A neat solution to the West Lothian question, but what might go wrong?

 

Like many elegant ideas, David Cameron’s proposed solution to the West Lothian question could throw up some unintended consequences. For example...

The proposal will end the long-established equality and authority currently given to all MPs.

The devolved powers given to the Holyrood parliament are substantial, and will potentially rise if devolution-max is granted should Scottish voters reject independence. This would leave MPs from Scottish constituencies holding the same voting authority as their English colleagues only on reserved matters such as defence, foreign affairs and social security.

If Scottish MPs were excluded from involvement in everything but reserved powers, academics have suggested they would be reduced to one-day-week MPs. Even if they were involved in other matters, but only until the final stage of a Bill, this would still create a two-tier Commons: English MPs and involved, non-voting Scottish MPs.

The influence of Scottish MPs at Westminster will be reduced.

The Cameron plan creates a political barrier, a ceiling, beyond which Scottish MPs cannot operate on equal terms with their south-of-the-border colleagues. Scottish MPs could not technically hold many ministerial posts. A minister from a Scottish constituency could not be expected to pilot a key Bill, and then withdraw from voting at its final hurdle.

Regardless of its aim, the Cameron plan will increase Tory control.

Scottish constituencies currently send 59 MPs to Westminster. The Conservative Party has one MP – “not enough for a tennis doubles” is a well-worn jibe. Labour has 41 Scottish MPs. If this number had been excluded from key non-reserved Bills over the post-war period, Labour’s overall authority would have been diminished. So the Commons might become a Tory-dominated chamber, and might be seen by Scotland as an “English parliament”.

A prime minister who has only limited authority in Westminster is a constitutional nonsense. So we may have seen the last Scottish prime minister in Gordon Brown.

Technically it could be argued that if one of the main parties finds a potential superstar from a  Scottish constituency, their first course of action should be to find them a safe seat – in England. This makes a mockery of the constitutional link between MPs and their constituents – and favours political pragmatism over basic democracy. What the new proposal signals to future Scottish MPs is that Westminster will not be the pinnacle of their careers. No 10 is not theirs to covet. Holyrood’s attractiveness for a new generation of Labour politicians is likely to increase.

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebooks
ebooksAn introduction to the ground rules of British democracy
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
SPONSORED FEATURES
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Stock Broker / Trainee Broker / Closer - OTE £250,000

£30000 - £250000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Stock Broker/ Trainee FX, Stoc...

Guru Careers: Software Developer / Web Developer (PHP / MYSQL)

£30 - 40k + Benefits & Bonus: Guru Careers: A Software / Web Developer (PHP / ...

Recruitment Genius: ICT Operations Manager

Negotiable: Recruitment Genius: This company is the single governing and regul...

Recruitment Genius: Purchasing Assistant

£20000 - £25000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This high quality thread manufa...

Day In a Page

A groundbreaking study of 'Britain's Atlantis' long buried at the bottom of the North Sea could revolutionise how we see our prehistoric past

Britain's Atlantis

Scientific study beneath North Sea could revolutionise how we see the past
The Queen has 'done and said nothing that anybody will remember,' says Starkey

The Queen has 'done and said nothing that anybody will remember'

David Starkey's assessment
Oliver Sacks said his life has been 'an enormous privilege and adventure'

'An enormous privilege and adventure'

Oliver Sacks writing about his life
'Gibraltar is British, and it is going to stay British forever'

'Gibraltar is British, and it is going to stay British forever'

The Rock's Chief Minister hits back at Spanish government's 'lies'
Britain is still addicted to 'dirty coal'

Britain still addicted to 'dirty' coal

Biggest energy suppliers are more dependent on fossil fuel than a decade ago
Orthorexia nervosa: How becoming obsessed with healthy eating can lead to malnutrition

Orthorexia nervosa

How becoming obsessed with healthy eating can lead to malnutrition
Lady Chatterley is not obscene, says TV director

Lady Chatterley’s Lover

Director Jed Mercurio on why DH Lawrence's novel 'is not an obscene story'
Farmers in tropical forests are training ants to kill off bigger pests

Set a pest to catch a pest

Farmers in tropical forests are training ants to kill off bigger pests
Mexico: A culture that celebrates darkness as an essential part of life

The dark side of Mexico

A culture that celebrates darkness as an essential part of life
Being sexually assaulted was not your fault, Chrissie Hynde. Don't tell other victims it was theirs

Being sexually assaulted was not your fault, Chrissie Hynde

Please don't tell other victims it was theirs
A nap a day could save your life - and here's why

A nap a day could save your life

A midday nap is 'associated with reduced blood pressure'
If men are so obsessed by sex, why do they clam up when confronted with the grisly realities?

If men are so obsessed by sex...

...why do they clam up when confronted with the grisly realities?
The comedy titans of Avalon on their attempt to save BBC3

Jon Thoday and Richard Allen-Turner

The comedy titans of Avalon on their attempt to save BBC3
The bathing machine is back... but with a difference

Rolling in the deep

The bathing machine is back but with a difference
Part-privatised tests, new age limits, driverless cars: Tories plot motoring revolution

Conservatives plot a motoring revolution

Draft report reveals biggest reform to regulations since driving test introduced in 1935