Court defeat for BAA over airport sell-off
Wednesday 13 October 2010
A decision that could force airport operator BAA to comply with an order to sell three of its airports was restored by the Court of Appeal today.
In March last year, the Competition Commission (CC) ruled that BAA must sell Gatwick and Stansted airports as well as one of either Glasgow or Edinburgh.
But BAA successfully appealed against this, with the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) finding last December that there was "apparent bias" in the CC's ruling over Gatwick.
In turn, the CC went to the Court of Appeal in June to challenge the CAT decision.
Today, Lord Justice Maurice Kay, Lord Justice Jacob and Lord Justice Patten said that the CAT was wrong to find "apparent bias" and restored the Commission's decision.
They refused BAA's application to appeal to the Supreme Court, although the authority can renew its application direct.
BAA had already decided to sell Gatwick even before the March 2009 CC sell-off ruling which had followed a lengthy inquiry into UK airport ownership.
However, BAA was concerned that Professor Peter Mozier, one of the CC airports' inquiry panel, had a connection to the Manchester Airport Group which had been interested in buying Gatwick.
In its ruling last December, the CAT agreed with BAA's claim that Prof Mozier's role meant there had been "apparent bias" in the sell-off decision.
The CAT said Prof Mozier was not actually biased "but that a fair-minded person would have concluded that there was a real possibility of bias".
Gatwick was sold last year for £1.5 billion to US-based investment fund Global Infrastructure Partners.
As well as running Stansted, Glasgow and Edinburgh airports, Spanish-owned BAA also operates Heathrow, Southampton and Aberdeen airports.
In his judgment, Lord Justice Maurice Kay said the relevant legal test was whether a "fair-minded and informed observer", having considered the facts, would conclude that there was a real possibility of bias.
Such a person was not "unduly sensitive or suspicious".
He concluded: "I am entirely satisfied that, once in possession of the true facts about Prof Moizer's position, the fair-minded observer would conclude that, at all times between April 2007 and December 2 2008, Prof Moizer was untainted by apparent bias."
The judge said that Prof Moizer's relationship was with the Greater Manchester Pension Fund - where he was one of three external advisers - and not with Manchester Airport Group (MAG) or the local authorities.
"He had no reason to suppose that the fund was going to consider joining in the MAG bid for Gatwick. He was too remote from MAG and its owners for apparent bias to be a real concern."
The court had heard from BAA that Prof Moizer did not step down until March 3 2009 and it was not known what influence he might have had during that period.
But the Commission said that nothing in the panel's views changed significantly after December 2, while its provisional findings had been published the previous August.
The appeal judges agreed with counsel for the Commission, who said that to conclude that there was a real possibility that the "apparent bias" of Prof Moizer after December 2 afflicted the Commission's final decision was "moving into the reaches of fantasy".
In the context of the "iterative" nature of the Commission's procedure and the stage it had reached by December 2, they did not consider that a fair-minded observer would regard the final decision to have been tainted.
The Independent travel offers: Discover a world of inspiring destinations
- 1 PlayStation and Xbox hacked by Lizard Squad
- 2 The 'Black Museum': After 150 years, public set to see exhibits from police’s grisly crime museum
- 4 Vagina canoe artist defends herself over ‘obscenity’ charges
- 5 The Queen’s speech 2014: Recap and Twitter reaction to Game of Thrones reference
Travelling by train, boat and plane in 2015: what's in store from ferries to winter sports services
TripAdvisor reveals the top places to visit in 2015
Chic new hotels in 2015: From Britain's first football-themed property to a Facebook millionaire's debut desert resort
Yakutsk: Journey to the coldest city on earth
Top 10 travel destinations for 2015: From Haiti and Alaska to Namibia and Iceland
British actor Idris Elba cannot star as James Bond because he is black, says shock jock Rush Limbaugh
Rozanne Duncan: Ukip expels councillor for 'jaw-dropping' comments made in BBC TV interview
Germany anti-Islam protests: 17,000 march on Dresden against 'Islamification of the West'
Ukip member gets into Christmas spirit with Union Flag plea to Santa 'for our country back'
BBC director Danny Cohen: Rising UK antisemitism makes me feel more uncomfortable than ever
Alex Salmond has 'broken his word to the Scottish people' says Scottish Lib Dem leader
£25000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: The fastest growing fitness cha...
£240 - £275 per day: Investigo: Support the global business through in-depth a...
Negotiable: Ashdown Group: Data Manager - MySQL, Shell Scripts, Java, VB Scrip...
£27000 - £32000 per annum: Ashdown Group: Application Support Analyst - near S...