Oxford, £35, 598pp. £31.50 from the Independent Bookshop: 08430 600 030
The White Man's World, By Bill Schwarz
Friday 27 January 2012
Latest in Reviews
Historians – and sometimes politicians or a wider public – argue ever more fiercely over what entailments, if any, empire and its end have for us today. Some vehemently deny that they are at all important. The strongest counter-arguments have often centred on ideas about race, and how they shape the collective imaginings, political rhetoric and cultural workings of national life, of Britishness and Englishness.
It has regularly been asserted that the crucial point of connection and contestation was the "moment" of Enoch Powell in April 1968, with his notorious "Rivers of Blood" speech. But that assertion and its denials have usually been more a matter of polemic than reflection. Nobody had deeply studied the multiple historical roots of that moment, its connections to the whole intricate story of Britain's postwar global decline and internal transformations, nor its manifold consequences. Until now.
Why was the popular response to Powell so huge and passionate? How did it illuminate deeper currents of social change, the loss of empire, the febrile vauntings and hidden anxieties about what it meant to be "white", and to be a man? Bill Schwarz in this book finds many of the answers in the experience, and imagery, of whites on the frontiers of imperial settler societies - the "white man's countries". "Powellism" was in significant part about the reworking of these experiences within Britain.
One of the main themes both in Powell's speech, and in reactions to it, was the idea that the British nation was under threat of destruction: stabbed in the back by a treacherous ruling elite - Macmillan, Macleod, Wilson, Heath, Major - betraying race and nation. It was a malign fantasy, but had a powerful collective appeal, to which the idea of whiteness, indeed of a white world, was central.
The ideas went far back into the 19th century, at least as far as Rider Haggard or Cecil Rhodes, but were renewed first in post-1950s settler populism on the shrinking frontiers, then at home. Britain had become too prosperous, urbanised, civilised, idle – indeed too "feminine" - to live up to the ideals of a proper white man's country. As ideas of "the white man" came to an end in the colonies, they were reborn in Britain.
Britain itself was ceasing to be truly, fully British: the best elements in "the British character" could no longer flourish there. Mass non-white immigration, loss of empire, the threat of "going into Europe" (Schwarz could perhaps have integrated this last more fully) together formed a true axis of evil. Ideas and fantasies of race entered into the intimate textures of everyday life in post-war Britain. Schwarz finds them persisting and renewing themselves in domestic political developments from the 1970s to the present.
The White Man's World is to be the first of three volumes, under the general title Memories of Empire. In the sequels, Schwarz will be enriching, and extending, the already remarkable range and depth of argument found here. He will be looking especially at how the historic encounters between Britain and the Caribbean have shaped both, and how the ideas of an array of West Indian-born artists and theorists illuminate the British present and possible futures.
He will also probe further the notions of empire, decolonisation and nation, of historical memory, of national consciousness and collective unconscious – thus pushing at the limits of our historical and political imagination. The White Man's World is already the finest, most original work on these themes I have read. It also whets the appetite for what the rest of the trilogy will bring.
Stephen Howe is professor of the history and cultures of colonialism at Bristol University
- 1 Last bow for Blur at Brit awards?
- 2 BANNED: The most controversial films
- 3 The sci-fi movie Hollywood would not dare to make
- 4 Picture preview: Charline von Heyl, Tate Liverpool
- 5 The artist vandalising advertising with poetry
- 6 Adam Deacon: Streetwise star who knows the score
- 7 The Ten Best History Books
- 1 Last bow for Blur at Brit awards?
- 2 How an A-grade prank by a hacker closed a school for a day
- 3 Copenhagen, probably the best city in the world
- 4 Robert Fisk: 'If only Hague and Clinton would listen to Yusuf Islam'
- 5 How did a man buried in this frozen car for two months come out of it alive?
- 6 The sci-fi movie Hollywood would not dare to make
- 7 Ian McKellen: What's wrong with us? Should we not aspire to happiness?
- 8 Mark Steel: Iraq was such a laugh, let's do it to Iran
- 9 Aborted baby lived 45 minutes
- 10 Journalists killed in Syria rocket strike 'were targeted'
Win an adventure with Subaru XV
Enjoy a three-night family adventure for four to Slaley Hall in Northumberland.
Delivering network infrastructure for London 2012
Cisco is maximising connectivity for the Olympic and Paralympic Games.
Free trial of our new iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
Can we pull the plug on the plug?
The 10 Best Lecture Series
Michael Frayn: Still making a big noise



Comments