Viewers were left baffled and amused as Erivo was not given a scoring paddle and only commented on performances, leading to awkward on-screen positioning.
Fans on social media platforms like X/Twitter commented that she looked "like a competition winner" or "like a lemon" without a paddle.
Erivo's appearance on the show comes ahead of the 21 November release of Wicked: For Good, in which she stars as Elphaba.
Separately, contestant Stefan Dennis was absent due to illness but automatically advanced, and Thomas Skinner was the first celebrity eliminated from the 2025 series.