General Election 2015: Ed Miliband and David Cameron go head-to-head tomorrow night

Labour leader opted to go second in debate

Andrew Grice@IndyPolitics
Wednesday 25 March 2015 20:30
The two main party leaders will be interviewed separately on Thursday night's programme
The two main party leaders will be interviewed separately on Thursday night's programme

Ed Miliband has won the first skirmish in the televised battle between the party leaders ahead of the May general election.

Labour won a toss of the coin on Sunday to decide whether Mr Miliband or David Cameron could choose to go first or last in the 90-minute live programme to be screened by both Sky News and Channel 4 at 9pm tonight. The Labour leader opted to go second, believing it would be an advantage to have the last word.

The running order

Jeremy Paxman, the former presenter of BBC’s Newsnight, will kick off “The Battle for Number 10” programme by interviewing Mr Cameron for up to 18 minutes. Then the Prime Minister will take questions from a studio audience for the same length of time. This session will be moderated by Kay Burley, the Sky News presenter.

Kay Burley and Jeremy Paxman at rehearsals ahead of 'The Battle For Number 10'

Then it will be Mr Miliband’s turn to take the audience’s questions before he is interviewed by Mr Paxman. The leaders’ aides will then swing into action in the “spin room” at the London venue as they try to convince the watching journalists their man has won – whatever his performance.

Is it a debate?

Not really. At the 2010 election, Britain saw its first three TV leaders’ debates, in which Mr Cameron, Nick Clegg and Gordon Brown took audience questions and debated with each other. During fraught negotiations ahead of this year’s election, it was clear that Mr Cameron did not want to go head-to-head with Mr Miliband, as the broadcasters wanted. With the Labour leader’s ratings so poor, the Tories judged he could get a boost if he surprised voters by doing well. Labour is frustrated by tonight’s format, saying it is “ludicrous" that Mr Cameron and Mr Miliband would take questions from the same audience, but not debate face-to-face, and accusing the Prime Minister of "cowardice".

Labour is wary of Mr Paxman’s involvement. He has described himself as a “One Nation Tory”, was approached to be the Tory candidate in next year’s election for Mayor of London and has said he senses the election is “running the Tories’ way”. But he may surprise his Labour critics.

Other programmes

On 2 April, a seven-way debate on ITV will include Mr Cameron, Mr Miliband, Mr Clegg, the Ukip leader Nigel Farage, the Greens’ leader Natalie Bennett, the SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon and the Plaid Cymru leader Leanne Wood.

On 16 April, the five opposition party leaders – without Mr Cameron and Mr Clegg — will debate on the BBC. The Tories have dubbed this “the night of the nonentities”.

On 30 April, Mr Cameron, Mr Miliband and Mr Clegg will appear on a special edition of the BBC’s “Question Time”, but they will not be on screen together.


Mr Miliband has been holding intensive preparations for the TV debates since before Christmas. Alastair Campbell, who was Tony Blair’s communications chief, played the role of Mr Cameron in rehearsals. But the Prime Minister’s refusal to go head-to-Ed means that Labour has had to adjust its sights, with aides working out likely questions from interviewers and the studio audiences. Mr Cameron is thought to have spent less time preparing – not least because Tory strategists were hoping there would be no agreement on any leaders’ programmes.

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments