Sign up to Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter sent straight to your inbox for free Sign up to Miguel’s Delaney’s free weekly newsletter
Jamie Carragher has been forced to admit he was wrong about Paul Pogba as the Manchester United star continued his resurgence under Ole Gunnar Solskjaer.
The Frenchman was once again outstanding making one goal and scoring another as United knocked holders Chelsea out of the FA Cup with an impressive display at Stamford Bridge.
Pogba has returned to form following the sacking of Jose Mourinho in December forcing a number of onlookers, including Carragher, to rethink their position.
“I don’t know if he’s worth the hassle for what he gives on the pitch. And there’s an idea that it’s one or the other. If Mourinho goes you won’t see a new Pogba, I can assure Manchester United fans of that,” Carragher told Sky Sports back in September.
“He’s not as a good as he thinks he is. He’s got talent but his big problem is his understanding of the game. It’s been a problem since he arrived and it hasn’t changed now.”
Show all 22 1 /22Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Kepa 4 Not sharp enough given he cost £71million. Sluggish and slow on both headed goals he conceded, and not exactly assured with his feet either. Although he could reasonably enough blame the defence in front of him.
Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Azpilicueta 6 Characteristic commitment, but defending in this team is far from easy. Looks frustrated by his inability to cover for his team-mates. Unable to break through going forward.
REUTERS
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Rudiger 5 He is a good athlete but is he good enough to make up for the fact he plays in a back four with Marcos Alonso and David Luiz? Looked lost at times here as United players ran at him.
Action Images via Reuters
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Luiz 3 How long can Chelsea survive with someone so defensively casual? Sarri’s football plays to his strengths but it also exposes his faults, his laxness in stopping the cross for the second a case in point.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Alonso 4 Could only stand and watch as Herrera ran past him to head in United’s opening goal, and miles away for the second. Not doing enough either defensively or going forward to make a positive contribution to this team right now.
PA
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Kante 6 Worked hard at his aggressive role but surely he would have been better in a position where he could have stifled United’s counter attacks. Looks like the right answer to the wrong question in a wide area.
AP
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Jorginho 5 Clearly a clever player but he cannot control these games up against physical, driven opposition. Plenty of passing but none of it incisive, with United able to raise the tempo away from him whenever they chose.
Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Kovacic 5 Tidy enough in possession but never looks like turning that into chances or goals, as Chelsea looked as blunt as ever. His substitution was booed by the fans because he not replaced by Callum Hudson Odoi.
PA
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Pedro 5 He is not the reason why Chelsea lost but he also struggled to make an impact and was the first man to get hooked as Sarri chased improvement, off for Willian before the hour mark.
REUTERS
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Hazard 6 Always on the move, buzzing around with the ball, trying to provoke something. But it was a largely frustrating evening because of Chelsea’s defensive struggles, and he never really looked like scoring.
REUTERS
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Higuain 5 Some clever moves, and missed one headed chance, but he still looks too slow for English football. Being caught up by Luke Shaw when through on goal is a case in point. Might have been a good signing a few years ago.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Romero 6 Made a double save early on when the game was still in the balance. If Chelsea had taken the lead it would have been very different. After that had a very quiet evening. Will hope to play in the quarter-final.
AP
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Young 6 United’s experienced captain, he directed his team-mates through the game. Too old to play as a winger now but is a sturdy right-back and put in some hefty tackles here when he had to.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Smalling 7 Imposed himself on the Chelsea front line, playing with the assurance that is typical of his improvement this season. United need his leadership and organisation at the back.
AP
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Lindelof 6 Was never tested too much by Gonzalo Higuain but he did stand up to Eden Hazard when he had to, as well as using the ball cleverly and calmly.
AP
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Shaw 6 Continued his steady progress with a strong performance at left-back. Did not get to attack too much but defended well.
Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Matic 6 Provided a solid base in midfield but after an early booking he was lucky to stay on the pitch after he tripped Ngolo Kante in the second half. Still looking much better than he did under Mourinho.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Herrera 7 Did his usual job scurrying around, shouting and tackling, but also scored that fantastic opener, anticipating and charging forward to head in Pogba’s cross, leaving the whole Chelsea defence out of place.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Pogba 9 After the disappointment of midweek, he responded here in the perfect way. First he delivered an assist of remarkable patience and precision for Herrera from the left and then he scored a brilliant Ronaldo-esque header just before the break, from a move he started. Another complete peformance.
Action Images via Reuters
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Rashford 8 Had to be patient in the first half but worked so well for the second goal, chasing the ball down and firing in a sharp cross for Pogba to head in, catching the Chelsea defence unawares. Never let Chelsea relax with his running.
Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Lukaku 6 Probably not in the strongest United team but he was at least a handful here, asking questions with his movement, even if he is lacking confidence in the box.
AFP/Getty Images
Player ratings: Chelsea vs Manchester United Mata 8 Back in his favoured no10 role, he was always lively looking for space, and it was not too hard to find it around Jorginho. Helped United to keep the ball and see out the win.
REUTERS
When his comments were put back to him on Twitter following Monday night’s game Carragher was quick to praise Pogba’s performances.
“Well I hope you completely disagreed at the time & not just now?!!,” he said. “He’s been a revelation since OGS came in because he’s basically let him play without defending.
“I didn’t see this turn around so I have no problem saying I was wrong.”
Solskjaer was impressed with what he saw from Pogba and was pleased with how he responded after the Champions League defeat to PSG last week, a game which saw him sent off late on.
“He had a tough game against PSG but he was probably our best player then,” Solskjaer said afterwards. “He had two or three players around him all the time.
“Tonight [Monday] was a great response, playing against one of the best defensive midfielders in the world with [N’Golo] Kante next to him.
Pogba scored and assisted in Manchester United’s 2-0 win at Chelsea (Getty) “We know he’s one of the best attacking midfielders in the world. He has vision, so the cross for Ander’s goal was fantastic.
“Then the way he plays the ball out to Marcus [Rashford] and gets into the box for the second was fantastic, too.”
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies