'Gang of Four' could decide Obama's fate after May primaries

By Leonard Doyle
Sunday 23 October 2011 08:00
Barack Obama is favoured to win the primaries in Indiana and North Carolina on 6 May
Barack Obama is favoured to win the primaries in Indiana and North Carolina on 6 May

Barack Obama's hopes of emerging as the first black Democratic presidential nominee could now depend on top party officials intervening to stop the fight with Hillary Clinton in the name of unity.

The focus of the Democratic race has shifted to Indiana and North Carolina where Mr Obama is favoured to win in the early May primaries. But victory in these states will still leave him short of winning the nomination and allow the damaging battle with Mrs Clinton to continue through the summer. A defeat could be fatal for his chances.

One idea being floated is for a so-called Gang of Four – comprising the former presidential hopeful John Edwards; the former vice-president Al Gore; the Democratic Party leader Howard Dean; and the House speaker Nancy Pelosi – to intervene after the primaries on 6 May. They would then call on the superdelegates to make a commitment within 10 days so that the party can have a nominee before the August convention in Denver. At that stage, the Obama campaign hopes to have won 2,025 delegates, enough to secure him the nomination. Mrs Clinton could still thwart him if she persuades enough superdelegates to back her on the grounds that she is a tougher, more effective candidate who would carry more states in the presidential race.

If Mr Obama cannot break through the submerged racial prejudice of older white voters, the argument of many Democrats goes, he cannot win the White House. Time magazine's commentator Joe Klein said poorly educated white voters have grave doubts "about a young, inexperienced African-American guy with an Islamic-sounding name and a highfalutin fluency with language".

Despite her solid victory in Pennsylvania on Tuesday, Mrs Clinton remains in an uphill struggle in Indiana where Mr Obama has a slight edge in the polls. One advantage Mr Obama has going into the race is that Indiana's population is concentrated in the smaller cities like Gary, where he has a high profile. He is also expected to take North Carolina, a Southern state with a large black population.

However, Mrs Clinton is now waging a battle to persuade the remaining uncommitted superdelegates that his consistent failure to defeat her in the big states, such as Pennsylvania, New York and California, makes him a weaker candidate for the November presidential election.

Mrs Clinton raised enough doubts about Mr Obama in Pennsylvania to persuade white working-class voters to hand her a nine-percentage point victory. A big part of Mr Obama's problem is race. The exit polls in Pennsylvania revealed that 20 per cent of voters think race is important and heavily backed Mrs Clinton.

Mr Obama tried gamely to make a connection with working-class white voters, downing beers and large quantities of greasy food. He was mocked for his incompetence on the bowling alley, but far more damaging in the eyes of white voters was his association with his hot-headed former pastor Jeremiah Wright.

Asked whether race was a factor in the race, David Axelrod, Mr Obama's senior political adviser, said: "I'm sure there is some of that." He went on to say that Mrs Clinton's biggest advantage had been among older voters, "and I think there is a general inclination on the part of the older voters to vote for what is more familiar". He added: "Here's a guy named Barack Obama, an African-American guy, relatively new. That's a lot of change."

Mr Axelrod sought to play down the importance of working-class voters, saying they had largely abandoned the Democrats in recent elections. Mr Obama's appeal among black people, young voters, independents and even some Republicans would be more significant. "Let's understand – the white working class has gone to the Republican nominee for many elections," said Mr Axelrod. "This is not new. Democratic candidates don't rely solely on those votes."

For rolling comment on the US election visit: independent.co.uk/campaign08

Join our new commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

View comments