BBC admits it made ‘mistake’ by editing Boris Johnson footage to remove audience laughing at him
'Although there was absolutely no intention to mislead, we accept this was a mistake on our part,' spokesperson says
The BBC has admitted to making a "mistake" when it edited footage of Boris Johnson to remove the sound of an audience laughing at him.
During the Question Time special in which each of the main party leaders were questioned by the public, some of those watching in the studio could be heard laughing after the PM was asked whether he thought the "truth matters".
But in later video of the same event shown on BBC News, the laughter was removed. The edit gave rise to suggestions the video had been changed to make it less embarrassing to the Conservative leader.
While insisting it was not intended to mislead, the broadcaster has admitted the ommission was "a mistake on our part, as it didn't reflect the full reaction to Boris Johnson's answer".
"This clip from the BBC’s Question Time special, which was played in full on the News at Ten on Friday evening and on other outlets, was shortened for timing reasons on Saturday’s lunchtime bulletin, to edit out a repetitious phrase from Boris Johnson," a BBC statement said.
General election: Facts and figures
General election: Facts and figures
1/79 General election 2019 opinion polls
2/79 Estimated declaration time
3/79 'Big beasts' at risk
4/79 Smallest majorities at 2017 general election
5/79 Turnout at UK general elections
6/79 General election 2019 poll of polls
7/79 Vote shares at general elections since 1945
8/79 Seats to watch in North-west England
9/79 Women MPs at UK general elections
10/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits - Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn
11/79 Boris Johnson's campaign visits so far
12/79 Jeremy Corbyn's campaign visits so far
13/79 Pound v dollar
14/79 General election 2019 opinion polls in Wales
15/79 Seats to watch in London
16/79 Seats to watch in Wales
17/79 Seats to watch in Eastern England
18/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits so far
19/79 Seats to watch in south-east England
20/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits
21/79 Historic Labour seats at risk
22/79 Opinion polls (one week to go) v election result 2017
23/79 General election 2019 polls in Scotland
24/79 Opinion polls (one week to go) v election result 2015
25/79 Seats to watch in West Midlands
26/79 Bellwether seats
27/79 Conservative top targets
28/79 General election 2019 polls in London
29/79 Leaders' approval ratings, July-December
30/79 Seats to watch in Yorkshire
31/79 General election 2019 timetable
32/79 Labour top targets
33/79 Seats to watch in north-east England
34/79 When parliamentary seats last changed hands
35/79 Seats to watch in the East Midlands
36/79 Seats to watch in south-west England
37/79 Planned increase in day-to-day departmental spending
38/79 Corporation tax rates
39/79 Opinion polls (two weeks to go) v election result 2017
40/79 Opinion polls (two weeks to go) v election result 2015
41/79
42/79 Applications to register to vote
43/79 How many women MPs could there be after the election?
44/79 General election 2019 opinion polls in Wales
45/79 A comparison of the length of the manifestos of the main parties
46/79 Mentions of key words in the main party manifestos
47/79 Mentions of key words in the main party manifestos
48/79 Leaders' approval ratings, July-November
49/79 Council houses built in the UK 1951-2018
50/79 Council houses built in the UK
51/79 Opinion polls (three weeks to go) v election result 2015
52/79 Opinion polls (three weeks to go) v election result 2017
53/79 General election 2019 target seats
54/79 Lib Dem targets
55/79 SNP targets
56/79 Plaid Cymru targets
57/79 Prime ministers with shortest time in office
58/79 Applications to register to vote
59/79 Major toll roads & bridges in Great Britain
60/79 Police workforce in England and Wales
61/79 Police officers in England and Wales
62/79 Police-recorded homicides in England and Wales
63/79 Knife crime offences recorded by police in England and Wales
64/79 Opinion polls in 2019
65/79 Number of candidates per seat
66/79 Candidates standing in the 2019 General Election
67/79 Candidates at UK general elections since 1979
68/79 Women candidates at the 2019 General Election
69/79 Prime ministers with smallest constituency majorities to defend
70/79 Cost of administering polls since 2010
71/79 People's Vote group priority list of recommended candidates in key target seats
72/79 MPs retiring from the House of Commons at general elections
73/79 Lib Dems/Plaid Cymru/Green pact in Wales
74/79 Lib Dems/Green pact in England, seats where Greens have stood down in favour of Lib Dems
75/79 Lib Dems/Green pact in England
76/79 Nationality of NHS workforce in England
77/79 Proportion of NHS workforce in England who are not UK nationals
78/79 Long-term net migration to the UK
79/79 Shortest parliamentary sessions since First World War
1/79 General election 2019 opinion polls
2/79 Estimated declaration time
3/79 'Big beasts' at risk
4/79 Smallest majorities at 2017 general election
5/79 Turnout at UK general elections
6/79 General election 2019 poll of polls
7/79 Vote shares at general elections since 1945
8/79 Seats to watch in North-west England
9/79 Women MPs at UK general elections
10/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits - Boris Johnson and Jeremy Corbyn
11/79 Boris Johnson's campaign visits so far
12/79 Jeremy Corbyn's campaign visits so far
13/79 Pound v dollar
14/79 General election 2019 opinion polls in Wales
15/79 Seats to watch in London
16/79 Seats to watch in Wales
17/79 Seats to watch in Eastern England
18/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits so far
19/79 Seats to watch in south-east England
20/79 General election 2019 leaders' visits
21/79 Historic Labour seats at risk
22/79 Opinion polls (one week to go) v election result 2017
23/79 General election 2019 polls in Scotland
24/79 Opinion polls (one week to go) v election result 2015
25/79 Seats to watch in West Midlands
26/79 Bellwether seats
27/79 Conservative top targets
28/79 General election 2019 polls in London
29/79 Leaders' approval ratings, July-December
30/79 Seats to watch in Yorkshire
31/79 General election 2019 timetable
32/79 Labour top targets
33/79 Seats to watch in north-east England
34/79 When parliamentary seats last changed hands
35/79 Seats to watch in the East Midlands
36/79 Seats to watch in south-west England
37/79 Planned increase in day-to-day departmental spending
38/79 Corporation tax rates
39/79 Opinion polls (two weeks to go) v election result 2017
40/79 Opinion polls (two weeks to go) v election result 2015
41/79
42/79 Applications to register to vote
43/79 How many women MPs could there be after the election?
44/79 General election 2019 opinion polls in Wales
45/79 A comparison of the length of the manifestos of the main parties
46/79 Mentions of key words in the main party manifestos
47/79 Mentions of key words in the main party manifestos
48/79 Leaders' approval ratings, July-November
49/79 Council houses built in the UK 1951-2018
50/79 Council houses built in the UK
51/79 Opinion polls (three weeks to go) v election result 2015
52/79 Opinion polls (three weeks to go) v election result 2017
53/79 General election 2019 target seats
54/79 Lib Dem targets
55/79 SNP targets
56/79 Plaid Cymru targets
57/79 Prime ministers with shortest time in office
58/79 Applications to register to vote
59/79 Major toll roads & bridges in Great Britain
60/79 Police workforce in England and Wales
61/79 Police officers in England and Wales
62/79 Police-recorded homicides in England and Wales
63/79 Knife crime offences recorded by police in England and Wales
64/79 Opinion polls in 2019
65/79 Number of candidates per seat
66/79 Candidates standing in the 2019 General Election
67/79 Candidates at UK general elections since 1979
68/79 Women candidates at the 2019 General Election
69/79 Prime ministers with smallest constituency majorities to defend
70/79 Cost of administering polls since 2010
71/79 People's Vote group priority list of recommended candidates in key target seats
72/79 MPs retiring from the House of Commons at general elections
73/79 Lib Dems/Plaid Cymru/Green pact in Wales
74/79 Lib Dems/Green pact in England, seats where Greens have stood down in favour of Lib Dems
75/79 Lib Dems/Green pact in England
76/79 Nationality of NHS workforce in England
77/79 Proportion of NHS workforce in England who are not UK nationals
78/79 Long-term net migration to the UK
79/79 Shortest parliamentary sessions since First World War
"However, in doing so we also edited out laughter from the audience.
"Although there was absolutely no intention to mislead, we accept this was a mistake on our part, as it didn’t reflect the full reaction to Boris Johnson’s answer. We did not alter the soundtrack or image in any way apart from this edit, contrary to some claims on social media.”
It comes after the BBC apologised for showing old footage of Mr Johnson at the Cenotaph during Remembrance Sunday events.
During a news bulletin, video of Mr Johnson laying a flower arrangement the wrong way up was edited out, and old footage was posted instead.
It blamed the change on a "production error" and apologised for the error.
Comments
Share your thoughts and debate the big issues
Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Newest first
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Oldest first
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Most liked
{{/moreThanOne}}Please be respectful when making a comment and adhere to our Community Guidelines.
You can find our Community Guidelines in full here.
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Newest first
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Oldest first
- -1) ? 'active' : ''">
Most liked
{{/moreThanOne_p}}Follow comments
Vote
Report Comment
Subscribe to Independent Premium to debate the big issues
Want to discuss real-world problems, be involved in the most engaging discussions and hear from the journalists? Start your Independent Premium subscription today.
Already registered? Log inReport Comment
Delete Comment
About The Independent commenting
Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. It allows our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences, discuss real-world solutions, and more. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium. The most insightful comments on all subjects will be published daily in dedicated articles. You can also choose to be emailed when someone replies to your comment.
The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. Due to the sheer scale of this comment community, we are not able to give each post the same level of attention, but we have preserved this area in the interests of open debate. Please continue to respect all commenters and create constructive debates.