7 best eyeshadow primers

These are hard-working products that will give your eye make-up some serious staying power

Pippa Bailey
Saturday 30 September 2017 19:47
Prime your eyelids for long-lasting colour with our selection of top picks
Prime your eyelids for long-lasting colour with our selection of top picks

It doesn’t matter how beautifully you blend if two hours later your eyeshadow has settled into the creases of your eye socket, so we’ve been testing products that show those oily lids who’s boss.

Primers come in liquid or cream formulas, which you simply sweep across your lids with the tips of your fingers as the first part of your eye make-up routine, and most are pigmented either in a skintone colour (don’t worry about matching it as it will be hidden beneath your eyeshadow) or with brightening or eyeshadow-enhancing shimmer.

All of these helped our eyeshadow (beautifully blended, of course) stay put for 16 hours.

1. Nars Smudge Proof Eyeshadow Base: £19.50, Nars

If you don’t want a coloured product, Nars’s offering is your best bet. It goes on (with a stick sponge applicator) slightly white but dries clear, completely mattifies oily lids and holds even cream eyeshadows all day.

Buy now

2. Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion: £17, Urban Decay

This is a cult product for good reason. It holds shadow on oily eyelids even in serious heat, blends out imperfections and seriously ups the intensity of eyeshadow pigmentation. It has a sponge wand applicator and comes in six shades, from caffeine (great for darker skin tones) to sin, which adds a champagne shimmer to shadow applied on top.

Buy now

3. Bare Minerals Prime Time Eyelid Primer: £16.50, Escentual

Bare Minerals’ primer comes out of the tube creamy but almost dries to a powder on your fingertips and the tiny tube with a slanted end is really easy to squeeze the right amount from. It’s quite drying so those without properly oily lids may find it hard to blend shadows on top, but it has great staying power.

Buy now

4. YSL Couture Eye Primer: £23.50, YSL Beauty

This thin, creamy base has become our go-to for sheer ease of application (it warms on your fingertips and glides over easily) and for the fact that it makes an excellent eraser for any mistakes you make applying your shadow. It also amplifies the colour of eyeshadow applied over the top and stops nude colours appearing patchy.

Buy now

5. Laura Mercier Eye Basics: £21, John Lewis

This comes in six different shades, from a brightening pale blue (less alarming than it sounds) to a warm peach, with more natural skin tone shades in between, so you can wear them alone to cover veins and redness on minimal make-up days. It’s thin and non-drying so it feels barely there on your eyes.

Buy now

6. Tom Ford Eye Primer Duo: £36, Harrods

This two-stage primer includes a cream base and a sheer powder that you pat or dust over the top, meaning that you don’t have to wait for it to dry matte before applying shadow. Considering the cream feels very thin on the fingers, it gives the most opaque pigmentation of any we tried and it also fills out fine lines; great for more mature skins.

Buy now

7. Elizabeth Arden Advanced Eye Fix Primer: £20, Escentual

Elizabeth Arden’s primer is a thick, concealer-like (though more drying) formula, that we love worn alone with a simple liquid eyeliner as much as under eyeshadow. It does particularly well holding a smokey eye.

Buy now

The Verdict: Eyeshadow primers

For its competitive price and does-what-it-says-on-the-tin simplicity, Nars’s primer gets our vote, plus it’s clear, so you don’t have to worry about shade or blending it, while Urban Decay’s range of colours and finishes is unbeatable.

IndyBest product reviews are unbiased, independent advice you can trust. On some occasions, we earn revenue if you click the links and buy the products, but we never allow this to bias our coverage. The reviews are compiled through a mix of expert opinion and real-world testing.