Andy Coulson loses fees battle
Wednesday 21 December 2011
Latest in Crime
Related articles
On Facebook
From the blogs
Sepp Blatter: Penalty shoot-outs must remain, they’re football’s great leveller
As England supporters, we should scorn at any such deciding factor within football. On so many occas...
Why do some men consider the street as a female meat market?
Pronouncements on sexual inequality in the UK are normally met with an eye roll by my generation. As...
Political corruption reflects the widening chasm between the political class and the electorate
The corruption and hypocrisy which has come to characterise politics and politicians, and in particu...
Despite its popularity, the death penalty would allow the state to kill innocent people
The University of Michigan law school and Northwestern University have just compiled a database of o...
Former News of the World editor Andy Coulson has lost a High Court action against his ex-employer over its refusal to pay legal fees arising from the phone-hacking affair.
Mr Coulson, 43, who was not in court today, sued News International subsidiary News Group Newspapers (NGN) over the construction of a clause within a severance agreement from his resignation in February 2007.
He asked Mr Justice Supperstone for a declaration that NGN, which stopped reimbursement in August, "must pay the professional costs and expenses properly incurred" by him "in defending allegations of criminal conduct" during his tenure.
Mr Coulson, who was arrested in July over the allegations and released on bail, has always denied any wrongdoing.
He resigned from his position as Prime Minister David Cameron's director of communications in January, saying that coverage of the scandal was making it too difficult for him to do his job.
Christopher Jeans QC, for NGN, said the clause covered the "occupational hazards of being an editor" and not alleged criminal activity.
Dismissing the claim, the judge said the agreement did not cover the criminal allegations made against Mr Coulson personally and if, contrary to his view, the criminal allegations were covered, no proceedings had commenced.
He ordered Mr Coulson to pay NGN's costs and refused him permission to appeal, although he can renew his application directly to the Court of Appeal.
Mr Jeans had said that, if it was intended that NGN would pay all Mr Coulson's legal costs, a clause could simply have stated that it would pay any costs he incurred in relation to any legal investigations or hearings in any way connected with his period as editor.
"Instead, the clause is thick with qualifications - such as 'lawfully able', 'reasonable', 'properly incurred', 'having to defend', the naming of specific types of proceedings, and all 'as a result of his having been editor'."
Far from being, as Mr Coulson's lawyers claimed, as wide as could be drafted, it was a carefully limited clause which in no way covered personal criminal wrongdoing.
He said that, if NGN was wrong on that, the clause only covered proceedings which had commenced - and there were none.
In his ruling, the judge said that plainly, as editor, Mr Coulson was required to act lawfully.
"That being so, the reference to 'editor' in the clause must be to someone performing the lawful duties of editor. His duties comprised only lawful activities.
"Accordingly, it cannot have been intended that activity outside the scope of an editor's lawful responsibilities would be covered by an indemnity; still less that the indemnity should extend to any serious criminal activities for which he was alleged personally to be responsible."
He added that, in his view, proceedings had not yet started.
PA
- 1 Mark Zuckerberg saved $111m by selling Facebook shares before stock slumped
- 2 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 3 Greece: Out of cash, out of hope
- 4 Society: The only way is Finland
- 5 News in pictures
- 6 Cameron knew Hunt would back BSkyB bid
- 7 In pictures: The bewildering face of China
- 8 Catcalls, whistles, groping: the everyday picture of sexual harassment in London
- 9 Ten adverts that shocked the world
- 10 '60 stone' Welsh teenager remains in hospital
- 1 Mark Zuckerberg saved $111m by selling Facebook shares before stock slumped
- 2 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 3 Society: The only way is Finland
- 4 Catcalls, whistles, groping: the everyday picture of sexual harassment in London
- 5 Feeding a hungry world – or meddling with laws of nature?
- 6 Owen Jones: If socialists really did run the show, working people would benefit
- 7 'Hello mum, this is going to be hard for you to read ...'
- 8 African monkey meat that could be behind the next HIV
- 9 French in uproar over oral sex anti-smoking posters
- 10 Coke reveals its secret: It may need to carry a cancer warning
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
Can you imagine a career in teaching?
Be inspired to teach - let real teachers show you how rewarding the job can be.
Playing a game-changing role during the Games
Cisco is providing the solutions for London 2012's complex IT needs.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
For men only: A pilgrimage to Mount Athos
48 Hours In: Faro
Monkey meat that could be behind the next HIV
Catcalls, whistles, groping: just another day for a young woman
Jailing of Maori separatists stirs colonial-era resentment
Pizza Pilgrims: Like mamma used to make


