Welcome to the new Independent website. We hope you enjoy it and we value your feedback. Please contact us here.


Letter: Trauma part of a police constable's job

Sir: According to Rosemary Telford and John Wright (letter, 7 April), "43 per cent of American soldiers exposed to the Vietnam war zone were identified as having high levels of psychiatric disorders more than 10 years later". Forty-three per cent is nearly half. Nearly one of two!

I have known hundreds of Vietnam war veterans and the percentage of those having any trauma is very, very low. I am a veteran of that war myself. I also flew as aircrew in combat in the Second World War and know that most combat veterans experienced few problems. Most people "recover" quite handily and resume their normal life after this war or any catastrophe.

If these claims were true, 43 per cent of the British civilians who survived the horror of the Second World War bombing would still be walking around in a daze. On the contrary, when the war ended, most people put those horrors behind them and resumed their normal lives. My experiences with German civilians have been the same. They resumed their normal lives without great difficulty.

Most sincerely,


London N3

10 April