up There: The North-East Football Boom and Bust, by Michael Walker, De Coubertin Books £16.99