It’s hard to know what to think about immigration. But not impossible

Having watched politicians have their numbers debunked lately, we're well acquainted with the sight of MPs overcooking statistics - but not Government departments

Share
Related Topics

If I was right now to quantify the latest shifts in my understanding of UK immigration, the data would look something like this: confidence that whatever Government body currently responsible for it knows what it is doing; down 6.2 per cent. Confusion over how many Brazilian geneticists are actually coming in and out of the country; up by two orders of magnitude. General stupefaction – always a problem in the summer months –approaching a decades-long high.

OK there’s a touch of guesswork going on here. But, according to a report released on the weekend into official migration totals, the methods used to compile my figures aren’t so totally different from those employed by the Office for National Statistics (ONS).The report claims that migration data released by the nation’s data watchdog is “little better than a best guess” – meaning we can’t really be sure of how many people - be they healthy Brazilian geneticists or wounded Syrian jihadis – have entered the UK in the past year.

Which, frankly, is a worry. Not just because many thousand fewer immigrants might have entered the country in 2011-12 than the estimated 515,000 (or many thousand more) but because these are the kind of baseline numbers on which responsible politics depends.

Having watched Mr Duncan Smith, Mr Osborne and even Mr Cameron have their numbers debunked lately, we should by now be well acquainted with the sight of coalition MPs overcooking statistics. (For sauciness alone, Mr Gove’s use of a poll commissioned by Premier Inn to support his curriculum reforms will take some beating).

It all becomes a little more unnerving however when the body at fault is not fork-tongued politicians – who can and have been challenged in the press - but notionally objective Government departments. As someone who tends to take it as read that any number prefaced by a three-letter acronym (BCS, OBR, APS) contains something approaching the truth, the idea that beneath that number might be a mess of inadequate, subjective working comes as something of a shock.

I appreciate the naivety here. The steady rise of data journalism has shown up those of us who still can’t tell a quadratic from a quartile. This latest ONS snafu, then, ought to increase public scepticism of even the most official statistics - without turning it up to full voltage.

Because however tempting it may be to quote “lies, damn lies and statistics”, that line simply isn’t true. There are poor stats and better stats, and it’s important to seek out the latter sort. To form an opinion on the economic impact of immigration, for example, you can now make use of a data set far larger and more sophisticated than was available ten years ago. That would take real work, though…

Same-Sex Marriage

Buy the new Independent eBook - £1.99 A collection of reports published in The Independent over more than two decades, allowing you to retrace the challenges, setbacks and bold leaps forward on the long road to equality.

kobo Amazon Kindle

React Now

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Year 1 Teacher

£90 - £160 per day: Randstad Education Group: A Primary School in Bradford are...

Commercial Lawyer – Renewable Energy

£28000 - £32000 Per Annum: The Green Recruitment Company: Job Title: Commercia...

Solar PV - Sales South

£30000 Per Annum Bonus + Car: The Green Recruitment Company: Job Title: Solar ...

Renewable Heating Sales Manager

£25000 Per Annum basic + car + commission: The Green Recruitment Company: The ...

Day In a Page

Read Next
 

I won't let the trolls win with #TwitterSilence - they want us to shut up

Vicky Beeching
Actor Peter Capaldi  

From spin doctor to Doctor Who: Is Peter Capaldi the right choice to play the regenerated Time Lord?

Neela Debnath
Special report: How my father's face turned up in Robert Capa's lost suitcase

Special report: How my father's face turned up in Robert Capa's lost suitcase

The great war photographer was not one person but two. Their pictures of Spain's civil war, lost for decades, tell a heroic tale
The unmade speech: An alternative draft of history

The unmade speech: An alternative draft of history

Someone, somewhere has to write speeches for world leaders to deliver in the event of disaster. They offer a chilling hint at what could have been
Funny business: Meet the women running comedy

Funny business: Meet the women running comedy

Think comedy’s a man's world? You must be stuck in the 1980s, says Holly Williams
Wilko Johnson: 'You have to live for the minute you're in'

Wilko Johnson: 'You have to live for the minute you're in'

The Dr Feelgood guitarist talks frankly about his terminal illness
Lure of the jingle: Entrepreneurs are giving vintage ice-cream vans a new lease of life

Lure of the jingle

Entrepreneurs are giving vintage ice-cream vans a new lease of life
Who stole the people's own culture?

DJ Taylor: Who stole the people's own culture?

True popular art drives up from the streets, but the commercial world wastes no time in cashing in
Guest List: The IoS Literary Editor suggests some books for your summer holiday

Guest List: IoS Literary Editor suggests some books for your summer holiday

Before you stuff your luggage with this year's Man Booker longlist titles, the case for some varied poolside reading alternatives
What if Edward Snowden had stayed to fight his corner?

Rupert Cornwell: What if Edward Snowden had stayed to fight his corner?

The CIA whistleblower struck a blow for us all, but his 1970s predecessor showed how to win
'A man walks into a bar': Comedian Seann Walsh on the dangers of mixing alcohol and stand-up

Comedian Seann Walsh on alcohol and stand-up

Comedy and booze go together, says Walsh. The trouble is stopping at just the one. So when do the hangovers stop being funny?
From Edinburgh to Hollywood (via the Home Counties): 10 comedic talents blowing up big

Edinburgh to Hollywood: 10 comedic talents blowing up big

Hugh Montgomery profiles the faces to watch, from the sitcom star to the surrealist
'Hello. I have cancer': When comedian Tig Notaro discovered she had a tumour she decided the show must go on

Comedian Tig Notaro: 'Hello. I have cancer'

When Notaro discovered she had a tumour she decided the show must go on
They think it's all ova: Bill Granger's Asia-influenced egg recipes

Bill Granger's Asia-influenced egg recipes

Our chef made his name cooking eggs, but he’s never stopped looking for new ways to serve them
The world wakes up to golf's female big hitters

The world wakes up to golf's female big hitters

With its own Tiger Woods - South Korea's Inbee Park - the women's game has a growing audience
10 athletes ready to take the world by storm in Moscow next week

10 athletes ready to take the world by storm in Moscow next week

Here are the potential stars of the World Championships which begin on Saturday
The Last Word: Luis Suarez and Gareth Bale's art of manipulation

The Last Word: Luis Suarez and Gareth Bale's art of manipulation

Briefings are off the record leading to transfer speculation which is merely a means to an end