Jamie Carragher thinks Liverpool did not do enough to prevent Steven Gerrard's "surprise" exit from Anfield.
Gerrard announced on Friday that his 17-year spell at Liverpool will come to an end in the summer when his contract expires.
The 34-year-old is expected to see out the rest of his playing career in the United States and he then has ambitions of returning to the Merseyside club in some capacity.
Carragher admits Gerrard's best playing days are behind him, but feels the club should have made every effort to keep their captain because of his experience.
The Anfield club offered Gerrard a new contract, but Carragher, who played alongside the midfielder in the Liverpool first team for 15 years, thinks they should have pulled out all the stops to keep him on Merseyside.
"From the club's point of view, I am surprised," the former Liverpool captain told Sky Sports News.
"It was Stevie's decision, but could the club have maybe done a little bit more? Maybe spoken about a coaching role in the future to try to entice him to stay?
"You are not losing Steven Gerrard of 24 or 25 years of age. He's not the same player at 34. No player is at that age, but I just think to lose that experience at the club, which he can pass on to the youngsters at the Academy and players in the first team now...
"I just look at that and think from a club's point of view and a supporter's point of view I would have liked to have seen him stay in some capacity."
Gerard Houllier has little doubt Gerrard will one day become Liverpool manager, but Carragher thinks the former England captain will not be offered the position in the future unless the club are certain he will do a good job.
"He's got the name and the profile to do it," the ex-Liverpool defender said.
"If Steven Gerrard wanted to be a manager and was up to the job then of course you would love to see him in that dugout because of what he represents for the club.
"But Liverpool Football Club shouldn't be about giving people jobs just because of what they have done as players."
Graeme Souness achieved something Gerrard failed to do during his playing time at Liverpool - win the league title.
In fact, he did it five times, and also won the European Cup on three occasions.
The Scot failed to repeat that success during a three-year spell as manager though and he thinks Gerrard may not necessarily go into the role due to the stresses and strains of the profession.
"It's not just Steven, but I think players of his level might not have the desire to go into football management simply because it's riddled with insecurity," Souness said.
"It's a very, very hard job to do and someone who's only played at the highest level, been an outstanding player, I'm not sure if he wants the aggravation of management."
Opinion may be split on Gerrard's future, but there was almost universal acceptance that the midfielder deserves to be regarded as one of the club's finest players.
Gerrard may have failed to win the league, but he played a huge part in Liverpool's dramatic Champions League final victory against AC Milan in 2005 and against West Ham in the FA Cup final 12 months later.
Kirkby-born Phil Thompson believes Kenny Dalglish, with whom he played during the 1970s and 1980s, should be regarded as the only better player to have worn the famous red Liverpool shirt.
"Steven is the last of a dying breed for my football club. That will be a massive hole to fill," the former Liverpool defender and assistant manager said.
"Steven has won plenty of trophies. He hasn't won the Premier League but he is the next best to Kenny Dalglish and that is still a great accolade."
Liverpool's current squad showered praise on Gerrard after Friday's announcement.
Striker Daniel Sturridge told Liverpool's website: "He will go down in history as one of the best midfielders in the game. He's just unbelievable every day, a great leader and the perfect example for every young player around the country."
Who could replace Steven Gerrard?
Who could replace Steven Gerrard?
1/5 Ross Barkley
It is unthinkable that Barkley could quit Everton and move across Stanley Park to the Toffees' arch-rivals, and the Blues would certainly never consider selling him to them. Such a scenario probably belongs in the realms of fantasy but, nevertheless, Barkley would actually be a fine replacement for Gerrard. Since breaking into the Everton team and earning England recognition, the 21-year-old has shown he has the potential to reach the top. He is possibly the best English box-to-box midfielder to emerge since Gerrard.
2/5 Paul Pogba
Also possibly unrealistic given that the Frenchman is rated in the £50million bracket and Liverpool - despite receiving such fees for players - have never seriously threatened to pay at that level. Since leaving Manchester United for Juventus, the 21-year-old has established himself as one of the best young midfielders in Europe. He is often linked with a return to England, but usually with the likes of United or Chelsea.
3/5 Morgan Schneiderlin
It is certainly not inconceivable Liverpool could attempt to raid Southampton again, however. After taking Adam Lallana, Dejan Lovren and Rickie Lambert last summer, the Reds could look at the highly-rated 25-year-old Schneiderlin. The Frenchman looks to have settled after threatening to leave in the summer but an offer from Liverpool could be tempting.
4/5 Fabian Delph
It might not be a signing to excite, but Delph's contract at Aston Villa is coming to an end and, with his future uncertain, he would be an easily attainable option. The former Leeds player, 25, has improved greatly over the last 18 months and is now in the England reckoning.
5/5 Henrikh Mkhitaryan
Liverpool made serious attempts to sign the Armenian in the summer of 2013 but ultimately lost out to Borussia Dortmund. Since then the 25-year-old's star has fallen slightly with Dortmund struggling in the Bundesliga. If he were to become available again, Rodgers could revive his interest.
Lifelong Liverpool fan Rickie Lambert added: "He is Mr Liverpool.
"He's number one for me and I think he always will be. He has meant everything to me, growing up as a Liverpool fan.
"The nights he has given Liverpool fans are unbelievable - I'll never forget them and I know the Liverpool fans will never forget them."
Mario Balotelli paid tribute to Gerrard, likening him to his World Cup winning Italy team-mate Andrea Pirlo.
"Wow. I think of him as being at the same level as Pirlo," the Reds striker added.
"Vision, technique but he is powerful as well.
"Stevie can do anything, he's an amazing player. It's going to be very difficult for the team to find another player like him in the future."
- More about:
- Liverpool FC