How old is too old to freeze eggs? Doctors clash over fertility advice
Jeremy Laurance is Health Editor of The Independent and the i and has covered the specialism for more than 20 years. He thinks the harm medicine does is under-appreciated, the harm it prevents over-rated, and that cycling works better than most drugs. He was named Specialist Journalist of the Year in the 2011 British Press Awards.
Tuesday 18 October 2011
A British fertility expert has clashed with a US specialist over when is the "right" time for single women who want children to resort to freezing their eggs.
Gillian Lockwood, medical director of Midland Fertility Services in Aldridge, near Birmingham, defended the practice despite US research showing that the average age of women seeking egg freezing for social reasons is between 37 and 39 – by which time their eggs are rapidly deteriorating.
A review of 26 studies to be presented at the annual meeting of the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM) in Orlando today has found that women who froze their eggs when they were under 30 had higher rates of success than those who were older.
Roger Lobo, president of the ASRM, warned women not to leave it too late. Dr Lobo said egg freezing was still "an experimental procedure" with "insufficient evidence" to show whether it was a "worthwhile undertaking".
"Despite increasing numbers of clinics offering the procedure and the significant media attention paid to it in recent years, women are not pursuing elective egg freezing at an age when it would be most likely to help them accomplish their fertility goals."
But Dr Lockwood said although it was true that egg freezing was not an option for many women in their late 30s, "we have to ask what the comparator is here".
"The comparator is how well will these women do with their own eggs in their early 40s? A 39-year-old frozen egg is going to do better in IVF than a 42-year-old fresh egg, because the drop-off becomes so sharp during these years."
Dr Lockwood said she was frequently contacted by women in their mid to late 30s who were still single and wanted to freeze their eggs. "They've discovered Mr Right has turned out to be Mr Wrong. They are deliberately and quite bravely trying to buy a bit of time."
Egg freezing is still rare in Britain but is recognised as a last resort for women who want to preserve their fertility, either because they have had cancer treatment or for social reasons.
Dr Lockwood has seen around 100 women in the last few years who want to freeze their eggs for social reasons.
"With most of the women I see we agree that social egg freezing is not appropriate, either because they've left it too late or because their ovarian reserve is too low. I see it as unethical if you are only going to get three or four eggs because really you need 16, 18, 20 to have a realistic chance of achieving pregnancy. "I would still say a woman up to her mid-30s who wishes to be a genetic mother one day and has not met Mr Right would be much better freezing her eggs than hoping Mr Right turns up before she's 40."
* Scientists are developing a test that could dramatically boost IVF success rates from a single cycle of treatment. The technique, created at Oxford University, checks for chromosomal abnormalities in the developing embryo but also looks at two new markers that could potentially cause pregnancies to fail. Over time, researchers hope they can increase success rates towards the 100 per cent mark. At present, only around 30 per cent of IVF cycles worldwide result in a pregnancy, with many failing due to chromosomal abnormalities.
6,388 According to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority 6,388 eggs had been frozen up to the end of 2008, for medical as well as social reasons.
£3,500 Midland Fertility Services charges £3,500 for the three-stage freezing process plus £170 annual storage after the first year.
11.9 per cent The clinic has had a licence to freeze eggs for a decade and has carried out 42 cycles of IVF in that time with an 11.9 per cent live birth rate.
That's some guestlist! Stunning images show huge dynastic wedding between Ultra-Orthodox Jewish families which attracted 25,000 guests
Man and woman arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to murder victim of Woolwich machete attack, named as Drummer Lee Rigby
'Sickening, deluded and unforgivable': Horrific attack brings terror to London’s streets
Video: Woolwich attack - man with bloodied hands and knife addresses camera
Ingrid Loyau-Kennett, the mother-of-two hailed as a hero for confronting Woolwich attackers, thought: 'better me than a child'
- 1 Man and woman arrested on suspicion of conspiracy to murder victim of Woolwich machete attack, named as Drummer Lee Rigby
- 2 'Sickening, deluded and unforgivable': Horrific attack brings terror to London’s streets
- 3 Grace Dent: I’m not sure how these people can avoid being called ‘bigots’. And the more ‘civilised’, the worse they are
- 4 Woolwich murder: They killed, then they performed - these men should be starved of our attention
- 5 Woolwich attack: The EDL will seek to exploit this evil crime for their own evil ends
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
Get the latest on The Evening Standard's campaign to get London's children reading.
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.