Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Number of countries criminalising sex between lesbian and bisexual women increasing , human rights lawyers warn

A report into criminalisation of same-sex relationships between women has warned 'corrective rape', forced marriages and other forms of violence are still commonly used against lesbian and bisexual women around the world

Siobhan Fenton
Saturday 14 May 2016 17:00 BST
Comments
A coroner has found serious failings over Ashley Gill's death in prison in April 2015
A coroner has found serious failings over Ashley Gill's death in prison in April 2015 (Reuters)

It is illegal to be a bisexual or lesbian woman in 1 in 4 countries around the world and the number is growing, research has revealed.

A total of 44 countries criminalise sex between consenting adult women and of these at least ten countries which have previously only criminalised male relationships have recently expanded their laws to include women. Many of the laws were first instigated under British colonial rule and others are based on Sharia law. The report has been released by the Human Dignity Trust, a pro-bono organisation comprised of international lawyers providing legal advice to people in countries where homosexuality or bisexuality is illegal.

The Trust warns that while many countries have historically only criminalised male homosexuality due to the legacy of British colonial penal codes, increased international criticism of the laws is having the counter-intuitive effect of laws being expanded to include women as states believe the legal basis is strengthened if they are gender neutral and therefore more 'equal'.

The report finds: "Ironically, such amendments [to criminalise women] are often made on the inaccurate premise of ensuring non-discrimination in the State's treatment of male and female homosexuals. A Botswana court found that a gross indecency law that only applied to male homosexuals, and not female homosexuals, was discriminatory, but that the discrimination was rectified when the provision was made gender-neutral. Similarly, a court in Solomon Islands found that the male gross indecency law was discriminatory since women were not criminalised, but found that this would be rectified by removing the word 'male'."

Corrective rape is found to be common as a way of 'curing' women of same-sex attraction and forced marriages with men are also a continuing threat

&#13; <p>Human Dignity Trust</p>&#13;

The report warns that while reports on LGBT criminalisation can often focus on gay and bisexual men, women experience criminalisation in specific and particularly damaging ways as they suffer from the dual effects of misogyny and bi/homophobia. Corrective rape is found to be common as a way of 'curing' women of same-sex attraction and forced marriages with men are also a continuing threat. As social and economic structures are already designed to require women to be dependent on men, women can experience particular stigma and practical issues if seeking to live independently outside of a 'traditional' relationship or with another woman. Another concern highlighted in the report is how restrictions on women's movement in socially conservative countries can often mean it is forbidden for women to travel without a man, making it difficult for women to meet in private.

Restrictions on women's movement in socially conservative countries can often mean it is forbidden for women to travel without a man, making it difficult for women to meet in private.

&#13; <p>Human Dignity Trust</p>&#13;

"Women in general are disadvantaged economically in many societies, for example by inequality in family structures, labour markets and laws on property and inheritance, which in turn compound the human rights violations faced by lesbians and bisexual women as they are less able to live independently without male family members. Women [pressured into sham 'heterosexual' marriages] are likely to have significantly less control over their own bodies than gay men who enter sham heterosexual marriages, and may have little control over their sexual and reproductive health choices.

"Lesbians and bisexual women are also particularly vulnerable to violence, control and abuse within their own families and by people they know. They frequently experience targeted rape, through which abusers purport to correct a victim's sexual orientation. Much of the research, advocacy and legal discourse around the criminalisation and persecution of LGBT people worldwide has to date inadvertently focussed on the situation of gay and bisexual men. This means that the unique situation of lesbians and bisexual women has not been properly addressed in legal responses to criminalisation."

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in