Jeremy Laurance: Reverse this retrograde law against donor anonymity

Payment for eggs should reflect the level of risk and commitment

Related Topics

Back in the mists of time when I was a reporter on a Sunday paper, I turned up an interesting tale about women offered free sterilisations in return for their eggs. Private fertility clinics were providing the surgery, which then cost £600, to women prepared to help an infertile couple or two. I called Dame Mary Donaldson, a former mayor of London and then head of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority to get her reaction. "That's unethical," she snapped, without hesitation.

Twenty years on, offering free (or reduced cost) IVF treatment to women prepared to donate eggs is accepted practice. Now Dame Mary's successor at the HFEA, Lisa Jardine, is suggesting that in addition to the lure of free treatment, women should be offered cash to induce them to become donors. What was once condemned as "blackmail" we are now invited to accept as the normal working of the market.

Professor Jardine's reasoning is persuasive. There is a serious shortage of donor eggs and sperm, which has worsened since the removal of anonymity for donors in 2005 (treatment cycles using donated eggs fell 25 per cent between 2004-2006 and those using donated sperm were down 30 per cent).

Under existing rules, donors can get up to £250 in expenses but no fee for their services. Relying on altruism has failed to meet the demand and the shortage of donors is fuelling fertility tourism. If we allowed payment to donors, we might keep the patients and the donors here, where they can be treated in regulated clinics, rather than left to take their chance in the unregulated environment in countries overseas.

So far, so good. Men should get a lower payment, Professor Jardine suggests, because they can deliver a sample in minutes at no personal risk. But if young women want to flog their eggs to pay off their student loans, where is the harm? Provided they are properly counselled about the risks and receive top quality medical care.

For women, egg donation is a lengthy and invasive process, requiring them to take hormones to stimulate their ovaries before the egg retrieval is performed under anaesthetic. The payment should reflect the greater level of commitment and the higher risk.

Fine. But how is this different from the kidney donor looking for cash for their organ? There is a global shortage of organs for transplant, with around 40,000 people on transplant waiting lists in Western Europe, of whom between 15 and 30 per cent are expected to die. A transplant is the only cure for kidney failure (dialysis is expensive and never more than a stop-gap).

Transplant tourism has a longer history than fertility tourism and arguably poses tougher questions. Wealthy patients in western countries travel to parts of the world where the trade in organs is ignored, or tolerated, and life is cheap. Eastern Europe, Pakistan and the Far East are among the regions where it is booming. Last week, the FBI smashed a money-laundering gang in New Jersey, US, which brokered the sale of human kidneys, among other activities, and included three mayors, five rabbis and 36 others.

Professor Jardine says that the law treats eggs, sperm and embryos, regulated under the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, differently from other tissues which are regulated under the Human Tissue Act and there was no danger that selling eggs would set a precedent for selling kidneys. But the distinction drawn by the law appears to be without rationale. Setting a precedent is precisely what authorising donors to sell their eggs would do.

Transplant surgeons might welcome it. Cutting out bits of ourselves and selling them to the highest bidder strikes many people as grotesque – an act that should remain taboo. But senior doctors, including a former president of the General Medical Council, have called for a debate on the trade in organs, recognising, like Professor Jardine, that it cannot be stopped and would be better regulated. A person confronting their mortality, or that of a loved one, told it is wrong to buy a kidney is unlikely to be restrained by the law.

That, however, is an altogether bigger and more morally fraught debate which Professor Jardine was hoping, probably vainly, to avoid. So why head down this road at all? It is now clear that the shortage of egg and sperm donors has been aggravated by the removal of donor anonymity in 2005. A respectable attempt to give "donor" children equal rights to know their heritage has grievously backfired.

Instead of paying for eggs and sperm, which risks switching off the supply of altruistic donors as well as opening the door to the dubious organ trade, it is surely time to revisit the 2005 decision to remove donor anonymity – and reverse it.

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Sustainability Manager

Competitive: The Green Recruitment Company: Job Title: Scheme Manager (BREEAM)...

Graduate Sustainability Professional

Flexible, depending on experience: The Green Recruitment Company: Job Title: T...

Programme Director - Conduct Risk - London

£850 - £950 per day: Orgtel: Programme Director - Conduct Risk - Banking - £85...

Project Coordinator/Order Entry, SC Clear

£100 - £110 per day: Orgtel: Project Coordinator/Order Entry Hampshire

Day In a Page

Read Next
Former N-Dubz singer Tulisa Contostavlos gives a statement outside Southwark Crown Court after her trial  

It would be wrong to compare brave Tulisa’s ordeal with phone hacking. It’s much worse than that

Matthew Norman
The Big Society Network was assessed as  

What became of Cameron's Big Society Network?

Oliver Wright
Some are reformed drug addicts. Some are single mums. All are on benefits. But now these so-called 'scroungers’ are fighting back

The 'scroungers’ fight back

The welfare claimants battling to alter stereotypes
Amazing video shows Nasa 'flame extinguishment experiment' in action

Fireballs in space

Amazing video shows Nasa's 'flame extinguishment experiment' in action
A Bible for billionaires

A Bible for billionaires

Find out why America's richest men are reading John Brookes
Paranoid parenting is on the rise - and our children are suffering because of it

Paranoid parenting is on the rise

And our children are suffering because of it
For sale: Island where the Magna Carta was sealed

Magna Carta Island goes on sale

Yours for a cool £4m
Phone hacking scandal special report: The slide into crime at the 'News of the World'

The hacker's tale: the slide into crime at the 'News of the World'

Glenn Mulcaire was jailed for six months for intercepting phone messages. James Hanning tells his story in a new book. This is an extract
We flinch, but there are degrees of paedophilia

We flinch, but there are degrees of paedophilia

Child abusers are not all the same, yet the idea of treating them differently in relation to the severity of their crimes has somehow become controversial
The truth about conspiracy theories is that some require considering

The truth about conspiracy theories is that some require considering

For instance, did Isis kill the Israeli teenagers to trigger a war, asks Patrick Cockburn
Alistair Carmichael: 'The UK as a whole is greater than the sum of its parts'

Alistair Carmichael: 'The UK as a whole is greater than the sum of its parts'

Meet the man who doesn't want to go down in history as the country's last Scottish Secretary
Legoland Windsor's master model-makers reveal the tricks of their trade (including how to stop the kids wrecking your Eiffel Tower)

Meet the people who play with Lego for a living

They are the master builders: Lego's crack team of model-makers, who have just glued down the last of 650,000 bricks as they recreate Paris in Windsor. Susie Mesure goes behind the scenes
The 20 best days out for the summer holidays: From Spitfires to summer ferry sailings

20 best days out for the summer holidays

From summer ferry sailings in Tyne and Wear and adventure days at Bear Grylls Survival Academy to Spitfires at the Imperial War Museum Duxford and bog-snorkelling at the World Alternative Games...
Open-air theatres: If all the world is a stage, then everyone gets in on the act

All the wood’s a stage

Open-air productions are the cue for better box-office receipts, new audiences, more interesting artistic challenges – and a picnic
Rand Paul is a Republican with an eye on the world

Rupert Cornwell: A Republican with an eye on the world

Rand Paul is laying out his presidential stall by taking on his party's disastrous record on foreign policy
Self-preservation society: Pickles are moving from the side of your plate to become the star dish

Self-preservation society

Pickles are moving from the side of your plate to become the star dish
Generation gap opens a career sinkhole

Britons live ever longer, but still society persists in glorifying youth

We are living longer but considered 'past it' younger, the reshuffle suggests. There may be trouble ahead, says DJ Taylor