Sign up to Miguel Delaney’s Reading the Game newsletter sent straight to your inbox for free Sign up to Miguel’s Delaney’s free weekly newsletter
Manchester United surprised many with their performance against Bayern Munich at Old Trafford last night.
With the favourites to win this season's Champions League arriving at the soon-to-be-disposed champions of England, many expected David Moyes' side to take a battering and suffer yet another home defeat to add to the many their fans have seen already this season.
However, Nemanja Vidic gave Manchester United the lead before Bastian Schweinsteiger struck an equaliser for the visitors. Finishing at 1-1, the tie is poised delicately before next week's second-leg at the Allianz Arena.
But will Bayern's away goal prove crucial and what are United's chance of reaching the semi-finals? The evidence is conflicting.
In all European Cup history, after the first-leg was drawn 1-1, the away team in the second-leg has progressed 74.5 per cent of the time. On that basis, last night's result looks a good one for Manchester United.
However, in the 11 first-legs in which Bayern Munich have drawn 1-1, the German side have gone on to progress in EVERY single one of them. Ominous.
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player RatingsShow all 22 1 /22Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings David de Gea 7 Spaniard was not called on a great deal despite Bayern’s monopolising of possession but made important flying stop from Robben on the half hour
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Phil Jones 6 England utility man looked woefully out of place up against mesmeric Robben and Ribery before being moved out to left-back when Buttner went off
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Rio Ferdinand 8 Confident beginning and put in easily his best performance of the season. Calm in possession and won crucial challenges to keep United in contention
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Nemanja Vidic 8 Important tackle on Muller inside area and back to something resembling his best. Towering header briefly gave United hope of an unlikely first-leg lead
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Alexander Buttner 7 Brought in to replace the suspended Patrice Evra, not afraid to dive in and conducted himself well. Handled in area but a case of ball to hand
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Michael Carrick 6 Calm as ever in possession and careful with passing but effect paled at times. Slow to close down Bayern attacks as visitors dominated the middle
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Ryan Giggs 5 Last night was his 141st appearance in the competition and did most of his meaningful work helping out defence. Taken off at half-time
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Marouane Fellaini 5 Much-maligned Belgian struggled in both the air and on the ground but stuck to his task. Lost Schweinsteiger for goal that cost United the victory
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Antonio Valencia 6 Harshly booked for late tackle on Lahm before surviving a second when going in on Boateng. Positive in possession, had one cross-shot deflected over
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Danny Welbeck 6 Penalised for high feet when finding the net from 15 yards in opening minutes. Endured his Geoff Thomas moment when clean through before break
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Wayne Rooney 6 As so often this season, left marooned at times as United struggled to keep the ball. Kept to task and corner set up Vidic to open the scoring
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Manuel Neuer 7 Stood up well to Welbeck when forward was played clean through before the break. Quick off his line but caught wrong footed by Vidic header
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings David Alaba 6 Enjoyed evening in effectively a right wing position and provided steady stream of ammunition for the visitors. Mainly a successful night in defence too
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Jerome Boateng 7 Offered muscular presence and dealt well with Rooney. Mistake allowed Welbeck clean run on Neuer and caught late by Valencia in the second half
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Javi Martinez 6 Deployed in relatively unfamiliar role at back. Beaten by Welbeck early on before reprieve. Resorted to dragging Hernandez back late on, earning a ban
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Rafinha 6 Like his fellow full-back the Brazilian spent much of the evening further forward and it was his arching cross that generated the equaliser
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Philipp Lahm 6 Caught by Valencia which earned Ecuadorian a booking. Popped up in all the right places, with one vital block on a Rooney effort
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Bastian Schweinsteiger 7 Easily bossed midfield against weak opposition. Classy finish gave Bayern crucial away goal but blotted copybook with late dismissal, albeit a little harsh
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Toni Kroos 6 Covered a lot of ground but struggled to influence as he did on his last visit to England at the Emirates in February. Saw shot blocked by Vidic
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Franck Ribery 6 Happy to sit back on wing and dictate matters, his partnership with Robben was a constant threat. Tired late on as Bayern forced to settle for a draw
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Arjen Robben 7 Linked up well with Ribery and twice went close in opening exchanges. Forced fine save from De Gea and dragged wide of keeper’s post late on
GETTY IMAGES
Manchester United 1 Bayern Munich 1: Player Ratings Thomas Muller 6 Just beaten to ball by Vidic underneath the United crossbar. Not able to make most of Bayern’s midfield promptings before being replaced
GETTY IMAGES
Speaking after last night's match Bayern manager Pep Guardiola admitted the result at Old Trafford wasn't ideal for his team, but sounded confident his side would progress .
"It is always dangerous when you go into the second leg with a 1-1 draw, but even a 2-1 victory would have been dangerous. We will try to win the second leg and I am sure we can do it. I have full confidence in my players and hope the fans in Munich will push us like the United supporters did for their team today."
The 1-1 scoreline means that Manchester United must score at the Allianz Arena. The teams meet again next Wednesday.
Join our commenting forum
Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies