Judges block 1948 Malaya 'massacre' probe
Tuesday 04 September 2012
Two High Court judges today blocked attempts to force a public inquiry into the killing of 24 Malaysian rubber plantation workers by British troops more than 60 years ago.
Victims' relatives described the shootings at Batang Kali, Malaya, in December 1948 as a "massacre" and judges said allegations against members of the Scots Guards were "as serious as it is possible to make".
But Sir John Thomas - president of the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court, who sat with Mr Justice Treacy - said it would be "very difficult at this point in time" to establish whether the shootings were "deliberate executions".
Judges said the cost of an inquiry would be "materially greater" than £1 million and said it was "very questionable" whether "much can be learnt".
British soldiers were conducting operations against communist insurgents during the "Malayan Emergency" when the plantation workers were killed, judges heard.
Relatives said there was enough evidence to justify an official investigation and asked judges to overturn a Government decision not to hold an inquiry.
Foreign Secretary William Hague and Defence Secretary Philip Hammond opposed the relatives' application, arguing that the decision not to hold an inquiry was lawful.
Judges today ruled in the Government's favour following a hearing in London in May.
Relatives said they would appeal.
Sir John, in a written ruling handed down at a hearing in London, said: "The first matter in relation to the purpose of inquiry is to consider whether it can establish the facts.
"There are obviously enormous difficulties in conducting an inquiry into a matter that happened over 63 years ago. Most of the contemporary documents are missing and most of those who were engaged are dead."
He added: "All in all, it would appear to be very difficult at this point in time to establish definitively whether the men were shot trying to escape or whether these were deliberate executions.
"Nor, in our view, would it be any easier to determine whether the use of force was reasonable or proportionate."
Sir John said decisions taken by Mr Hague and Mr Hammond not to set up an inquiry were "not unreasonable".
Solicitor John Halford, who represents victims' families, said after today's hearing, that relatives would appeal.
Mr Halford, from law firm Bindmans, added: "The survivors and families of the Batang Kali massacre will continue to pursue legal action."
sportLiverpool 5 Norwich City 1: Uruguayan striker has now scored 11 league goals against the club
arts + entsOlivier-nominated actor and singer is set to star in Lloyd Webber's musical about the Profumo affair
filmWith more than 70 per cent of early films lost, archivists are scouring the world to preserve the precious examples that remain
sportThe coach of Chalfont St Peter's under-10s football team was relieved of his duties after he sent an email to parents that said: 'I am only interested in winning'
techA piece of new hi-tech kit aims to get us scribbling again
indybestMake getting out of the wrong side of bed on cold winter mornings a thing of the past with our selection of night-time covers
life + styleClarissa Baldwin is the brains behind the slogan 'A Dog is for Life not just for Christmas'
- 1 North Korea: Kim Jong Un 'sacks powerful uncle and has his aides executed'
- 2 The hardwired difference between male and female brains could explain why men are 'better at map reading'
- 3 Is this the scariest advert ever? Japanese tyre commercial comes with its own disclaimer and health warning
- 4 A forgotten episode in Russian history leaves links with the Philippines
- 5 ‘Put it in my mouth’: Viewers outraged by apparent reference to oral sex in VIP e-cig advert
Work until you’re 70: Chancellor accused of ‘living in fantasy land’ over Autumn Statement pension reforms
What made Charles Saatchi grab my throat, by Nigella Lawson - as she accuses him of threatening to 'destroy' her with drug claims
Is this the scariest advert ever? Japanese tyre commercial comes with its own disclaimer and health warning
‘Put it in my mouth’: Viewers outraged by apparent reference to oral sex in VIP e-cig advert
Paul Walker death: Eight-year-old son of Porsche driver Roger Rodas tried to rescue his father