Leading article: Private money and public interest

Share
+More
Related Topics

As ever, fools rush in. Those who stumbled over themselves to paint Vince Cable as a wild-eyed Marxist on the basis of early extracts from his Liberal Democrat conference speech were left with egg on their faces yesterday when the Business Secretary delivered a classic defence of regulated free markets. But the furore did serve to highlight a prominent and malign feature of official attitudes towards the private sector in Britain.

For the past three decades there has been a free market fundamentalist ideology at work in political life; an assumption that the public good is automatically served by leaving the private sector to its own devices. This view took hold under Margaret Thatcher's administration and reached near dominance under New Labour. And it was this laissez-faire instinct which reared its intolerant head when reports emerged that the Business Secretary would be daring to criticise some aspects of private-sector behaviour.

It is certainly true that free markets, which drive up quality and drive down price, are the best way of delivering the goods and services that people want and need. But the idea that the private sector always and everywhere promotes the public interest is a dangerous delusion. The reality, as Mr Cable pointed out forcefully yesterday, is that private firms, when left entirely to their own devices, often work against the public good, rather than enhancing it. They behave in ways that undermine competition and distort markets for their own narrow advantage.

Examples of this tendency abound, and this newspaper has highlighted them. While the wholesale price of energy fell sharply in 2008 the prices charged to customers by the "big six" energy firms stayed the same. The giant supermarket groups stand accused of using their market power to bully small suppliers and to pressurise local councils on matters of planning. And, of course, the banking sector has been the source of a host of abuses in recent years, from excessive overdraft charges to the arbitrary imposition of penal borrowing terms on small businesses since the recession.

The costs to the public of a laissez-faire attitude to markets from the state manifest themselves in excessive charges and needlessly high prices. But the public costs by no means stop there. The reason Britain has one of the biggest deficits in the G20 is because the Treasury became so heavily reliant on the bubble revenues of an inadequately regulated financial services sector. Britain is facing years of savage public spending cuts largely because of the failure of successive ministers and regulators to curb the recklessness of the banks.

It is for the same reason – protection of the public interest – that Mr Cable is justified in examining the rules surrounding private sector takeovers, such as the recent acquisition of Cadbury by the US food giant Kraft. Most of these large mergers end up destroying shareholder value over the long term. And Cadbury is unlikely to be an exception. Shareholders, not ministers, should decide on matters of ownership. But it is almost impossible for shareholders who take a long-term perspective to hold out when short-term speculators arrive en masse as they do when news of a takeover attempt breaks. It is entirely legitimate for the Government to examine ways of throwing sand in the wheels of such takeovers. There is nothing in the least "anti-business" about demanding a level playing field for investors.

In recent years, ministers have tended to assume that support for free markets means blindly cheering on all private sector activity. But the interests of individual companies, or a particular sector, should not be confused with the interests of the wider economy or the general public. Mr Cable understands that distinction. We await with interest to see whether the Coalition as a whole has got the message.

React Now

Day In a Page

Read Next
 

Britain should prosecute terrorist suspects, not play shady games of geopolitics

Dr Nafeez Mosaddeq Ahmed
Brave Ingrid engaged a man holding a meat cleaver in conversation until police arrived  

The bravery of women shames men

Janet Street-Porter
Andrew Mitchell: 'It's no good feeling hard done by'

Andrew Mitchell: 'It's no good feeling hard done by'

In his first interview since 'plebgate', the former Chief Whip opens up just enough to concede that, in politics, you have to take the rough with the smooth
Corruption and the FCO: Blue skies, white sands, dark clouds

Corruption and the FCO: Blue skies, white sands, dark clouds

Special report: Met police call for criminal inquiry into former diplomat's Cayman Islands rule
Fallen angel: Winona Ryder on bouncing back from her decade in the wilderness

Fallen angel: Winona Ryder bounces back

She owned the 1990s... but then she disappeared. Now, Ms Ryder is back with quite the bang in her latest role, as the wife of a notorious real-life Mob hitman.
Roman Polanski shakes Cannes Film Festival

Roman Polanski shakes Cannes Film Festival

The director's new film, 'Venus in Fur', is one of the raciest on offer
Rev Richard Coles: 'I don’t have any concerns that God is cross with me for being gay and eventually the Church won’t either'

Rev Richard Coles on the Church and homosexuality

The mellifluous, erudite and witty Coles is the nation's most pop-culture-friendly priest
'Baghdad likes to live from crisis to crisis': Civil war looms in Iraq

Patrick Cockburn: Civil war looms in Iraq

The governor of Kirkuk - one of the country's most violent but successful provinces - fears the worst
Written on the body: Tattooists at pains to point out their artistic credentials

Written on the body

Tattooists at pains to point out their artistic credentials
Conquering Everest: 60 facts about the world's tallest mountain

Conquering Everest: 60 facts about the world's tallest mountain

The IoS marks the sixtieth anniversary of Sir Edmund Hillary and Tenzing Norgay first reaching the peak of the highest mountain on Earth
A new, and irreversible, Dust Bowl looms

Rupert Cornwell: A new, and irreversible, Dust Bowl looms

The destructive power of tornadoes will be as nothing once the Great Plains' vast underground water reserve dries up
Every creature's needless death diminshes us all

Philip Hoare: Every creature's needless death diminishes us all

A 60 per cent decline in our national species should alarm us, yet few of us act. But to mind more about animals would reflect well on society
Killing with kindness: Burma's religious battleground - and the monks at the heart of it

Killing with kindness: Burma's religious battleground

Six years ago, the world cheered the monks behind Burma’s Saffron Revolution. Now, a horrific new eruption of religious slaughter is being blamed on a 'Buddhist Bin Laden'.
Let's take it outside: Bill Granger's Bank Holiday feast

Let's take it outside: Bill Granger's Bank Holiday feast

You can’t always depend on the weather – but you can avoid the pitfalls of the British barbecue by preparing an elaborate outdoor feast indoors ahead of time...
The Calvin report: Stirring Champions League final shows how far English game must advance

The Calvin report

Stirring Champions League final shows how far English game must advance
10 big questions for the British & Irish Lions to answer

10 big questions for the British & Irish Lions to answer

Warren Gatland's squad fly Down Under aiming to do justice to the expectations – and hoping the Wallabies stay in the pub
The Last Word: Golf must end the hypocrisy before its halo slips totally

The Last Word

Golf must end the hypocrisy before its halo slips totally