British children reluctant to cheat, US study shows

Despite designing a study to lure the youngsters into peeking at the answer to a trivia question, the vast majority of the British children refused to cheat

Click to follow

The idea that the British have an inherent sense of fair play is met with scorn by those who view it as nothing more than nationalist myth-making.

However, psychologists researching links between the development of memory in young children and their ability to lie hit a problem when studying six- and seven-year-olds in the UK.

Despite specifically designing a study to lure the youngsters into peeking at the answer to a trivia question – so their skills of deception could then be put to the test – the vast majority of the British children refused to cheat.

Based on studies mainly in North America, about two-thirds were expected to sneak a look at the right answer when the researcher left the room, but less than 25 per cent of the British children actually did so.

Dr Tracy Alloway, of North Florida University, who led the research, told The Independent that they now planned to try to find out why so few took the bait.

“A great follow-up study we’re interested in pursuing is looking at cultural differences,” she said.


“Part of [the propensity to lie] is your social network. One of your siblings will tell on you, you get caught out and eventually no one wants to be friends with someone who’s constantly telling lies. A smart child who’s socially aware will stop pursuing these kinds of behaviours.”

However their findings might not necessarily support the idea that this process is somehow stronger in Britain than elsewhere.

“Being British, I’d love to agree with you, but I’m not sure that’s entirely true,” Dr Alloway said.

One theory is that the word “peeking” – the children were told not to do this by the researcher – has a stronger negative connotation in Britain than in the US and Canada.

Dr Alloway also said the British children may have been more concerned they would be caught. Rather than being in a quiet laboratory, they were tested in a classroom and Dr Alloway said noise in the hall outside may have spooked potential cheaters.

“You could see from the [hidden camera] videos that the children were constantly looking around when they did actually look at the card. They would look very surreptitiously,” she said.

The study, published in the Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, found a link between a better verbal working memory and the ability to lie convincingly.

Dr Ross Alloway, a co-author of the study and Dr Alloway’s husband, said: “Parents may sometimes become frustrated when their child lies about sticking their hand in a cookie jar, but we can take heart that the more believable the explanation for the crumbs around their mouth, the more intelligent they are.”