Find by writer
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
- Rebecca Armstrong
- Memphis Barker
- Max Benwell
- Chris Blackhurst
- Ian Burrell
- Andrew Buncombe
- Ben Chu
- Patrick Cockburn
- Mary Dejevsky
- Grace Dent
- Robert Fisk
- Andrew Grice
- Stefano Hatfield
- Lucy Hunter Johnston
- Howard Jacobson
- Alice Jones
- Ellen E Jones
- Simon Kelner
- Lisa Markwell
- Michael McCarthy
- Hamish McRae
- Jane Merrick
- James Moore
- Matthew Norman
- Dom Joly
- Amol Rajan
- Happy List
- Our Voices
- Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
- Terence Blacker
- Simon Carr
- Rupert Cornwell
- Sloane Crosley
- Mary Dejevsky
- Robert Fisk
- Andrew Grice
- Adrian Hamilton
- Philip Hensher
- Howard Jacobson
- Dominic Lawson
- John Lichfield
- Hamish McRae
- Matthew Norman
- Christina Patterson
- John Rentoul
- Democracy 2015
- IV Drip Archive
- If I were PM
- Scottish independence
- Save the tiger
- The state of the NHS
- Find by writer
- Arts + Ents
Thursday 1 November 2012
Letters: Poison perils for wild birds
Richard Benyon (letter, 30 October) is correct to assert that carbofuran is already banned under the law throughout the UK. However, the minister's decision not to issue an order proscribing the possession and storage of this and other pesticides used in the illegal poisoning of birds of prey is very disappointing.
Such an order could be quickly issued under existing legislation and, by providing the courts with the possibility of issuing custodial sentences rather than just fines, would provide a powerful deterrent to those intent on poisoning raptors.
Furthermore, not all pesticides used to kill birds illegally are banned substances and an order could also address this by proscribing the possession and storage of these products without legitimate purpose.
As a result of illegal persecution there is a crisis facing populations of some birds of prey in England; the hen harrier, for example, has been driven virtually to extinction. An order would provide wildlife protection officers with a valuable new tool to assist in the fight against this persecution, which existing legislation has proved powerless to stop.
We must take the minister's word that his policy decisions are never based on his own personal circumstances, but a failure to take meaningful action to curb the killing of raptors on shooting estates will inevitably lead many to question just how seriously he takes his responsibility to protect species that have traditionally been disliked by the shooting community.
Newcastle upon Tyne
Many of our current farming habits are simply a disgrace. I recently had reason to travel the east coast line from Edinburgh to King's Cross. Being a farmer myself, I like to look out of the window to see how others are getting on.
Imagine my distress, when I saw that pretty well all the post-harvest grain fields had been sprayed with Monsanto's Roundup which kills outright any green growth in the fields. To the informed eye, this turns them to a lifeless grey.
Lifeless? Certainly, because the insects and small animals that feed on that greenery are starved for weeks or even months. When one considers that this is happening right across the grain-growing acres of the British Isles, is it any wonder that in the last 20 years, our wild bird population has set off on a precipitous decline?
Another tragic farming practice is our habit of sowing winter wheat after an oil-seed rape crop. The rape nearly always produces a huge population of slugs, which in their turn eat the young wheat crop shortly before or after it appears. Our current answer is to cover these fields in slug pellets which then poison the slugs, birds and small mammals. The sadness is that very few people know about these blanket killing operations. Is it any wonder that those that do happen to know about them, are gradually moving towards organic methods of food production?
Spaunton Bank, North Yorkshire
Obsessed with a hurricane in a faraway country
I find it interesting that the media in this country are providing wall-to-wall coverage of a storm in a faraway country. I bet that in 1987 the hurricane which assaulted south-east England received nothing like this level of attention in the US. As I write on Tuesday night, the television news is still wittering on about the misfortune of a minority of the richest nation on earth. .
It is time that the media in the UK broke the thrall in which they seem to be held by the US. Does our general election get the same degree of coverage in the US that their presidential election is receiving? I doubt it, in a country where fewer than half the population have a passport.
The US is no longer the single most powerful influence on the affairs of the planet and it is high time that the rest of us who share it with them made them realise this.
Your front page headline "Shock and Awe" (31 October) is beneath you, betraying sarcasm and Schadenfreude misplaced in these circumstances.
In the wake of Hurricane Sandy, the usual suspects among The Independent's correspondents have been attributing it to man-made global warming. Sadly, weather extremes do not directly reflect identifiable changes in the Earth's energy balance – such as rises in atmospheric temperature – and the physics remains uncertain.
These events have complex causes, involving anomalies in atmospheric circulation, and a solid understanding of these is needed before reliable models can be constructed. Given insufficient observational data and coarse mathematical models, such speculative claims and unverifiable attribution bring climate science into disrepute.
Dr John Cameron
Fuel from air will not save planet
Making petrol from carbon dioxide and water vapour is not going to prevent climate change ("The scientists who turned fresh air into petrol", 19 October). Any extracted CO2 will be put back into the atmosphere when the petrol is burnt.
Greener energy sources like this are important because they will keep the lights on as fossil fuel supplies become more expensive and difficult to extract, but they would combat climate change only if they meant that huge quantities of easily and cheaply accessible oil, coal and gas stayed in the ground. That is not going to happen, and so the reality is that so-called alternative energy is actually additional energy.
To prevent the disaster of climate change, we need to invest in geoengineering: technology that artificially cools the planet. This can be funded by a financial transactions tax, agreed between the world's major economies. David Cameron needs to start working on it with other world leaders now.
The founder of Air Fuel Synthesis, Tony Marmont, has put £1m of his own money into this company to prove the technology which has been waiting to be developed. It is an engineering rather than a scientific triumph which is far from trivial, the key being the technique for sucking carbon dioxide out of the air which makes the fuel at least carbon-neutral and at best carbon-negative when renewable electricity powers the process.
Those of us who have been working on making synthetic fuel from air and water are fortunate that Tony has shown that this technique is both practical and economic. That is why Virgin Fuels and the airlines are taking such a close interest, because it means that there is no biological input and no limit on the amount of fuel that can be made.
Leon Di Marco
FSK Technology Research, London W9
New names for old cities
I was interested by Francis Herbert's letter (30 October) referring to Guy Keleny's input of 20 October about "creeping geographical correctness" in respect of foreign place names. I have to agree with Guy Keleny, because the sensitivity seems always to be one-way.
I wonder if the French will ever refer to the UK as other than "Royaume Uni", or to the River Thames rather than the "Tamise", or London not "Londres". What about calling Germany Deutschland rather than Allemagne? Perhaps we should refer to Spain as España and Italy as Italia, but I worry about what to call Greece or Serbia.
There are numerous similar examples. I remember being puzzled at the Olympics opening ceremony when the supposedly English translation of "Côte d'Ivoire" was repeated in exactly the same French instead of "Ivory Coast".
Just like political correctness, of which it is probably an offshoot, it is quite crackers.
Roxby, North Lincolnshire
Francis Herbert is correct when he highlights the march of geographical correctness in recent place-name changes. I notice that although we now call Bombay Mumbai, India has not yet renamed Bollywood as Mollywood.
Go on, spoil somebody's day
Barrie Spooner asks how he should spoil his ballot paper (letter, 31 October). I have a suggestion – which need not involve body fluids.
When a ballot paper is spoiled, the returning officer has an obligation to show it to each of the candidates. So writing on the ballot paper what you really think of them is the only guaranteed way of ensuring that each candidate will actually read it.
A parliamentary candidate once told me that a pithy comment on a spoiled ballot paper was one of the most wounding things he had ever read.
Andrew C blundy
The article by the Minister for Universities (26 October) is misleading. He claims that the increase in tuition fees will "tackle the deficit" because graduates will be providing 40 per cent of the costs. No graduates will repay any of their loan until 2015 at the earliest, and that figure of 40 per cent will not be reached for many years. It is wrong to imply that the new student loan system has any relevance to reducing the government deficit in the short or medium term.
Professor Michael W Eysenck
Roehampton University, London SW15
Name of evil
Richard Waters is correct only in part when he writes about Vlad Dracul and the Dracula saga (31 October). The word Dracul meant simply "dragon" in 15th-century Romanian. The "son of the house of the devil" translation of this word and all the diabolical connotations with Dracul and Vlad Tepes are part of the modern Romanian language, centuries after the death of Vlad Tapes in an ambush on the road between Bucarest and Giurghiu at the end of December 1476.
It's not surprising that the figures in Schiele's study for his Last Supper (review, 29 October) set about the meal "with an air of determination", seeing that it was made "in oil and tempura". Can't be doing with this new-fangled Japonism, myself. I much prefer Chardin's pastilles, or Masaccio's fresco prosecco.
Kids Company founder Camila Batmanghelidjh to quit charity and blames government's 'ugly games'
Staffordshire school bans short skirts because they're 'distracting' to male teachers and pupils
Nicola Sturgeon threatens second independence referendum over 'English votes for English laws'
Minute's silence: Wimbledon play to be delayed as the Queen, Prime Minister and country remember 38 people killed in terror attack
Greece debt crisis live: This is what will happen if Greece runs out of money and has to reinstate the drachma
Student builds his own tiny 145-square-foot home - so he can 'graduate debt-free'
£25000 - £34000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Are you looking to work for an ...
Negotiable: Recruitment Genius: This is an opportunity to join a successful an...
£45000 - £55000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An opportunity is available to ...
£16000 - £17000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This world leading specialist i...