User reviews set to replace hotel stars in Britain

British tourism authorities have revealed that they are considering scrapping the country's star-rating system, a traditional indicator of hotel quality.

In a move that could mark the start of a broader shift away from state-sanctioned assessments, Britain's government said that a forthcoming policy paper will propose ending the one-to-five-star system.

It says that user reviews - with TripAdvisor specifically singled out - offer consumers a better idea of what the hotel's quality will be like and what they can expect from a stay than the ratings of the current system, in which the country's hotels are evaluated by experts.

Hotels will be able to choose a standard of their own, either a TripAdvisor score (already in use by some) or a collection of reviews from another source, and use it to guide customers.

Such a system would be likely to benefit some properties, such as small luxury hotels which lose star points because they cannot provide the amenities required by high star ratings but often offer top-notch food or comfort.

However, the tacit approval of TripAdvisor as an option is likely to anger some in Britain's accommodation industry, which doesn't always have a smooth relationship with the global travel review giant.

While Britain is considering scrapping star ratings, other countries are introducing them.

Last year, both Abu Dhabi and Jordan implemented a five-star classification system for their hotels, aiming to improve the experience of visitors when booking accommodation.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Teenage kicks: Twitter and the 'bling ring' gang

Lena Corner gets the inside story on this very post-modern scandal.

Moveable feasts: Festival grub goes gourmet

Meet the mobile foodie pioneers bringing Bloody Mary crumpets, craft ales and sustainable seafood to the masses.

'My own Diamond Jubilee': 60 years in same job

The Queen is part of an elite club which clocks in way past retirement age.
Joumana Haddad: 'Arab women have been brainwashed'

Joumana Haddad: 'Arab women have been brainwashed'

Haddad is a voice rarely heard in the Middle East – an unapologetic feminist who wants to challenge the way both Arab men and women think.

Food: Mark Hix knows his onions

Alliums are among the most versatile kitchen ingredients, says our chef.
Grotty no more: How Lanzarote upgraded its appeal

How Lanzarote upgraded its appeal

Lanzarote has been quietly changing its fly-and-flop holiday image, discovers Andrew Eames.
Traveller's Guide: Montenegro

Traveller's Guide: Montenegro

It's one of Europe's smallest countries, but it packs in spectacular landscapes and glittering beach resorts.
48 Hours In: Verona

48 Hours In: Verona

Summer opera returns to the Roman arena, says Charles Hebbert.
Ten things we’re looking out for at E3 2012

Ten things to look out for at E3 2012

From Wii U to The Last of Us we consider this year's show
Come dine (online) with me

Come dine (online) with me

Move over TV chefs, hello YouTube stars
Next in line – but public just can't warm to idea of Charles in charge

Next in line – but public just can't warm to idea of Charles in charge

'Independent' poll finds less that half want him to take throne as ministers moan of interference
Nothing's sacred: the illegal trade in India's holy cows

Nothing's sacred: the illegal trade in India's holy cows

Andrew Buncombe reports from Kaharpara on a bloody war between rustlers and border guards
Mogul grounded: Desmond gives up his jet deal

Mogul grounded: Desmond gives up his jet deal

Media tycoon's company pays £1m to cancel his order for a £36m private jet after drop in profits
How Ai Weiwei built a pavilion in London – by remote control

How Ai Weiwei built a pavilion in London – by remote control

The artist tells Clifford Coonan how he used Skype to escape confinement in Beijing
Nature, nurture... or neither? The new twist in an age-old argument

Nature, nurture... or neither?

The new twist in an age-old argument