The billionaire, the banker – and a bit of birch-thrashing
A libel case is shedding light on the secretive world inhabited by the super-rich – and Lord Mandelson. Jerome Taylor reports
Friday 27 January 2012
Latest in UK Politics
Related articles
On Facebook
From the blogs
What can parents do to protect their children online?
Paul Woodward recently hit the headlines for speaking out against parents who allow their children t...
Palestinian hunger strike comes to an end but the status quo is not sustainable
Hundreds of Palestinian prisoners, being held without being charge and without trial by the Israeli ...
RadFem2012: Excluding on the basis of gender
As someone who is interested in feminism as a movement, I was pleased to find out about RadFem2012 -...
Chelsea Flower Show 2012: Inside Diarmuid Gavin’s magic pyramid
You've got to love Diarmuid Gavin. Whatever he does, it's usually bigger, bolder and madder than any...
VIEW GALLERY
When a Russian oligarch, a peer of the realm and a British banking scion lay on their stomachs at a Siberian sauna to be thrashed with birch twigs, before plunging together into an invigorating ice bath, none of the men had business on their minds. Nor could they have envisaged, through the steam of the Russian banya in which they submitted to the traditional spa treatment, that their business dealings would be unpicked by lawyers seven years later as part of one of the most surprising libel battles to be heard in a British court.
This week, Nathaniel Rothschild, the investment banker and heir to the Rothschild dynasty, went to the High Court to sue the Daily Mail for its investigation into the January 2005 trip in which a group of business figures stayed at the Siberian chalet of Oleg Deripaska, the billionaire owner of Russia's largest aluminium plant.
Mr Rothschild, 40, claims the story damaged his reputation by suggesting that he invited Lord Mandelson to Siberia to help smooth the way for a £500m deal with Mr Deripaska.
Hugh Tomlinson, QC, who represents Mr Rothschild, said the Mail's article portrayed Lord Mandelson – then an EU trade commissioner in Brussels – as "a poodle that [my client has] wheeled out to impress Mr Deripaska". He added: "This is an article in relation to Mr Rothschild that makes a clear accusation he has done something wrong. That is the sting of the libel."
The piece described how Mr Rothschild persuaded Lord Mandelson to fly to Moscow for the weekend after they met at the World Economic Forum in Davos. The story alleged that the peer attended a dinner which resulted in a £500m deal between a company owned by Mr Deripaska and Alcoa, America's largest aluminium manufacturer.
Mr Tomlinson said the story portrayed Mr Rothschild as "a puppet-master" who made sure Lord Mandelson was at the dinner to reassure all parties that EU import tariffs for aluminium would not rise over the coming years.
Last month, the Daily Mail's owner Associated Newspapers, admitted it could not prove that Lord Mandelson attended the Alcoa dinner. Mr Rothschild's lawyers insist that he was at a separate dinner in the same restaurant with a Russian minister, though the former Business Secretary was not called to the court to give evidence. But the Mail said there was a "reasonable suspicion" that aluminium tariffs were discussed during the visit and that the nature of the trip had created a "perception of a conflict of interest".
The original Mail story made no mention of the trip to Siberia, which became public knowledge only after the case came to court. Lord Justice Tugendhat, who is hearing the case, was told that following the visit to Moscow, Mr Rothschild and Lord Mandelson were whisked in a private jet to the Siberian town of Abakan, where Mr Deripaska owns a chalet and smelting plant. Peter Munk, a Canadian gold magnate, and Sebastian Taylor, a friend of Mr Rothschild, also joined the group.
Taking the stand earlier this week, Mr Rothschild said his friends were taken to a traditional sauna, where they were whipped with birch leaves before plunging themselves into icy water.
"It is the best way in the world to beat jet lag and everything else," he said. "It was incredibly enjoyable. Everyone woke up the next day feeling revitalised and excited about the day."
Over the next 24 hours, the party spent time skiing, visiting an aluminium smelter, playing football and listening to a traditional Cossack band. Lord Mandelson then returned to Brussels and the rest of group went on to central Asia to visit more of Mr Deripaska's industrial plants in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan. Mr Rothschild insisted the Siberian part of his trip was entirely recreational and that the peer was invited because he was a friend.
"The presence of Lord Mandelson and Mr Taylor on the trip was purely social," he said. "No EU tariffs or other matters of that nature were discussed. The only business was to take place in central Asia, after Lord Mandelson had returned to Brussels."
He added: "I have never sought to exploit my friendship with Lord Mandelson to further my relationship with, or impress, Mr Deripaska or any other person with whom I do business. Lord Mandelson was and remains a good friend. Our relationship is no more than that."
But the case has also shone light on the powerful political circles in which Mr Deripaska, who went from being the manager of an aluminium plant to one of the world's richest men, now moves.
On Wednesday, the co-chairman of the Conservative Party, Lord Feldman, told the court he and George Osborne, who was then Shadow Chancellor, were invited to a party at a villa on Corfu owned by Mr Rothschild.
Mr Deripaska was also at the party, which eventually moved on to his luxury yacht moored nearby. The party caused huge media interest over allegations that Mr Osborne solicited a party donation from Mr Deripaska.
But according to Lord Feldman, it was Mr Rothschild who first suggested that the Russian was looking to make a donation through one of his UK-owned companies.
"I said that I was not sure if such a donation was appropriate," he told the court. "I told Mr Rothschild I would have to seek advice. It was decided after consulting senior party officials that it would not be appropriate."
Mr Justice Tugendhat is expected to give his judgment in a fortnight.
Who? What? Where?
The "puppet master": Nathaniel Rothschild
According to Rothschild's counsel, the Eton-educated banking heir and hedge fund boss was libelled by the Daily Mail in May 2010 when they painted him as a "puppet master" willing to exploit his friendship with Mandelson to smooth Deripaska's £500m aluminium deal.
The guest of honour: Peter Mandelson
The court heard the then European Trade Commissioner attended a restaurant in Moscow in 2005 as a guest of Rothschild.
The oligarch: Oleg Deripaska
The Russian aluminium tycoon, who has an estimated £6.5bn fortune, is the centre of the story, with claims Rothschild tried to "impress" him by bringing Mandelson to the dinner. Deripaska provided the jet which took Mandelson and Rothschild to Siberia.
The fundraiser: Lord Feldman
The Conservative party co-chairman denies soliciting a donation for the party from Deripaska when he and George Osborne visited the oligarch's yacht in August 2008. He went aboard the Queen K, he said in court, because he "had never seen a boat that size close up".
The birch whipping at the spa
After visiting a Siberian smelter, the party went to a Banya spa, where the men were thrashed with birch twigs by a 25-year-old before jumping into icy water to improve circulation. "It was incredibly enjoyable. Everyone woke up feeling revitalised," said Rothschild in court.
The villa in Corfu
Lord Rothschild's villa on the Greek island has long been known as a place where plutocrats and politicians mingle, and it is here, Feldman claimed, that Rothschild suggested Deripaska was interested in making a donation to the Tories. Rothschild denies this.
Samuel Muston
- 1 Double trouble at JP Morgan: trader's losses could exceed $7bn
- 2 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 3 News in pictures
- 4 In pictures: The bewildering face of China
- 5 Parents 'killed daughter by forcing bag into her mouth'
- 6 Ten adverts that shocked the world
- 7 Mark Zuckerberg loses friends on Wall Street as regulators probe $19bn slump
- 8 Christine Lagarde: Time is running out for George Osborne's Plan A
- 9 Manal al-Sharif: 'They just messed with the wrong woman'
- 10 The Bain of Mitt Romney's life?
- 1 Double trouble at JP Morgan: trader's losses could exceed $7bn
- 2 Romain Amalfitano is latest French connection for Newcastle
- 3 Brazil rocked by abortion for 9-year-old rape victim
- 4 Portugal 'sells' Ronaldo to Spain in £160m deal on national debt
- 5 Tony Blair and George Bush's phone conversation a week before Iraq invasion 'must be released'
- 6 Forgotten Authors: No 8: William Sansom
- 7 Manal al-Sharif: 'They just messed with the wrong woman'
- 8 Tory MPs 'gagged' welfare-to-work whistleblowers
- 9 Coke reveals its secret: It may need to carry a cancer warning
- 10 French in uproar over oral sex anti-smoking posters
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
Can you imagine a career in teaching?
Be inspired to teach - let real teachers show you how rewarding the job can be.
Playing a game-changing role during the Games
Cisco is providing the solutions for London 2012's complex IT needs.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
Grace Dent
Mike Sheridan: Confessions of an Ofsted inspector
Manal al-Sharif interview


