While there is nothing wrong with the principle that people who accept benefit accept a corresponding obligation to look for work, a total denial of benefit is unacceptable in a civilised society. It reduces people to a position where they cannot legally make a living, and must therefore be either an invitation to crime or a back-door death penalty.
We will understand this proposal much better if we identify it as a proposal for conscription. Conscription should be backed by the sanction of imprisonment, not of the death penalty. Also, as Bill Clinton should have realised, it must contain provision for conscientious objection. I would not back such a proposal, but I would find it less objectionable than the version outlined in your report.
House of LordsReuse content