Five things we learnt from the weekend's Four Nations
England impressed, says Dave Hadfield, and Sam Tomkins sparkled, but there is probably more to come from Australia...
Dave Hadfield was a schoolboy convert to rugby league, the game which, one way or another, has dominated his life ever since. After working for newspapers in Shropshire and Blackpool (where he covered the fortunes of Blackpool Borough) he travelled the world, working mainly in Hong Kong and Sydney. He became The Independent's rugby league man in 1990 and has written five books on the game and broadcast extensively for Sky and the BBC. Dave played his last game at the age of 53 and would have set up a try if anyone could have been bothered supporting his break. When not writing about the sport, he now limits himself to a bit of tick and pass with his local club, the Bolton Mets. Family includes supporters - of varying degrees of dedication - of Salford, Wigan, Sheffield Eagles and St George Illawarra.
Tuesday 08 November 2011
1 Sam Tomkins is a genuinely world-class player and rugby league could not have afforded to lose him
Even in defeat at Wembley, the Wigan full-back was the most skilful and exciting player on the pitch. His two backhanded flick-passes which led to England tries were exquisite. His broken-field running often had the Aussies in a panic and his defence was strong – which couldn't always be said of everyone in front of him.
Rugby league produces such good players that some of them are bound to be lured by a wealthier code. Most of the losses, like Chris Ashton, Kyle Eastmond, and Sam's brother, Joel, it can cope with. To lose Sam Tomkins, however, would have been the most depressing development since the free gangway made such moves inevitable.
2 It is worth taking big matches to Wembley after all
The calculated gamble on getting enough of a crowd to make the stadium look and feel OK was justified by a 42,000 attendance.
The quality of the games – Wales showed enough sheer doggedness against New Zealand to stop the first game descending into farce – deserved more, but you don't always get what you deserve. Besides, the impact of the event should not be measured solely at the turnstiles. The Four Nations and the code in general got more positive publicity than they would ever have done in the North and it all tied in neatly with the relaunch of the London Broncos as the Super League presence in the capital.
Around a third of the tickets sold in advance were sold in the South. Even allowing for the London-based Aussies and Kiwis, that proves that there is an untapped market for the Broncos to connect with.
3 A major game needs an experienced referee
Henry Perenara seems a nice bloke. He has the advantage of recently playing the game at first-grade level and he handled the England-Wales match the previous weekend without any dramas.
But he has only officiated in a handful of NRL games and, on Saturday, it showed. He was strict with England at the play-the-ball, not so much so with Australia. He bottled out of showing a card to Tony Williams for the game's worst tackle. Never mind that Ben Westwood has said he was play-acting, the intent and the impact were both there.
Worst of all was the double-think over the double-movement. If he had gone to the video referee, Tom Briscoe's try would have been allowed. Insult was added to injury when he went to the screen and gave one to Chris Lawrence.
You don't have to subscribe to Steve McNamara's rather paranoid theory that he was "got at" by Aussie pressure. He was just out of his depth.
4 England are capable of beating New Zealand
OK, they eventually lost to Australia by 16 points, but not since Melbourne in 1992 have they looked as consistently dangerous against them.
They played a hugely enterprising brand of rugby and were always liable to make breaks. With a bit of fine tuning, they can certainly do the same against the Kiwis.
Then it will be a question of whether they can cut down on the daft mistakes. No more short kicks from the 20-metre line, if you please. And it goes without saying that they will need to make the key tackles, several of which were missed at Wembley.
5 The problem is that there could be better to come from Australia
Even without the injured Billy Slater, they have Darius Boyd to slot in at full-back – and he is almost as good. Greg Inglis will be better for the run at Wembley and Darren Lockyer's dodgy shoulder will have had two weeks' rest.
We haven't yet seen the best yet of the new wingman, Akuila Uate, but Elland Road could well be his stage.
Meanwhile, the mobile and athletic Australian pack will be as formidable as ever. Take the case of Paul Gallen, a loose forward redeployed as a prop.
We're pretty happy with our front row at present – subject to injury news this week – but we could be looking at the future.
Latest in Sport
- 1 The truth about 'girl things': Three cheers for Heather Watson's honesty
- 2 Man who held up 'hire me' sign at Waterloo station returns a year later with 'I'm hiring' sign
- 5 Men behaving badly: Urinating while standing, 'manspreading' and the gendering of selfishness
Nigel Farage: NHS might have to be replaced by private health insurance
'We would evict Queen from Buckingham Palace and allocate her council house,' say Greens
French court convicts three over homophobic tweets, in case hailed as a 'significant victory' by LGBT rights campaigners
British Muslim school children suffering a backlash of abuse following Paris attacks
George Galloway condemns 'racist, Islamophobic, hypocritical rag' Charlie Hebdo at freedom of speech rally
Islamic history is full of free thinkers - but recent attempts to suppress critical thought are verging on the absurd