David Conn: Richmond fall a lesson for League

There was eerie timing in the revelation that Geoffrey Richmond, until two years ago one of football's more notably successful chairmen, was made bankrupt on Monday, owing £3.3m to the Inland Revenue, in the same week that the Football League agreed in principle to introduce the long-delayed "fit and proper person test" for football club directors. If, as expected, the League's clubs pass the test into their rulebook at this summer's Annual General Meeting, and Richmond does not succeed in any appeal against his bankruptcy, he will be barred from becoming the director of any League club for the course of his bankruptcy.

There was eerie timing in the revelation that Geoffrey Richmond, until two years ago one of football's more notably successful chairmen, was made bankrupt on Monday, owing £3.3m to the Inland Revenue, in the same week that the Football League agreed in principle to introduce the long-delayed "fit and proper person test" for football club directors. If, as expected, the League's clubs pass the test into their rulebook at this summer's Annual General Meeting, and Richmond does not succeed in any appeal against his bankruptcy, he will be barred from becoming the director of any League club for the course of his bankruptcy.

The "fit and proper person test", aimed at preventing unsuitable or unscrupulous directors from taking over clubs, was first urged on the Football Association back in 1997, in a report it commissioned itself, from Sir John Smith, the former deputy commissioner of the Metropolitan Police. A majority on the Government's Football Task Force came to a similar conclusion in 1999, that it was a minimal, common sense protection for clubs not to be run by criminals, bankrupts or people who have run companies into insolvency. The football bodies, however, met the recommendations with a string of limp objections, and did nothing.

With dozens of clubs having gone bust since then, leaving a trail of miserable creditors, football has finally faltered into introducing some regulatory measures. The FA last year responded in time-honoured fashion - by setting up a committee. It, the Financial Advisory Committee, produced a report recently, which painted a generally awful picture of club management and promised, among other initiatives such as a code of good practice for directors, to establish a "fit and proper person test" this year. The League, however, insisted it wanted to set up its own test, and its clubs agreed at their meeting at Walsall on Thursday for the basic principles (see panel) to go through to their AGM.

Sir Brian Mawhinney, the League's chairman, said: "This huge and important step shows that we are addressing poor governance in football, and the unflattering view many people have of the game."

All quite encouraging, if hardly lightning quick - and, in its detail, not as tough as it might have been. The tests apply only to directors, not shareholders, even though major shareholders pull the strings. A starker deterrent would have been to bar directors who have run any insolvent company or club, but the League has shied away from that and will be giving them a chance to do it twice.

The Geoffrey Richmond saga prompts more questions about this than it answers. Any such rule would not have applied to him. Under Richmond's stewardship, his club, Bradford City, was driven to the brink of liquidation with £36m debts in 2002, when he was still apparently a rich, talented businessman who would have swanned through any test with the relevant committee falling over themselves to welcome him into football. He was running the Ronson cigarette lighter business when he took over Scarborough in 1988, a club he steered very capably, before he took over Bradford in 1994. He sold Ronson for £10m that year, so had a conspicuously good record in business and football, the platform for him to transform Bradford inspirationally and steer the club into the Premier League in 1999 as everybody's favourite underdog.

Had they gone down, he might still be there, a hero in the city; it was only after they dramatically stayed up via David Weatherall's header to beat Liverpool 1-0 that Richmond borrowed copiously and took on fantastical players' wages during his self-confessed "six weeks of madness", in an attempt to establish Bradford in the Premier League. Bradford collapsed so spectacularly only because they were relegated, to a Football League parched of television money compared to the minted, millionaire Premiership. The administrator then revealed that Richmond and his son, David, had shared with Bradford's co-owners and directors, David and Julian Rhodes, dividends of £8.125m plus VAT in 1999 and 2000.

None of that, according to the principles agreed by the League, would have barred Richmond from becoming a director of Leeds United, rather than acting as the "unpaid advisor" to the consortium which took over the club, until he left earlier last week. The consortium, chaired by the accountant Gerald Krasner, cleared Leeds' main creditors' debts of £82m with £15m borrowed via the property developer Jack Petchey, and cobbled together £5m more to work with. However, their mooted ways to make money, from a sale and leaseback of Elland Road and 2,000 20-year season tickets at £4,000 apiece, do not look like the plan of the century so far. Leeds, staring at relegation, are still in trouble, saddled with an outsize wage bill amassed during the regime of the former chairman Peter Ridsdale, which, as he memorably admitted, "lived the dream".

Bradford, too, are a long way from safety, in administration again, and relegated to the Second Division. This Friday, unsecured creditors face another Company Voluntary Arrangement settlement proposal, in which they are being asked to completely write off their £14.4m debts from the first administration, plus £10.4m debts now - £24.8m in total. Of that, Julian and David Rhodes account for around £12m, having spent fortunes trying to shore up the club after the first administration, while Richmond left, saying he was unable to put money in. If the creditors vote in favour, Julian Rhodes will put in another £1.1m, to pay off the most recent £965,000 trading loss, the rest to the finance company Lombard, the remaining secured creditor. He believes he will then have to stump up another £2m to steady the club:

"It has been a nightmare," Rhodes, perpetually chipper, admitted this week. "These proposals give us a chance to start afresh and give the club a future."

The biggest danger is an appeal from the Inland Revenue, which has taken exception to the "football creditors" rule, whereby football debts are paid in full, and challenged CVAs at Exeter and Wimbledon. The taxman is owed over £1m at Bradford but being asked to accept nothing. Rhodes said that if the Inland Revenue appeals, Bradford will be out of business - although the club has drunk at more than one last chance saloon and staggered on.

It should give the football authorities food for thought that the issue which came back to bite Richmond this week had nothing to do with football. It originated from the very sale of Ronson 10 years ago which apparently established his fire-proof credentials. No test then could or should have picked up that Richmond had not paid the tax on the sale, but instead sought to "roll it over" into another business, and anyway Richmond contested the Inland Revenue's claim for years until he lost a High Court case last May, in which the judge ruled that he and a fellow director had not acted "in all respects honestly and reasonably". They were ordered to pay the £2.3m tax, plus interest from 1994, which now adds up to £3.3m. For a man who loved the profile of success, this is a very hard landing.

Richmond's case highlights how limited the effect of a fit and proper person test is likely to be. It is difficult to think of more than one director of any club recently who would have been barred by this test. The clubs are falling not because of rogue directors, although scrappy management is clearly a problem, but because in varying degrees they suffer "madness", or "live the dream".

The huge rewards at the top, which are monopolising Premiership titles in the hands of Arsenal or Manchester United, and the massive gap between the breakaway Premier League and the Football League, which makes relegation financially shattering, encourages directors, whoever they are, to gamble. The authorities' tiptoe towards new rules is welcome, but the fiercely unequal distribution of money in the game is the nettle they are all still too timid to grasp.

Suggested Topics
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Caption competition
Caption competition
  • Get to the point
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

Bleacher Report

Daily Quiz
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

Day In a Page

Inside the Kansas greenhouses where Monsanto is 'playing God' with the future of the planet

The future of GM

The greenhouses where Monsanto 'plays God' with the future of the planet
Britain's mild winters could be numbered: why global warming is leaving UK chillier

Britain's mild winters could be numbered

Gulf Stream is slowing down faster than ever, scientists say
Government gives £250,000 to Independent appeal

Government gives £250,000 to Independent appeal

Donation brings total raised by Homeless Veterans campaign to at least £1.25m
Oh dear, the most borrowed book at Bank of England library doesn't inspire confidence

The most borrowed book at Bank of England library? Oh dear

The book's fifth edition is used for Edexcel exams
Cowslips vs honeysuckle: The hunt for the UK’s favourite wildflower

Cowslips vs honeysuckle

It's the hunt for UK’s favourite wildflower
Child abuse scandal: Did a botched blackmail attempt by South African intelligence help Cyril Smith escape justice?

Did a botched blackmail attempt help Cyril Smith escape justice?

A fresh twist reveals the Liberal MP was targeted by the notorious South African intelligence agency Boss
Tony Blair joins a strange and exclusive club of political leaders whose careers have been blighted by the Middle East

Blair has joined a strange and exclusive club

A new tomb has just gone up in the Middle East's graveyard of US and British political reputations, says Patrick Cockburn
Election 2015: Meet the top 12 wacky candidates seeking your vote in May

Election 2015

Meet the top 12 wacky candidates seeking your vote in May
Countdown to the election: Operation Save Danny Alexander shifts into high gear as the SNP target his Commons seat

Operation Save Danny Alexander shifts into high gear

The Chief Secretary to the Treasury didn’t forget his Highland roots in the Budget. But the SNP is after his Commons seat
The US economy is under threat because of its neglected infrastructure

The US is getting frayed at the edges

Public spending on infrastructure is only half of Europe’s, and some say the nation’s very prosperity is threatened, says Rupert Cornwell
Mad Men final episodes: Museum exhibition just part of the hoopla greeting end of 1960s-set TV hit

New Yorkers raise a glass to Mad Men

A museum exhibition is just part of the hoopla greeting the final run of the 1960s-set TV hit
Land speed record: British-built hybrid rocket car aims to be the fastest on Earth

British-built hybrid rocket car aims to be the fastest on Earth

Bloodhound SSC will attempt to set a new standard in South Africa's Kalahari desert
Housebuilders go back to basics by using traditional methods and materials

Housebuilders go back to basics - throwing mud at the wall until it sticks

Traditional materials are ticking all the construction boxes: they are cheap, green – and anyone can use them
Daniel Brühl: 'When you have success abroad, you become a traitor. Envy is very German'

Daniel Brühl: 'Envy is very German'

He's got stick for his golden acting career and for his beloved restaurant - but Daniel Brühl is staying put in Berlin (where at least the grannies love him)
How Leica transformed photography for ever: Celebrating 100 years of the famous camera

Celebrating 100 years of Leica

A new book reveals how this elegant, lightweight box of tricks would transform the way we saw life on the street and in fashion, on the battlefield and across the world