Fragmented care system is failing elderly, MPs warn

Select Committee urges integration of health, care and housing budgets to protect the vulnerable

Suggested Topics

Elderly patients are suffering a "diminished quality of life" because the enormous pressures on the social-care system mean they are not receiving the help they need, a committee of MPs warns today.

The Government's controversial Health and Social Care Bill will do nothing to integrate the current fragmented and failing system, the report by the Health Select Committee found.

The transfer of £2bn from health to social care had been "welcome" but was "not sufficient to maintain adequate levels of service quality and efficiency", it concluded.

Cuts to support for the elderly are putting the NHS under unnecessary strain as "too much is spent treating preventable injuries like falls, which can have a catastrophic impact on the lives of older people", it warned.

The report called for a radical overhaul of the system to allow social care, health, housing and welfare budgets to be pooled to stop vulnerable people being from one department to another.

Stephen Dorrell, chairman of the Health Select Committee, said: "It is impossible to deliver either high quality or efficient services when the patient is passed like a parcel from one part of the system to another, without any serious attempt to look at their needs in the round.

"The funding for NHS care, social care and social housing comes from different sources. Our central recommendation is that the key to joined-up services is joined-up commissioning.

"We recommend the Government place a duty on the new clinical commissioning groups and local councils to create a single commissioning process for older people's health, care and housing services in their area."

The committee suggests the current failure to link up provision across the services has led to more hospital admissions, longer hospital stays and poorer outcomes for patients.

MPs warned that "funding pressures" are causing reductions in service levels "which are leading to diminished quality of life for elderly people and increased demand for NHS services".

The committee concluded it came "as a great shock to many people that whilst the care and treatment provided by the NHS is free, care services are means-tested and many people will have to pay for them."

It called on the Government to accept the "principle" of a cap in costs following the recommendation last year by the Dilnot Commission for the state to step in when bills rise above £35,000 for any individual.

Richard Humphries, senior fellow at the King's Fund health think-tank, said: "Successive governments have talked about the need to integrate health and social care but have failed to make it happen. The time for warm words and good intentions has passed."

Michelle Mitchell director general of Age UK said: "The Government should act urgently and implement the Dilnot funding reforms, update social care law, and bring health and social care much closer together.

The Care Services minister Paul Burstow said the Government would respond to the report and the Dilnot Commission this spring with a White Paper on reforming adult social care.

He said: "Integrated care should be the norm."

Case study: Without more funds, people will suffer

David Gower, 76, lives in sheltered accommodation. He has a neurological problem which has left him with severe mobility problems and restricted movement in his hands and relies on carers four times a day

"My condition means I am very restricted in my movement. My local authority has already cut down my home care service as much as it can. It's a real rush for the carers because my mobility is so restricted.

I've seen a big increase to the charges I pay for the care. If this goes on, within 12 months I won't have anything left. The system needs to be better funded or a lot of people are going to suffer."

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

The 50 Best country pubs

The 50 best country pubs

From rustic locals to stylish taverns, the out-of-town places to eat and drink
Graham Coxon: All a blur

All a blur

Grahan Coxon talks about Blur's Olympic gig and why he hates The X Factor
Ryan McGinley: Pictures of youth

Pictures of youth

The extraordinary world of photography' s golden boy Ryan McGinley
Berried treasures: Mark Hix makes the most of British berry season

Berried treasures

Mark Hix makes the most of British berry season
Difficult, moi? Feeding les enfants, French style

Difficult, moi?

Feeding les enfants, French style
Is this the end of meat?

Is this the end of meat?

These days, fake flesh looks – and tastes – just like the real thing
48 Hours In: San Francisco

48 Hours In: San Francisco

The Golden Gate Bridge turns 75 next weekend
Street treats in Shanghai

Street treats in Shanghai

It's a city of world-class fine dining,
A journey through the heart of Italy

A journey through the heart of Italy

A holiday that takes in two coasts, mountains, cookery, seaside treats and a round of golf
G8 summit: The hunger game

G8 summit: The hunger game

Broken pledges from rich nations have put millions at risk of famine
Greengrass shoots and scores with Barcelona film

Greengrass shoots and scores with Barcelona film

British director is in Cannes to sell movie celebrating recent success of Catalan side
The curse of the Kennedys

The curse of the Kennedys

The death of Mary Richardson Kennedy has once again thrown the spotlight on the goldfish bowl that is life in America's most famous family
Horticulture: Can you dig it?

Horticulture: Can you dig it?

A group of gardening guerrillas has set up a hip alternative to the Chelsea Flower Show
10 Best Salt and Pepper sets

10 Best Salt and Pepper sets

Whether they’re for hard work in the kitchen or to adorn the dining table, it’s worth getting a stylish, sturdy shaker
Ian Herbert: Fenway have identified their Billy Beane

Ian Herbert: Fenway have identified their Billy Beane

It is hard to exaggerate the extent to which Martinez has overhauled Wigan