There is no foolproof recipe for the perfect Premier League manager

The Weekend Dossier: Those who had to work at their game are more able to coach than naturals

As Ellis Short sifts through the CVs of those managers in contention to replace Paolo Di Canio he will be painfully aware that appointing a new boss is an inexact science. This is his fourth attempt and, if handing Di Canio a long-term deal always seemed high-risk, his previous two choices were sensible ones. Steve Bruce and Martin O’Neill had both compiled a decent body of work at a variety of clubs. Bruce’s subsequent success at Hull City only serves to confirm he was a logical choice, even if it did not work out for him at the Stadium of Light.

If Short sought enlightenment from studying the selections of his fellow owners, he will have finished the exercise more confused than ever. The one thing the managers of the other 19 Premier League clubs have in common is that none is in his first job, but that is hardly surprising given the demands of managing a modern top-flight club.

There are few other patterns. Some, like Steve Clarke and Chris Hughton, began as assistant managers or coaches and, having served their apprenticeship, moved into the decision-making seat. Several have done it the traditional way, working their way up from small clubs step by step. Paul Lambert (Livingston-Wycombe-Colchester-Norwich-Aston Villa) is the classic example though David Moyes (Preston), Ian Holloway (Bristol Rovers) and Sam Allardyce (Limerick) are among others to have begun at moderate stations. The bosses from abroad have mostly followed similar career paths.

The clear exception is Mark Hughes, who began his management career in the international arena, with Wales. Hughes is unusual in another, more surprising sense. He had a stellar playing career. This is relatively rare among top managers. Of the Premier League bosses just under half were internationals and only three played in a World Cup finals: Lambert, Mauricio Pochettino and Michael Laudrup. Lambert and Laudrup are the only two to have played in a Champions League or European Cup final, with Borussia Dortmund and Barcelona respectively.

The two men to have managed in the Champions League final, by contrast, would never have got anywhere near it in their playing days. Arsène Wenger had a moderate career in France while Jose Mourinho played a handful of games in the Portuguese second division. His opponent today, Andre Villas-Boas, did not play professionally at all while a knee injury meant Brendan Rodgers’ professional career was over almost before it had begun. Indeed, with Roberto Martinez and David Moyes spending most of their time in England’s lower divisions, of the current managers of the clubs who made up the top seven last season only one, Chilean international Manuel Pellegrini, could be said to have had a significant playing career.

What most of these men have in common is an acceptance at an early age that they would not make the highest level as a player, and a subsequent interest in coaching. That gave them an advantage over those of their peers who only considered management as their playing days neared the end. Rodgers and Villas-Boas were coaching in their early twenties. Moyes played until his mid-thirties, but took his first qualifications at 22. So intent was Moyes on learning his new trade he later took the Uefa Pro licence in both England and Scotland. Man-management may be, as Neil Warnock argues elsewhere in these pages, more important than badges but an interest in coach education – which nowadays includes psychological aspects as well as tactical and technical ones – marks out many of the successful managers.

Of course, there have been excellent players who make outstanding managers – Pep Guardiola, Fabio Capello, Roberto Mancini and Carlo Ancelotti come to mind. Finding British equivalents is, however, not easy. The last great player from these shores to have won the title as a manager was Kenny Dalglish in 1995, before him Dave Mackay in 1975. In the intervening years George Graham, Brian Clough, Bob Paisley and Howard Kendall won titles but, like Alex Ferguson, they were good rather than great players.

There is an argument that those players who had to work at their game to realise their ability are more likely to be able to coach others than those to whom it came naturally. Possessing knowledge is one thing, being able to impart it is another entirely and it is notable that several teachers became successful managers – such as Rinus Michels, Howard Wilkinson, Andy Roxburgh and Craig Brown.

Tommy Mooney, the former Watford striker now working as an academy coach at Aston Villa, has been attending an FA Advanced Youth Award at St George’s Park. He reflected: “With the way I played football for 20 years, you don’t think of the way young players learn, you just got on with it and as long as you scored your goals on a Saturday afternoon you were happy. This [course] is an eye-opener for me and I’m sure for a lot of the other ex-pros.”

It may be telling that most of the managers whose playing experience is limited employ as coaches men who achieved greater distinction on the pitch. Ex-internationals Boro Primorac and Steve Bould assist Wenger, Wales striker Colin Pascoe works with Rodgers and, most obviously, alongside Villas-Boas is former German midfielder Steffen Freund. Conversely, ex-Dutch international Martin Jol works with career coach Michael Lindeman.

Uruguayan international Gus Poyet is in the frame for Sunderland but Short is wise not to rush the decision. He needs to look beyond the glittering career, beyond even Poyet’s achievements at (and bitter departure from) Brighton, and treat this appointment as he would have an executive position at Lone Star Funds, the equity company Short ran. Then he just has to sit back in his executive seat and hope, and pray, this time he guessed right.

Premier managers: International caps

Manager   Caps

Arsenal  Arsène Wenger -  

Aston Villa  Paul Lambert 40    

Cardiff City Malky Mackay     5

Chelsea       Jose Mourinho      -

C Palace      Ian Holloway         -

Everton       Roberto Martinez -

Fulham        Martin Jol               3

Hull City       Steve Bruce          -

Liverpool     Brendan Rodgers -

Man City      Manuel Pellegrini  28

Man Utd       David Moyes        -

Newcastle    Alan Pardew         -

Norwich        Chris Hughton      53

Southampton Mauricio Pochettino 20

Stoke City     Mark Hughes       72

Swansea       Michael Laudrup 104

Tottenham   Andre Villas-Boas -

West Brom   Steve Clarke        6

West Ham    Sam Allardyce      -

* Sunderland are without a manager

News
Young Winstone: His ‘tough-guy’ image is a misconception
people
Sport
Adnan Januzaj and Gareth Bale
footballManchester United set to loan out Januzaj to make room for Bale - if a move for the Welshman firms up
Arts and Entertainment
Ellie Levenson’s The Election book demystifies politics for children
bookNew children's book primes the next generation for politics
News
Outspoken: Alexander Fury, John Rentoul, Ellen E Jones and Katy Guest
newsFrom the Scottish referendum to the Ice Bucket Challenge, our writers voice their opinions
PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Arts and Entertainment
Lena Headey as Cersei Lannister in Game of Thrones
film
News
i100
Sport
Yaya Sanogo, Mats Hummels, Troy Deeney and Adnan Januzaj
footballMost Premier League sides are after a striker, but here's a full run down of the ins and outs that could happen over the next month
News
Nigel Farage celebrates with a pint after early local election results in the Hoy and Helmet pub in South Benfleet in Essex
peopleHe has shaped British politics 'for good or ill'
Sport
Tim Sherwood raises his hand after the 1-0 victory over Stoke
footballFormer Tottenham boss leads list of candidates to replace Neil Warnock
Voices
Strictly Come Dancing was watched by 6.9m viewers
voicesIt has been hard to form generally accepted cultural standards since the middle of the 19th century – and the disintegration is only going to accelerate, says DJ Taylor
Arts and Entertainment
Roffey says: 'All of us carry shame and taboo around about our sexuality. But I was determined not to let shame stop me writing my memoir.'
books
News
Danielle George is both science professor and presenter
people
News
i100
News
Caplan says of Jacobs: 'She is a very collaborative director, and gives actors a lot of freedom. She makes things happen.'
people
Caption competition
Caption competition
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

Bleacher Report

Daily Quiz
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

Day In a Page

War with Isis: The West needs more than a White Knight

The West needs more than a White Knight

Despite billions spent on weapons, the US has not been able to counter Isis's gruesome tactics, says Patrick Cockburn
Return to Helmand: Private Davey Graham recalls the day he was shot by the Taliban

'The day I was shot by the Taliban'

Private Davey Graham was shot five times during an ambush in 2007 - it was the first, controversial photograph to show the dangers our soldiers faced in Helmand province
Revealed: the best and worst airlines for delays

Revealed: the best and worst airlines for delays

Many flyers are failing to claim compensation to which they are entitled, a new survey has found
The stories that defined 2014: From the Scottish independence referendum to the Ice Bucket Challenge, our writers voice their opinions

The stories that defined 2014

From the Scottish independence referendum to the Ice Bucket Challenge, our writers voice their opinions
Stoke-on-Trent becomes first British city to be classified as 'disaster resilient' by the United Nations

Disaster looming? Now you know where to head...

Which British city has become the first to be awarded special 'resilience' status by the UN?
Finally, a diet that works: Californian pastor's wildly popular Daniel Plan has seen his congregation greatly reduced

Finally, a diet that works

Californian pastor's wildly popular Daniel Plan has seen his congregation greatly reduced
Say it with... lyrics: The power of song was never greater, according to our internet searches

Say it with... lyrics

The power of song was never greater, according to our internet searches
Professor Danielle George: On a mission to bring back the art of 'thinkering'

The joys of 'thinkering'

Professor Danielle George on why we have to nurture tomorrow's scientists today
Monique Roffey: The author on father figures, the nation's narcissism and New Year reflections

Monique Roffey interview

The author on father figures, the nation's narcissism and New Year reflections
Introducing my anti-heroes of 2014

Introducing my anti-heroes of 2014

Their outrageousness and originality makes the world a bit more interesting, says Ellen E Jones
DJ Taylor: Good taste? It's all a matter of timing...

Good taste? It's all a matter of timing...

It has been hard to form generally accepted cultural standards since the middle of the 19th century – and the disintegration is only going to accelerate, says DJ Taylor
Olivia Jacobs & Ben Caplan: 'Ben thought the play was called 'Christian Love'. It was 'Christie in Love' - about a necrophiliac serial killer'

How we met

Olivia Jacobs and Ben Caplan
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef's breakfasts will revitalise you in time for the New Year

Bill Granger's healthy breakfasts

Our chef's healthy recipes are perfect if you've overindulged during the festive season
Transfer guide: From Arsenal to West Ham - what does your club need in the January transfer window?

Who does your club need in the transfer window?

Most Premier League sides are after a striker, but here's a full run down of the ins and outs that could happen over the next month
The Last Word: From aliens at FA to yak’s milk in the Tour, here’s to 2015

Michael Calvin's Last Word

From aliens at FA to yak’s milk in the Tour, here’s to 2015