Got a chip on your shoulder about your upbringing and its negative effect on your current circumstances? Well, get ready to turn that chip into a whole bag of potato snacks. If a new book is to be believed, now you’ve got even more reason to feel annoyed and disempowered.
The Son Also Rises (see what he did there?) is a new book by Gregory Clark which states that our chances of success in life depend on what our family were doing 300 years ago. If you’re not doing so well these days, blame your great, great, great, great, great, great grandfather. If he was a shopkeeper, you’re likely to be a shopkeeper. If he was struggling, you’re likely to be struggling. And if you spend your time dreaming up spurious theses and getting paid actual money for them, chances are your ancestor was doing exactly the same thing.
Oh come on, Greg. I’ve never read such a load of rubbish in my life. My great, great, great, great, great, great grandfather was probably impoverished, illiterate and busy escaping a pogrom or inquisition of some sort. That’s not my situation, thank goodness. Granted I am lucky to live in a free society and not Saudi Arabia, where I really would be in trouble, but I do read and write for a living. Even if my ancestor had impeded my progress, what’s the point in thinking that? Blaming someone else who’s alive for your fate is disempowering and useless enough; there’s even less recompense from the long dead.
If we want to look at social mobility we need to work with what we’ve got now rather than looking back into the ancient past. And what we’ve got now are contributing factors that are bigger than any one individual. Too much of a divide between the independent and state sectors, not enough on-the-job training schemes for all ages (not just school-leavers), ridiculously high property prices, unaffordable childcare and too many people getting into debt doing higher-education courses that just won’t help them to get a job. With a lot of work and a change in thinking, we can fix these issues. It’s a little bit harder to resurrect our dearly departed loved ones and get them to sort out our lives.
Social mobility is a serious issue. Let’s take it seriously instead of pandering to mad academic theories.
Louise Scodie is a presenter for London LiveReuse content