A 35-year-old optical illusion is still astounding people. And it all revolves around a rotated picture of Margaret Thatcher.
But, as with many optical illusions, the strange effect shows a lot about the way that the brain processes images.
The Margaret Thatcher Illusion — which also gets called the Thatcher Effect, along with other names — occurs when a picture is turned upside down. But instead of changing everything in the picture, the effect happens when the features, like the mouth and eyes, are kept the right way up.
The brain is often unable to see that anything strange has happened when the picture was turned the wrong way up.
When the Thatcher Illusion was first developed, in 1980, it presented a huge challenge to the way that scientists understood how the human brain processes faces. It showed that people don’t just think about the face as a whole, but rather understand each of its component parts and assemble them into a whole.
The picture was first shown in a paper by Peter Thompson, of York University. He published it in Margaret Thatcher: a new illusion, in Perception.
In the 35 years since, it has been used on a range of different people. A site, thatchereffect.com, allows users to try the effect on famous people — as well as themselves.
The effect seems to work on almost anyone. The only thing that sometimes throws it out is if a person’s smile is especially distinctive, or notably shaped, which seems to pull the brain out of the trick and force them to notice that there is a problem.
1/4 These aren't moving either
The effect comes from much the same place
2/4 And neither is this
Yep, this is also a still image
3/4 These circles aren't moving
The trick comes from the way that our brains scan images over and over
4/4 There's only two colours in this picture
The effect comes from the way that the brain receives different parts of the image at different times
Research has found that many monkeys also respond to the illusion in the same way, seeing the face as normal even when it’s turned wrong and lighting up the same parts of the brain. What’s more, that discovery shows that primates have the same ways of understanding faces as humans do.
(What’s more, the effect also works on non-human faces, like a monkey’s. But those faces also tend to be more symmetrical up and down, meaning that the change is much less noticeable.)