Films

Partly Sunny with Showers 5° London Hi 6°C / Lo 1°C

This Is It, Odeon Leicester Square, London

(Rated 2/ 5 )

No thriller, this is just bad

Reviewed by Kaleem Aftab

The unprecedented 1am start to this London premiere was timed to ensure Michael Jackson's This is It could land in 20 countries simultaneously. It was rather fitting that when the cameras broadcasting footage to the hordes of fans in Leicester Square broke down, shots from the red carpet in Los Angeles were shown instead, connecting the place that Michael Jackson died with the British capital where the This Is It concerts were due to take place from July of this year.

Kenny Ortega, the man who was directing the stage show, is handed the director's credit here and it's no surprise that This Is It portrays Michael Jackson in a favourable light. The action is comprised almost solely of the singer, in various guises, rehearsing for the ill-fated concerts between April and June of this year. Ortega has attempted, as much as possible, to show what the concerts would have looked like. It starts with a written reminder of when the action takes place before opening with a number of young dancers talking excitedly about the prospect of working with the so-called King of Pop. It's a touching moment, and a reminder that behind all the brouhaha of Jackson's death there were many people, fans and professionals, who had their dreams shattered.

This proves a rare moment of interview material as Ortega decides to concentrate on footage of Jackson rehearsing, starting with "Wanna Be Startin' Somethin'". This obvious choice of song is quickly followed by footage of the singer announcing his comeback tour in which he stated that he's going to give the fans what he believed they wanted: a concert jammed full of his most popular tunes.

Video: This Is It, behind the scenes

The tone of the movie is set with songs being cut together from performances from different rehearsal dates. It's soon clear as the movie trots out hits such as "The Way You Make Me Feel" that the singer was a long way from his heyday. There are only fleeting moments of great dancing before the inevitable jump cut arrives as the four editors who worked on the film attempt to sculpt a performance.

There is no attempt to get inside the mind of Jackson à la Martin Bashir. The cameramen also seem somewhat shy of Jackson, not getting too close. As a concert film – using footage which was by-and-large shot for Jackson's personal use – this is a failure.

The concert was apparently going to have a very strong environmental message as Jackson talks about his love of trees. What the film does not do, or even try to do, is provide any information that would give an insight into the circumstances surrounding the musician's death. The last song we're shown Jackson singing is "Man in the Mirror"; it's a shame the filmmakers did not take a cue from its lyrics to put together an uncompromising assessment of Jackson, rather than delivering another attempt to perpetuate the myth.

'This Is It' is being screened nationwide

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Ridiculous
[info]dm7799 wrote:
Thursday, 29 October 2009 at 03:26 pm (UTC)
This is probably the most ridiculous review I've ever read. This was rehearsal footage intended for Michael Jackson's private library, and as a reference point for analysis of the show and what might need changing as they continue to prepare. What exactly were you expecting? A Martin Bashir-esque documentary, delving into the mind of Michael Jackson so that you can once again revel in criticising the man? 90% of reviews I have read for this film since it was released yesterday, which is a lot, have been overwhelmingly positive. The vast majority who have watched the film acknowledge Jackson's incredible talent and agree that the concerts would have been spectacular. Review this for what it is - rehearsal footage.
[info]ipn427 wrote:
Thursday, 29 October 2009 at 11:13 pm (UTC)
What a ridiculous and childish riview! You said that the footage was shot for Jackson's personal use, then you go on to say that they should have interviewed Jackson more vigorously... Why, if the footage was for his personal use? Given that the fotage wasmade into a film secifillybcasehdid without bei bltperfom th concert,should Ortega have interviewed Jackson (ala Bashir) AFTER HIS DEATH?

How di you get the job of a reviewer?
[info]ipn427 wrote:
Thursday, 29 October 2009 at 11:21 pm (UTC)
SORRY FOR THE TYPO

What a ridiculous and childish riview! You said that the footage was shot for Jackson's personal use, then you go on to say that they should have interviewed Jackson more vigorously... Why, if the footage was for his personal use? Given that the footage was made into a film only because Jackson died before the concert, should Ortega have interviewed Jackson (ala Bashir) AFTER HIS DEATH?

How did you get the job of a reviewer, anyway?
[info]ivannia wrote:
Tuesday, 3 November 2009 at 08:23 am (UTC)
I think you've completely misunderstood this movie. The greatness of this film lies in the fact that it DOES NOT mention anything about the circumstances surrounding his death. I would have hated the movie if it would have been like that, the movie is not supposed to be another way for the tabloids to get their say; how he died and why had absolutely nothing to do with this.


Somebody once told me that two people can't disagree if they're not speaking of the same thing. This is why I don't disagree with you - you are right, the movie did not attempt to get up-close and personal. But I do believe you as a journalist have made a fool out of yourself, seeing that you are the only person on the planet that has misunderstood the true purpose of this picture.
review
[info]rfk68 wrote:
Thursday, 12 November 2009 at 02:59 am (UTC)
Man are you off base on this one. Sounds like you went into the screening room with a chip on your shoulder not to like it. I don't see how any objective screener, reviewer, or just theatre goer could not have been moved and blown away by this dynamic film. The dancing, music, performances, stage props, everything about this film was a stunner. One would have to have blinders on to have felt otherwise. Please, remove that chip and see this film again more objectively. You are in a very small minority on this one and rightfully so. I am not, nor have a ever been a major Michael Jackson fan. But I believe in giving a man his due when it is do, and with "This Is It", Michael is due all the plaudits, raves and commendations he earns from this work. What was you looking for that you didn't see my friend?
[info]member00010 wrote:
Tuesday, 1 December 2009 at 01:05 pm (UTC)

The review said nothing about interviewing jackson. It commemnted that the movie or rather 'documentary' (that is what it was. A documentary about the final jackson concert.) did not offer any insight concerning jackson's hopes or intentions for his concert. Documentaries are supposed to dig deep into the underlying story and offer up differnt insights and points of view about the subject matter. Instead it has been hailed as some great movie about the 'former king of pop' that should be viewed by all, but there is no reason to view the darn thing. It's just a mosh pot of clips designed to brown nose.... or white nose, this poor soul who lived outside the box of reality. People wanted Substance, not just a bunch of dancing singing and praise. There should have been an attempt to delve into the creative work and show the viewer that jackson was still capable of putting together a work of art through the use of personal footage rather that edited best parts chosen to create a final piece. It was supposed to be about the creative blood, sweat and tears. Not just another too long music video for die hard fans to tap a foot to, and sing praises.

Grow up people, and try to look at thing more objectively. Stop trying to defend a percieved wrong.

Most popular

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date