Sam Wallace: Benitez the master conjurer cannot hide fault lines that threaten Anfield's future
If Liverpool win the league, it will be an astonishing act of management from Benitez
Latest in News & Comment
140 Sport blogs
Via the World: Welcome to the ocean
The sun is setting on my fifteenth day at sea. Pale pinks and oranges paint the western sky and gent...
iBet: Serena Williams looks hungry again
Serena Williams has looked right back to her best in recent weeks and more importantly she looks hun...
Manchester City top the ‘injury league’, with Manchester United bottom
The results of new research into every significant injury suffered by every Premier League footballe...
Related articles
A week ago today, Steven Gerrard took the plunge and said, for the second consecutive summer, he wanted Gareth Barry to join Liverpool. Within 24 hours his fellow England midfielder was having a medical at Manchester City.
Then in Kazakhstan, even Gerrard could not escape the tyranny of the international news channels and their tickers of doom that delivered Liverpool's latest dismal financial results on Friday. Net losses of £86m for the club alone, interest payments of £36.5m a year and a warning from the auditors about the viability of Liverpool's parent company.
And so it goes for a week in the life of Liverpool football club. But not just any week, a week which should have been the start of a momentous summer in which Rafael Benitez made the changes to a squad that took him so close to the Premier League title last time around. This summer, of all summers, was supposed to be different.
Since Liverpool began their quest to win back the title, which started after they lost it to Arsenal in 1991, around about the time the Warsaw Pact was abandoned, they have approached each new season with optimism. Some summers, like 1993 or 1998, it has turned out to be badly misplaced. In others it has felt more realistic but rarely has there been as much reason to hope as this summer, albeit with so little evidence that the club's ownership can deliver it.
Where will the money come from? Liverpool's owners Tom Hicks and George Gillett might be able to offer Benitez £20m for transfers from one of their Caribbean-based holding companies. That hardly sounds like a club in the kind of state to do battle for the likes of Barry and Carlos Tevez, a club reliant upon the £350m refinancing deal being ratified by 24 July.
And what until then? Does Benitez simply cross his fingers and hope that the rest of world football will dawdle on the beach or lounge by the pool while Liverpool's owners get themselves organised? No, unfortunately for Anfield, the players that Benitez wants to acquire, their agents and their selling clubs – like David Silva at Valencia – will get on with it. With or without Liverpool.
As Liverpool's owners stumble on, so Benitez's achievement in making Liverpool the second strongest team in the country becomes ever more the great conjuring act. Benitez can do some odd things: that rant at Sir Alex Ferguson last season or his Soviet-style purge of the club's long-serving academy staff. But somehow, amid the financial wreckage, he has also built a team that can beat Real Madrid and Manchester United.
Buried in those accounts was another blow for Liverpool, the revelation that any move to a new stadium would be 2012 at the earliest. Like those occasional burnt-out Victorian houses in the terraced streets between Anfield and Walton Breck roads, the new Liverpool stadium is a building job, with all its attendant delays, that is starting to become a local embarrassment.
The new Anfield is the bedrock of the only plan that will give Liverpool parity with the finances of their fellow Big Four. United earn £101.5m annually from their matchday operations alone, Arsenal £94.6m and Chelsea £74.5m, the latter despite significantly lower average attendances than Liverpool. At Anfield the annual earnings from matchdays are £39.2m. You do not need to be a chartered accountant to spot the discrepancy in wealth.
Even Tottenham are ahead of Liverpool on that one, chasing the lucrative naming rights market with computer-generated images of their new White Hart Lane stadium emblazoned with "naming rights" on the roof and above the door. Liverpool have not just failed to get a new stadium off the ground, they have spent £10.3m on obsolete architects' plans that will never even see the light of day.
Hicks might dismiss the fears over Liverpool's refinancing with the usual unyielding optimism, but what, for instance, would it cost for the club to be sold? The combined debt of the parent company Kop Football Limited at the end of the financial year 2007-08 was, The Independent revealed on Saturday, £421.6m. Presumably, Hicks and Gillett would, at the very least, wish to be seen right for that amount.
That immediately places Liverpool at a premium. Especially when much richer men have spent much less on football clubs. A cost of £421m would be roughly 73 percent of the £576.9m Roman Abramovich has spent so far on Chelsea. But he bought that club in 2003 for £140m, debts and all. Manchester City were also much cheaper, they cost, with their liabilities included, around £210m to Sheikh Mansour last year.
So Liverpool is a club its owners can barely afford to own, let alone run. It has a stadium badly in need of replacing, a financial structure that cannot move forward until it is and a manager is expected to make the best of it all. If Liverpool win the Premier League next season without any radical change to this status quo it will be an astonishing act of management by Benitez.
Two seasons ago, Benitez turned up for pre-season with a goatee beard which belied his straight-laced image. If he shows up on Liverpool's summer tour next month with a henna tattoo and a straggly ponytail, just put it down to the stresses of the job. In the space of one week in June, Liverpool's hierarchy have demonstrated that winning the league involves a much greater challenge than just finishing ahead of United, Chelsea and Arsenal.
FA's attempt to get matey fails in Almaty
The Football Association was not helped by its alliance with the Kazakhstan police when based in Almaty last week. Black-shirted and unsmiling, the local constabulary even banned locals from walking on the pavement alongside the wall which ran around the perimeter of the city's Dinamo stadium where the England squad were training on Thursday.
The FA deserves credit for getting some local schoolchildren in, but for the hundreds outside standing on their car roofs to get a glimpse, or simply inconvenienced on their way home from work, it did not look so good. The plan when the 2018 World Cup bid was launched last month was simply to try to charm the world into giving England the tournament. Trouble is, everywhere the England team go, security is such a major issue.
Clubs' wrong tones
It is a long-held belief that clubs selling mobile phone ringtones of their supporters' favourite chants is the ultimate in corporate exploitation. So let's get this right. The fans devise the chants, they choose the tunes and they popularise them. Or, as the corporate men would say: design, marketing and PR all rolled into one. Then the club sells the chants back to them as ringtones for a profit. Please just say no to official club ringtones.
Rod would be wonderful for West Ham
Any visitor to Upton Park will have heard the locals sing the song 'East London is wonderful' followed by something unmentionable, something else unmentionable, 'and West Ham'. So here's hoping that the Hammers are going to sign the man who is reported to be their latest transfer target. Step forward Rennes' £5m-rated defender Rod Fanni.
- 1 Serena struck down by brave Razzano and umpire furore
- 2 Olympians: They're fit and don't we just know it
- 3 Brendan Rodgers 'agrees deal to become Liverpool manager'
- 4 Euro 2012 files: Notable absentees
- 5 Hodgson urges squad to attempt to 'enjoy' Euros
- 6 Club-by-club guide: Players available on a free transfer this summer
- 7 Marathon men: Are Spain running out of puff?
- 8 Sports caption competition winners
- 9 Brendan Rodgers veers towards taking Liverpool job
- 10 United close in on Kagawa after missing out on Hazard
- 1 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 2 Mark Steel: There was no deal between Blair and Murdoch. Only a conspiracy theorist would suggest that. Obviously.
- 3 Anger over Christine Lagarde's tax-free salary
- 4 Sex in dressing rooms and Play School presenters 'stoned out of their minds' - inside BBC Television Centre
- 5 'Cuddle drug' may be the new Viagra
- 6 'Hello mum, this is going to be hard for you to read ...'
- 7 Image released of naked cannibal killed by Miami police as he ate homeless man's face
- 8 Israel hints it may be behind 'Flame' super-virus targeting Iran
- 9 Coke reveals its secret: It may need to carry a cancer warning
- 10 French in uproar over oral sex anti-smoking posters
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
Can you imagine a career in teaching?
Be inspired to teach - let real teachers show you how rewarding the job can be.
A home to be proud of with Halifax
Download the Halifax's brilliant, free new Home Finder app, and take all the pain out of finding your dream home
Playing a game-changing role during the Games
Cisco is providing the solutions for London 2012's complex IT needs.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
David Rodigan on an MBE for reggae
Is doctors' fixation on treatment making us ill?
The most complained-about advertisements of all time
Olympians: They're fit and don't we just know it
Get ready for a royal good time





Comments