Gordon Brown stands firm in defence spending row

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

Taking away benefits from heroin users won’t solve anything

It was reported today that Ian Duncan Smith is threatening to stop heroin addicts from being able to...

Chelsea Flower Show 2012: The winners

Of course, gold is the top honour, but that shouldn't detract from the other medals. If someone wins...

Palestinian hunger strike comes to an end but the status quo is not sustainable

Hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, being held without being charge and without trial by the Israeli ...

RadFem2012: Excluding on the basis of gender

As someone who is interested in feminism as a movement, I was pleased to find out about RadFem2012 -...

The Prime Minister insisted again today that all urgent operational requests for equipment for troops fighting in Afghanistan and Iraq had been met.

In furious Commons question time exchanges, Tory leader David Cameron accused Mr Brown of failing in his "duty of care" to the armed forces.



He said the Government had fought two wars "on a peacetime budget" and the Treasury had "massively underestimated" the cost of the conflict in Afghanistan.



But Mr Brown hit back, saying defence spending had risen and £9 billion had been poured into the operation in Afghanistan, on top of the general defence budget.



As the row escalated, he repeatedly taunted Mr Cameron over the "non-dom" tax status of Lord Ashcroft, insisting, at one point, that he would take no lectures on integrity from an Opposition leader who would not answer questions on the Tory deputy chairman.



It came after an inquest into the deaths of Corporal Sarah Bryant, 26, the first female casualty in Afghanistan, and three special forces comrades heard a string of criticisms over their equipment and training.



Wiltshire and Swindon coroner David Masters pledged to raise his concerns with the Ministry of Defence at the end of yesterday's inquest.



He recorded unlawful killing verdicts for Cpl Bryant and special forces reservists Corporal Sean Robert Reeve, 28, Lance Corporal Richard Larkin, 39, and Private Paul Stout, 31, who died when their Snatch Land Rover hit a roadside bomb in June 2008.









Mr Cameron repeatedly pointed to criticisms levelled at the Government by former chiefs of the defence staff over alleged equipment shortages in Iraq and Afghanistan.

As some Labour backbenchers suggested this was because the critics were "Tories", Mr Cameron reacted angrily, banging his papers on the despatch box, and demanding an apology for this "disgraceful slur" on the former defence chiefs' patriotism.



"That is what this tribalist, divisive Government thinks about people who serve our country," he said.



The exchanges began with Mr Cameron pointing to yesterday's inquest into the deaths of four soldiers in Afghanistan in 2008.



"At the time, the Defence Minister (Quentin Davies) linked their deaths to the commander's choice of vehicle.



"This was flatly contradicted by what the coroner said. So will you now apologise on behalf of your minister?"



Mr Brown replied: "The minister apologised at the time and I repeat that apology."







Mr Brown said he had read the report from the inquest and it would go to the Ministry of Defence.

"They've said they will look at every detail that is raised by the coroner and take whatever action is necessary."



Three areas had to be looked at.



"The first is on vehicles themselves, where we have ordered 1,800 new vehicles since 2006 at a cost of £1.7 billion to make sure we have the vehicles necessary for the commanders on the ground.



"Secondly, on training, we have made sure the training is better and it will be improved for those who are going to Afghanistan.



"Third, on IEDs themselves. As everybody knows the guerilla warfare in Iraq and Afghanistan led to them starting to use IEDs and we had to take extra measures to deal with that.



"We have improved our engineering capability, our surveillance capability. We have now 3,000 mine detector machines on the ground for our troops. That will double over the next few months.



"We are doing everything we can to deal with the IED threat. So we are answering legitimate questions that have been raised."



Mr Cameron said: "You've now apologised for something that should never have been said by the minister and the House will be grateful for that."



Turning to the Prime Minister's evidence to the Chilcot inquiry last week, he said: "Following your evidence one former chief of the defence staff said you were being 'disingenuous', another said you were 'dissembling'. Both these people worked with you."







It was at this point that Mr Cameron turned on Labour backbenchers, saying: "Oh, it's because they're (the former chiefs of the defence staff) 'Tories' is it? That is what this tribalist, divisive Government thinks about people who serve our country."

He told the Prime Minister: "You should get up and disassociate yourself completely from what your colleagues have said."



Mr Brown said: "It's common cause within this House that we support the campaign in Iraq and Afghanistan. It's common cause also that we do not send our troops into battle without the commanders assuring us that they are properly equipped for the operations they are undertaking.



"In every instance where the MoD asked for equipment under urgent operational requirements, that equipment was given.



"Let's find where the common ground is, rather than where there is division."



Mr Cameron angrily rose again, saying: "Your MPs have questioned the integrity of people who served this country, fought for this country, who are essays in bravery...



"And before we go on, you've got to get to that despatch box and disassociate yourself from those disgraceful remarks."



Mr Brown told him: "I've never at any time criticised the patriotism of anyone involved in the defence establishment of this country.



"But I think we should have a debate about this which is serious and based on facts.



"Every request that was made to us by the MoD for urgent operational requirements was met.



"We've spent £18 billion in Afghanistan and Iraq on top of the MoD budget.



"I assure this House that every time our commanders go into action, I ask them for an assurance that they have the equipment they need for the operation.



"I want to applaud the patriotism of everyone who serves our country and so does the vast majority of this House."





Mr Cameron said the Prime Minister had given a lecture earlier on character. "But you haven't got the character to stand up to your own backbenchers. It is a disgraceful slur.

"It's not just chiefs of the defence staff who said this. We've had a former permanent secretary at the MoD talking about a 'guillotined' budget.



"We've had a serving Permanent Secretary talking about a serious dispute between the Treasury and the MoD.



"We've had the former commander of the Paras in Afghanistan saying he was 'staggered by the lack of any sense of responsibility' from you."



He demanded: "Why do you think that all these people, dedicated to the defence of this country, are wrong, while only you are right?"



Mr Brown said he had put the facts before the inquiry on Friday. Defence spending had been rising in real terms under the Government.



"I said, in addition to that expenditure, £8 billion had been spent in Iraq and we are spending £9 billion in Afghanistan.



"The Chief of the Defence Staff has said on record that we have the best-equipped force that we have ever been.



"I'm going to take no lectures on integrity from the man who won't even answer one question about Lord Ashcroft."



Mr Cameron said that, of course, ministers had not rejected requests for urgent operational requirements. "But they never thought what that meant for the defence budget.



"The fact is you've tried to fight two wars on a peacetime budget. When you were Chancellor, the Treasury massively under-estimated the cost of the war in Afghanistan."



Mr Brown denied this, insisting the defence budget had been "rising every year" and the only time it had been cut was when the Tories were last in power.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Andreas Whittam Smith: Authenticity is a great asset in a leader. David Cameron lacks it

Andreas Whittam Smith

Authenticity is a great asset in a leader. David Cameron lacks it
Back in the thick of it... Alastair Campbell returns to work as a spin doctor

Back in the thick of it... Alastair Campbell returns to work as a spin doctor

Labour's master of media manipulation is back in the PR business
Supermarkets accused of ripping off shoppers with 'misleading' offers

Supermarkets accused of ripping off shoppers with 'misleading' offers

Which? survey reveals that buying single items can often be cheaper than attractive-looking multipack promotions
The art of industrial espionage

The art of industrial espionage

Corporate investigation may lack the glamour of Bond and Bourne, but the two worlds aren't so far removed...
From fashion to film: Jean Paul Gaultier on his week as a Cannes juror

Jean Paul Gaultier: From fashion to film

The fashion designer discusses his week as a Cannes juror
Therapist who tried to 'cure' me of being gay thrown out – but the system is still broken

Therapist who tried to 'cure' me of being gay thrown out...

... but the system is still broken, says Patrick Strudwick
In a Sudanese field, cluster bomb evidence proves just how deadly this war has become

In a Sudanese field, cluster bomb evidence proves just how deadly this war has become

Aris Roussinos speaks to the villagers demanding UN help
'I don't want it to be boring': Former circus producer reveals plans for Diamond Jubilee river parade

Diamond Jubilee river parade

Former circus producer Adrian Evans reveals his plans for the Thames Pageant
VIP treatment: Life is golden in the Olympic fast lane

VIP treatment: Life is golden in the Olympic fast lane

As the rest of us get used to being also-rans in the race for tickets, a chosen few are preparing to enjoy nothing but the very best of London 2012
Forest guards told to shoot poachers on sight after rash of tiger killings

Forest guards told to shoot poachers on sight after rash of tiger killings

India hits back against hunters who sell body parts to Asia for use in traditional medicines
Mining tycoon beats Wal-Mart heiress to title of richest woman

Mining tycoon beats Wal-Mart heiress to title of richest woman

Industrialist Gina Rinehart earns £32m a day from her Australian iron-ore concerns
Language: The cussing room floor

Language: The cussing room floor

Ken Loach is the latest director to complain about censorship. The rules on swearing are so arbitrary, it's no wonder he's effing and blinding
The 10 best car gadgets

The 10 best car gadgets

From a wide-angle HD camera to a satnav that shows you real-time images of the road ahead...
James Lawton: Gary needs to the find key to Wayne's desolate world

James Lawton: Gary needs to find key to Wayne's desolate world

Has Neville been called in by Roy Hodgson to monitor the mood of his former team-mate?
Jessica Ennis: Olympic hope faces new hurdles

Jessica Ennis: Olympic hope faces new hurdles

Despite her great form Great Britain's heptathlon star tells Simon Turnbull there are many rivals who might 'get it right on the night' in London