Piling in for the view: A migrating herd in a mad rush ... and some wildebeest
Seeing Kenya's wildlife up close is a magnificent experience – except when scores of unregulated tourists pile in for the view. Plus, world attractions ruined by crowds
James Cusick is political correspondent of The Independent and The Independent on Sunday. As an experienced member of the lobby, he has previously worked at The Sunday Times and the BBC. His career as a journalist has been split between print and television, including senior positions as producer with Sir David Frost and at BBC Newsnight. He is also an award-winning golf and travel writer, working for over a decade as the UK contributing editor for one of the USA’s leading golf magazines. He broadcasts regularly for the BBC and CNN. He lives in London.
Saturday 08 February 2014
It looked like a spectators' car park at a busy Nevada rodeo, where the best way to get up close to the animals is simply to stand on the roof of your SUV and whip out a camera lens the size of a drain pipe. And when the kids get too excited and venture too close to the crazy critters, why you just holler and pull them back.
Stetsons, baseball hats, beanies, canvas cloches, military floppies, bright hoodies, would-be French legionnaires: all were on show. And with the multi-coloured hat-fest came striking T-shirts and vests, baggy shorts, khaki pants, a bright yellow anorak, polo shirts and sleeveless fishing vests.
I could see them all. A hundred or so people, surrounding a couple of dozen 4x4s. They were perched on the roofs of their vehicles; or standing outside them, trampling the grass; or edging towards the open dirt space where the action was taking place. I could see them – but I just couldn't believe what I was looking at. Because what was happening only a few metres away from this effectively illegal gathering was something far more dangerous, wild and spectacular than any steer-wrestling exhibition or tie-down roping.
This was the Mara River in south-west Kenya's Maasai Mara National Reserve. The radio chat between the rangers must have been intense throughout the morning to bring this amount of traffic to the site of a potential "crossing". There is neither a start nor finish to the annual migration cycle within the Serengeti ecosystem. But the search for food and water by 1.5 million wildebeest, 500,000 Thomson's gazelle, 200,000 zebra and 18,000 eland, along with a quarter of a million other residents that include lions, leopards, cheetahs and other predators, means the seasonal route from Tanzania into Kenya necessitates that the migrating herds will at some point risk their lives as they cross the Mara.
The daily spectacle is a reminder that survival of the many often comes with the bloody death of the few. They rope wild bulls in Reno and call it a sport. In the Mara, crocodiles pick off wildebeest and turn the river red with blood at "crossing" times, and they call it tourism.
It's a natural wonder and – depending on which report you read – more than half of the three million tourists expected to visit Kenya each year will travel to the Maasai Mara to see the migration. A substantial upward revision of that figure is expected soon, due to rising numbers of Chinese visitors. At the peak, between July and September, 8,000 people – each of whom pay an $80 entrance fee – are to be found somewhere in the reserve's 1,510sq km every day. The wildebeest do what they do, but the human "migration" supposedly has rules to ensure Africa's natural cycle is not disturbed too much. I was watching the rodeo crowd from the opposite bank of the Mara, where only a few 4x4s had parked. I took the chance to re-read the list of rules I'd picked up at the Oloololo Gate entrance. They include "Do not sit or stand on vehicles' roofs at any time. Do not alight from vehicles at river crossing points. Always stay 25 metres away from the animals. No shouting clapping, or cheering. No littering."
Beastly: wildebeest make the treacherous journey across the Mara River
Wardens, whose job it is to police the reserve, were standing outside the Land Rovers. They looked like they couldn't care less. Maasai guides, in their checked tribal robes, were among the crowd, watching as camera-laden tourists edged dangerously away from the vehicles to within a few metres of wildebeest nervously waiting to make their way down to the crossing point. It looked insane; as deranged as someone casually trying to walk across a Formula 1 circuit during a race.
My own guide, Joseph Ole Koyie, a knowledgeable Maasai from the Sanctuary Olonana tented camp were I was staying, was also distressed. Built on a private stretch of the Mara just outside the reserve, Olonana is the embodiment of Kenya's safari industry wish-list. It is astoundingly beautiful, ecologically conscious and respectful of its wider role in conservation. Throughout four days, I never felt I was intruding on the migration's natural flow. That's how it should be.
Olonana appeals to a small number of clients, with luxury tents and dining that wouldn't be out of place in a five-star Mayfair hotel. The Mara's small number of luxury camps fits with Kenya's long-term plan of lowering numbers coming into the Mara, without affecting income. But how serious are the nation's decision-makers about this? Is it simply to enforce tourism quotas – and to price most people out?
Botswana's safari industry has already chosen the high-end option. The private game reserves in the Kruger National Park of South Africa are variants of the same strategy. However, a Kenya government report recently estimated that although up to 70 per cent of the 108 camps and lodges in the Maasai Mara area were effectively unlicensed and not paying their share of the Mara's upkeep in taxes, there were no plans to close them down. In the short-term Kenya can't afford such a gesture.
Unlike easy-to-rope-off heritage buildings that tourists want to box-tick before they die, must-see natural ecosystems such as the Serengeti, the Red Sea Reef, Mount Kilimanjaro or the Ngorongoro Crater are struggling to find new survival strategies for increasing global appetites.
Church of the Holy Sepulchre, Jerusalem. 'So fraught that even the rival priests had an animated set-to. Almost impossible to recall that it is a sacred place.'
Peru's city in the clouds, Machu Picchu, the ancient Inca citadel that was built in grey granite more than 600 years ago, is currently visited by a little more than 2,000 tourists a day. It might have escaped the attention of 16th-century Spanish Conquistadors, but it can't escape the effects of 21st-century tourism. The footfall of international visitors is eroding parts of the site. Walking the Inca Trail is supposed to be the symbolically perfect way of getting there (rather than using the railway from Cusco). In 1984, 6,000 people used the trail. By the Millennium it was 82,000. It has now passed 100,000. Add to that the fact that fuel used for cooking on the trail comes from local timber and recent forest fires, and Machu Picchu itself looks threatened.
The solution? There has been talk of building a mountain highway and even a cable car. Helicopter flights have been authorised, but ecologists fear their impact on Andean condors. Entrance fees, along with income from the Inca Trail brings the Peruvian economy more than $10m a year. With other jobs, related tourism and support industries, the economic value of Machu Picchu is huge. Quotas and restrictions, if they come with lost income, won't happen for Machu Picchu just yet.
So how do you cope as a tourist if you know the crowds may spoil an adventure? A few years ago I was in Jordan and wanted to visit the rose-red carved monuments at Petra. The mountain city between Aqaba and Wadi Arabah is now, despite its remoteness, recognised as one of the wonders of the world. So it gets busy. The Siq is the high-sided narrow canyon that exits at the Treasury building. If you are first into the Siq, as dawn breaks, you can climb to the Deir (or "monastery") in an hour and be on your way out before the rush. Or take the "Petra by night" tour which sees 2,000 candles line the canyon, before you emerge with the Treasury bathed in candlelight and Bedouin music. For now, solutions such as these can help to an extent. However, an ecosystem such as the Maasai Mara doesn't have Petra's options.
Joseph Koyie doesn't believe the Mara is under threat. Driving away from the crowded crossings towards Tanzania, he showed it was still possible to move sensitively among the migrating herds. Nevertheless, he wants the reserve's long-term sustainability to come before short-term benefits. The days of the rodeo crowd, ignored rules and safari in the Mara as a mass-spectator sport, need to end. So is the Mara's future about persuading people not to come? It might be. The alternative could be a very large crowd – but nothing to see.
James Cusick was a guest of Sanctuary Retreats (020 7190 7728; sanctuaryretreats.com) which offers three nights at Olonana from £790pp, including luxury tented accommodation, all meals and drinks, safari activities, return road transfers to the airstrip in the Mara, a Maasai Village visit, sundowners and bush meals. James travelled from Nairobi to the airstrip near Sanctuary Retreats with Safarilink (00 254 206 000 777; flysafarilink.com.
Was your long-anticipated visit to a great cultural or natural wonder ruined by too many tourists? Get in touch at email@example.com or tweet us @indytravel
The Independent travel offers: Discover a world of inspiring destinations
Hashima: Among the ruins on Japan's Battleship Island, the place that time forgot
Top 10 cheapest cities to visit, according to TripAdvisor
South Africa's new travel rules: From October, families with under-18s will need to show their birth certificates
Harder, better, faster, longer: The best rollercoasters in the world
Weary? In need of some sun? Relax and unwind with a trip to... Iraqi Kurdistan
- 1 Al Pacino on suffering from depression: 'It can last and it's terrifying'
- 2 Half of young women unable to ‘locate vagina’ and 65% find it difficult to say the word
- 3 Saudis risk new Muslim division with proposal to move Mohamed’s tomb
- 4 A teacher speaks out: 'I'm effectively being forced out of a career that I wanted to love'
- 5 Mexican woman becomes world’s 'oldest person' at 127
Rotherham child sex abuse scandal: Labour Home Office to be probed over what Tony Blair's government knew - and when
What do immigrants really think of Britain? Polish immigrant's Reddit post goes viral
Ashya King: Parents of five-year-old boy refused permission to visit him in hospital and denied bail at Spanish court
With Douglas Carswell joining Ukip, my party has taken another giant step forward
When elitism grips the top of British society to this extent, there is only one answer: abolish private schools
Ashya King: 'Cruel NHS has not given us the treatment we need', says father of five-year-old with brain tumour who fled to Spain
£20 - 26k + Benefits: Guru Careers: A Marketing Executive / Member Services Ex...
£15,000 - £25,000: Recruitment Genius: A fantastic opportunity has arisen for ...
£30000 - £45000 per annum + Bonus+Benefits+Package: Harrington Starr: VB.NET a...
£30 - 35k + Uncapped Comission (£70k Y1 OTE): Guru Careers: A Business Develop...