Stay up to date with notifications from The Independent

Notifications can be managed in browser preferences.

Cornish pasty 'was invented by cookery teachers in London'

Food historian says pasties in Cornwall were almost always vegetarian

Jess Staufenberg
Sunday 30 August 2015 18:14 BST
Comments
Peter Brears says pasties should not have special EU protection to only be made in Cornwall
Peter Brears says pasties should not have special EU protection to only be made in Cornwall (Getty Images)

The humble Cornish pasty, so closely associated with pirates and the West Country, was actually the brainwave of urban middle classes in London.

That is according to leading food historian Peter Brears, who has said the foodstuff should not have special EU protection to only be made in Cornwall.

In an article for food studies journal Petits Propos Culinaires, Mr Brear said pasties in Cornwall were almost always vegetarian - whereas the Cornish pasty is classically filled with mince.

According to the Western Morning News, he wrote: "Always containing red meat, its use was spread throughout the entire country by London-trained cookery teachers who invented the term 'Cornish pasty'."

Cornish pasty: A case of London doing some cultural ripping off? (Getty)

"[The pasties] did not originate in Cornwall and although they drew their inspiration from those enjoyed by tourists to the county, were quite different from the true pasties of Cornwall in a number of ways," he continued.

Taking a large, hefty vegetarian pastry item, Londoners apparently created daintier versions filled only with the classic meat, onion and potato filling.

"[...] Most importantly, they were tiny, only a couple of inches across," he said in the journal. "These were not intended to feed a miner or an agricultural labourer but to make an economical savoury nibble for polite middle-class Victorians."

The Yorkshire-born food writer, who has written 27 books, also said the EU law which only lets pasties made in Cornwall be called "Cornish pasties" has "bemused most Brits".

The Western Morning News said Mr Brears explained in the journal that people in Yorkshire would not expect Yorkshire puddings only to be made there.

Join our commenting forum

Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies

Comments

Thank you for registering

Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in