Football

Showers (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 10°C / Lo 6°C

Off! The rise and rapid fall of Britain's flashiest referee

By Nick Harris

Mark Clattenburg was sacked from his job as a Premier League match official after an inquiry into his financial affairs

GETTY IMAGES

Mark Clattenburg was sacked from his job as a Premier League match official after an inquiry into his financial affairs

Mark Clattenburg was widely regarded as the brightest young talent in English football refereeing, a handsome, charismatic Geordie who soared through the ranks in record time and looked destined for fame on the greatest stages.

The 33-year-old from Gosforth, Newcastle, began officiating aged 15 as part of the Duke of Edinburgh Award scheme, and enjoyed a meteoric rise, taking charge of his first Football League match in 2000 aged just 25, a post-war record. In 2004, he was promoted to elite level in England, contracted full-time to the referees' governing body, PGMOL, on a salary of £75,000 a year, to specialise in Premier League games.

Since 2001, when professionalism was introduced, PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited) has been responsible for a pool of 78 officials who work in English professional football. Just 19 of them are salaried, paid big money to oversee games featuring star-studded clubs such as Manchester United, Arsenal, Chelsea and Liverpool, and Mr Clattenburg was among them.

In 2006, while still just 30, life got better still when he was also appointed to the refereeing roster of Fifa, football's world governing body, to take charge of prestigious international matches. He was the youngest Englishman ever elevated to that level.

But last night, Mr Clattenburg's career was in tatters after he was sacked from his job as a Premier League match official after an inquiry into his financial affairs.

He denies any wrongdoing and will appeal his dismissal, and there is no suggestion that he has been involved in any activities related to corruption within football.

But in a cautionary tale that highlights the extraordinary level of transparency required from modern referees, and the intense scrutiny of their lives, on and off the pitch, it appears that the divorced father of one took his eye off the ball when it came to his terms of employment.

Well-placed sources say he was sacked for breach of contract arising from failing to disclose in full or on time details about debts relating to businesses he ran as an electrician, his former trade.

He was initially suspended last August when his bosses received emails alleging he had secret debts of up to £175,000 and that he had sent an allegedly threatening email to a business associate. In separate, anonymous correspondence, allegations were also made about his private life.

Following a five-month investigation, during which Mr Clattenburg has consistently protested his innocence, he was called in to see the PGMOL hierarchy last week and told he was sacked.

PGMOL declined to confirm that Mr Clattenburg has also been told he will never work as a professional referee in England again but a spokesman effectively confirmed the sacking and the appeal by saying: "The disciplinary procedure is still ongoing, therefore it would be inappropriate for us to offer any further comment at this time."

High levels of transparency are required from referees in an era when match-fixing and corrupt officials have blighted leagues around the world. Most infamously in recent years, a German referee, Robert Hoyzer, was sent to prison in 2005 for his role in a match-fixing scandal in which several officials were paid by Croatian gambling syndicates to rig games in Germany.

The potential dangers of corruption in modern sport were also highlighted last year when the Central Council of Physical Recreation, the umbrella group for 270 sports governing bodies in the UK, published a report into the risks posed to the integrity of sport by corrupt betting. It said: "Referees are an obvious focus for betting rings to consider."

And while English football has never been affected by any substantiated claims of "bent" officials, at any level, Mr Clattenburg has, it seems, now fallen foul of contractual requirements put in place to help ensure no such claims will ever prove to be true.

His professional life was first thrown into turmoil in the week before the Community Shield match between Manchester United and Portsmouth, staged at Wembley on 10 August last year and scheduled to be refereed by Mr Clattenburg.

On 7 August, the allegedly threatening email sent by Mr Clattenburg to an associate was brought to the attention of PGMOL, as were details of alleged business debts, and he was suspended.

Mr Clattenburg's business interests centred on two companies. MC Electrical Services Ltd was placed in receivership last year and was subject to legal action over a claim of debts to another firm, Jarel UK, of £5,530.83. MC Electrical Retail Ltd was wound up by the official receiver with an alleged outstanding debt of more than £71,000, although Mr Clattenburg's total debts were alleged to be higher.

In August, when these claims first arose, along with claims about Mr Clattenburg's personal life, PGMOL suspended him. A PGMOL statement said: "[We] are aware of media reports concerning alleged debts incurred by companies connected to referee Mark Clattenburg. It has been decided he will not officiate any matches pending enquiries into the background to these reports.

"It is in the best interests of Mark Clattenburg and the game that these reports are fully investigated and, during that time, he will not referee any matches. Mark is one of England's leading referees and we hope to resolve this matter swiftly."

Also in August, a few hours after Mr Clattenburg had appeared at Newcastle County Court in the case related to Jarel UK debt, his £40,000 Porsche, parked outside his home, sustained thousands of pounds of damage when it was sprayed with paint.

Susan Clegg, 35, a former partner of Mr Clattenburg, was questioned by police, but in November was told she would face no action and her solicitor, Brian Hegarty, said: "Miss Clegg denied responsibility and fully co-operated with the police, informing them of her whereabouts when the offence was alleged to have occurred."

Most of Mr Clattenburg's on-field activities have been no more or less scrutinised than those of other officials. But one erratic performance – when officiating a Merseyside derby in October 2007 – led to death threats.

In the match, when Liverpool beat Everton 2-1 at Everton's ground, Mr Clattenburg sent off two Everton players, gave Liverpool a disputed penalty and turned down two penalty appeals from Everton. After the game, his life was threatened by Everton fans, some of whom also contributed to a online petition to PGMOL to have Mr Clattenburg sacked. It received more than 3,000 signatures.

Mr Clattenburg was dropped from the PGMOL rota for one round of games but it must be stressed that being dropped is not unusual for a referee after perceived errors on high-pressure occasions. And when he returned to action he was widely regarded as being on course to re-establish his reputation as his profession's golden boy.

Turbulent though Mr Clattenburg's life has been in recent years, the attention heaped upon him only reflects the exposure to abuse and pressure on top referees.

In 2004, the Swiss referee, Urs Meier, became the focus of a hate campaign – orchestrated by The Sun newspaper – by England supporters after he disallowed a goal by Sol Campbell against Portugal in the Euro 2004 quarter-finals. His personal details were published and he received thousands of abusive emails, and death threats, and was placed under police protection.

What Mr Clattenburg must now realise is that what he does away from a football pitch is scrutinised as much as what he does on it. He is understood to be indignant about losing his job, and while he was unavailable for comment yesterday, he is believed to stand by a statement he made in September, which said: "Every allegation that has been put against me, I have proved all the evidence against it. And I'll do exactly the same again. I'm innocent."

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Alan
[info]faircomments wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 08:03 am (UTC)
HE SENT OFF FERGIE, AND WAS THEREFORE SENTENCED TO BE DOOMED.
THAT'S HOW IT WORKS IN FERGIE'S MAFFIA STYLE PL!
inaccurate reporting
[info]topbalcony wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 09:43 am (UTC)
Clattenberg was not dropped from the refs panel after the derby game fiasco ,, he was on holiday.
David Moyes was however disciplined for his post match comments

you only get dropped if you upset the sky four
I'm from Missouri
[info]shanks72 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 09:57 am (UTC)
Have you proof of Everton fans threatening this person's life? If so, publish that proof or retract the allegation
[info]nick78447 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 10:30 am (UTC)
The article missed out how he sent off one of the Everton players on the insistence of Steven Gerrard. MC had a yellow card in his hand until the Liverpool captain demanded a red.

Clattenburg's performance that day was so inept, so one sided in one team's favour, that many Everton fans are not at all surprised this day has come. I would urge the Premier League to investigate this man further.
Alan
[info]faircomments wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 10:32 am (UTC)
Topbalcony, you don't get dropped if you upset Benitez, Escolari, or Wenger. Many supid fans also always threaten referees lives, it is par of the show.

But to upset and send off FERGIE is a mortal sin. To make an example of Clattenberg, Clattenberg was earmarked to referee the community shield game between "United" and Portsmouth, and to make the insult blatantly obvious, they dropped Clattenberg on the day of the match (to make headlines) due to bad business records!!!

Speaking of threatening referees' lives, various media reported that Fergie told Steve Bennet "do you really think our fans will let you walk out of here alive?" in a match against Man City 2 seasons ago, but Bennet never dared to report it.

Perhaps he was afraid to wake up with a horse's head in his bed, and perhaps that is why he has been a Fergie loyal servant since then; we all remember the final United game V Wigan last year!
Like the Italian league belonged to Moggi, Fergie owns the PL and the FA, so there is never any fair contest in the PL!
Re: Alan
[info]gordymac1999 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 01:50 pm (UTC)
Wonderful! so many scousers on here complaining about Sir Alex Ferguson! Please just accept that your teams are not up to the task of winning the Premiership and your manager is an idiot (Benitez that is). Your best opportunity for years and all you can do is complain about the United Manager.
Re: Alan
[info]topbalcony wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 05:53 pm (UTC)
styles was dropped following Benitez complaint after he gave a penalty to Chelsea at Anfield. he also had tp write a letter of apology to Rafa.
Unsurprisingly a couple of weeks later a fearful Clattenberg produced the refferring display that gave Liverpool the 2 1 win at Goodison mentioned above
[info]judierudie wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 12:49 pm (UTC)
The first paragraph is absolutely laughable. I take it you've never laid eyes on Clattenburg or listened to him speak or watched him officiate?
Good riddance
[info]bugsyb6 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 01:55 pm (UTC)
As someone who has refereed I am fully aware of the pressures referees are unduly put under. The pressures for those in the top flight doesn't bear thinking about. Things are not helped by the fact that losing managers have a microphone shoved beneath their noses after a game and are encouraged to whinge about decisions made out in the middle. Referees do not get a chance to put their case forward.
HOWEVER, as an Evertonian I watched Mark Clattenberg's game against Liverpool and thought it looked decidedly dubious...think after the game David Moyes made a point about Clattenburg being on a trip to Thailand at the same time as the Liverpool team....!!
Also seem to remember a very odd performance from the 'great' Collina when Everton went out to Villa Real in the Champions League a few years ago. He was also hastily 'retired' from the referees panel shortly afterwards.
We haven't had much in the way of luck over the years which makes Benitez's moans all the more annoying. Seem to remember Everton being denied two appearances in the European Cup because of Liverpool and the post-Heysel ban.

As you can imagine I am enjoying the self-destruction of Rafa and look forward to the summer fire sale of Liverpool's stars to pay back a loan to RBS. Happy days!!
RE: ALAN
[info]mg58 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 02:40 pm (UTC)
Phew, why don't you start legal proceedings against Sir Alex then since it's apparent that you have "evidence" that suggests Sir Alex has bought his trophies?

What a load of rubbish. If it were remotely true, Manchester Utd would have won every single decision, every game and every trophy under Sir Alex's twenty two years of management. The fact that, that has not happened means that he really is as good as you would hate him to be. Get over yourself. I wonder where your loyalties lie? In any case I would like to comment on your senile conclusions as follows:
(to the tune of three lions then: )
He's cracking up, he's cracking, Alan's cracking up (repeat to your hearts content)

Or is it that everything seems to be "crazy," now that the excuses have dried up?

Go figure and take a holiday to clear your head whilst your at it
I AM NOT A LIVERPOOL FAN!
[info]faircomments wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 03:02 pm (UTC)
gordymac1999;

My friend, I am NOT a Liverpool fan, and don't even like Benitez, so you can park the usual bad-style banter that everyone is used to from United fans; after all, their thug manager shows them the way!

I am NOT English, I support Barcelona, and all good and fair football. I love the English game, but have been turned off watching it, not because of the football, but because of how unfairly it favours Man United. Also fed up with Rooney always acting like a thug, and Ronaldo like a little spoiled teenager on the pitch, and always getting away with it!

In Spain Madrid and Barcelona enjoy a lot of the support from the system, Italy is worst; one had hoped that the great PL would not be the same, but nowadays it looks WORSE!
Clatt the incompetent
[info]hibbs78 wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 03:52 pm (UTC)
Any Forest fans that witnessed his (mis)handling of the playoff second leg against Sheffield Utd back in the day will also fail to be surprised. I was gobsmacked when he was appointed to the premier league in the first place.
How much brain is there in a United fan?
[info]faircomments wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 04:10 pm (UTC)
bugsyb6;

Please go back to kinder gardedn please; talking to little kids or the mentally disturbed is not on agenda for me today!
Re: How much brain is there in a United fan?
[info]kerrygold wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 04:32 pm (UTC)
Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned!
Oh dear
[info]oldskald wrote:
Thursday, 29 January 2009 at 07:21 pm (UTC)
And there was me expecting a serious debate about refereeing standards and probity, and the pressures and pitfalls of the trade, with perhaps some comments on technology. But no! Big 4 rears its ugly, self-important, triumphalist voice again (we all know the Premier League is a stitch up job and has been since it started. NO-one is fooled - deluded, maybe...). Keep it in the playground, and let the adults talk...
Hooray
[info]keffs wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 12:53 am (UTC)
I am so pleased.

The article failed to mention the waist high tackle by Kyut, on Neville, towards the end of the game. Nor Kyut's punishment.

A good day fro football.
Corruption
[info]creevy1 wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 01:24 am (UTC)
In 45 years of watching professional footaball I have never witness such an inept and franky, corrupt performance as the Merseyside Derby in which this official sent 2 Everton players off, turned down at least 2 Everton penalty appeals, gave a dubious penalty to the away side and took counsel off the away captain about which card to award, please FA investigate this matter

Andy Creevy
Bias
[info]zico_666 wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 10:27 am (UTC)
Today is a day to celebrate. The most openly biased referee has been sacked. His display in the Merseyside derby was an absolute disgrace. He is obviously a LFC fan and not objective in his decision making. He is another referee that all Everton fans, like myself, will never forgive. Good riddance to bad rubbish. By the way, I never heard anything about death threats from Everton fans, but I did know about the online petition. What comes around goes around. I will sleep easier tonight knowing Clattenburg will never referee Everton again :o)
Refferee Mark Clattenburgs sacking
[info]mackey013 wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 11:58 am (UTC)
As an Evertonian I regard Clattenburgs sacking as "closure".
His performance on that day back in October 2007 in the Merseyside Darby was nothing short of corrupt.
And as an additional note, reference Gerrard?s actions that day - now you know why the Blue half of Merseyside dislike this individual so intently.
Kuyt should have gone too
[info]tedsager wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 12:45 pm (UTC)
The report about his disgraceful performance in the derby failed to mention that Kuyt should have been sent off. He nearly took Neville's knee off and got a yellow. Who scored the winner? Kuyt. And the penalties, you don't get more blantant. MOTD described one as 'assault'. That was the one by that dirty get, Carra, who's losing his pace. For both, Lescott got hauled down in the box, literally dragged down. Afterwards Rafa said he dived. Typical red, full of s***.

Delighted to read this report, delighted he got sacked, deserved. As people have said, they should investigate the derby performance. I know refs are generally very poor, but that performance defied belief.
Re: Kuyt should have gone too
[info]pb2 wrote:
Friday, 30 January 2009 at 05:20 pm (UTC)
good bye and please don't come back., I have never ever seen such a suspect refereeing performance as Clattenburgs in the merseyside derby, it was so suspect even the most ardent kopites were embarrassed.
yah man!
[info]tazzm3 wrote:
Thursday, 19 February 2009 at 04:54 pm (UTC)
dont mess with fergie and the mafia crew, u go down if u say or do anything against the owner of the premier league. i think the Man U CEo should be taken off the board for the disrespect to end.

john
GHANA
chelsea FC

Free gym pass

Get fit for summer with Fitness First gyms in London

Download a free gym pass from Fitness First today