World

Rain (AM and PM) 3° London Hi 9°C / Lo 6°C

Exclusive: The silent exodus

Human tide of misery flees the anarchy of Somalia

As the world follows the escapades of the country's pirates, civilians are fleeing the anarchy on land, creating the world's biggest refugee camp

By Daniel Howden, Africa Correspondent

N-0 block of the Ifo refugee camp in Dadaab, northern Kenya

Andreas Lascaris, stills taken from forthcoming documentary 'Stolen Seas: The untold story of Somali pirates'. More info at www.thymayapayne.com

N-0 block of the Ifo refugee camp in Dadaab, northern Kenya

The lucky ones come with their families, others appear out of the thorn bushes, walking alone. Five hundred Somalis are now arriving at this bleak Kenyan outpost every day. They join a population of 267,000 and counting, in a facility built to shelter just 45,000. While the world has been captivated by the high seas drama of Somalia's pirates, this human tide has swollen the ranks of Dadaab, turning it into the world's largest refugee camp.

The new arrivals sit in their hundreds under a makeshift tarpaulin, trying to keep perfectly still in temperatures that reach 40C in the shade. It speaks volumes for the horrors unfolding in Somalia that people will abandon their homes, risk arbitrary arrest, death or starvation to reach the desolate welcome on offer in this corner of northern Kenya.

These people are proof of the human cost of the accelerating collapse of Somalia, yet their fate attracts nothing like the global interest that surrounds Somali piracy and its threat to commerce. The UN refugee agency (UNHCR) that runs Dadaab urgently needs new money from international donors and new land from the Kenyan government. Neither has been forthcoming. The annual budget for this camp is $19m (£13m) – roughly half the annual operational cost of a single warship patrolling the Indian Ocean in search of modern-day Blackbeards.

The story of Dadaab is in some senses the story of modern Somalia. Its three camps, Hagadera, Ifo and Dagahaley, were built to house those who fled when the last functioning central government – that of socialist dictator Siad Barre – collapsed in 1991. The camps soon reached their initial capacity and as the mother country just 50 miles to the north has sunk deeper and deeper, so the number of refugees has risen and risen. An entire generation of children has grown up knowing Dadaab as their only home. There have been 14 failed governments since then, Somalia is in a state of anarchy and Dadaab is facing an extraordinary influx. Last August the land ran out and the UN had to declare the camps full. It has not stopped the desperate masses arriving.

Somalia is a country surrounded by political walls. Its land borders with Ethiopia and Kenya have been closed to protect their countries from the Islamic militias on the other side. In reality the only effect of the closures has been to make it even harder for people like Osman Hussein Bare to flee. With his family seated in a tired circle around him, the middle-aged man stands to tell his story with some dignity. "There is war in Somalia," he explains. "A lot of bullets; day and night they are fighting in the place."

A farmer from a village close to the coastal city of Kismayo, Mr Bare found his life taken over by the emergence of the powerful Al-Shabaab militia. The breaking point, which sent him trekking for two nights across a sealed border to another country, came when the militants began to dig up the remains of religious leaders from Islamic sects they considered their rivals. "The way they rule I cannot live under them," he said.

Amina, 22, was not one of the lucky ones. She was separated from her family and has arrived alone from Kismayo. During her fortnight's journey to reach Dadaab she was badly beaten twice, once by militiamen and once by Ethiopian soldiers. She says: "I'm a woman, I'm vulnerable and there's no government to protect me."

By midday at the UNHCR's registration office at Dagahaley camp, a state of organised chaos prevails. Lines of worn and exhausted people queue in all directions; young children howl as they are given basic vaccinations. The prize on offer is a ration card. Outside the high fence faces and fingers push against the wire, some desperate, some curious. "Some people will have to come back tomorrow," Andy Needham from UNHCR explains. Registration means access to basic food and a rudimentary kit to build a shelter. There is no more land to give so people must find relatives or friends already inside the swollen camps to accommodate them.

After a week in which the first attempted hijack of a US ship off the coast of Somalia propelled the troubled nation to the top of the news agenda, it is the image of a shoeless young Somali, armed with a rocket launcher and shielded by a foreign hostage, that has remained with much of the world. In fact, the hundreds of thousands of Somalis in Dadaab are as much victims of those pirate gangs as the foreign sailors captured in the Gulf of Aden. Food supplies to the camps were delayed by this week's surge of hijackings and the refugees' rations have been cut by one third. A recent report on Dadaab by Oxfam described conditions as "conducive to a public health emergency".

The outlines of that are clearest at the N-0 encampment which lies on the fringe of the Ifo facility. It is known to regular visitors as the "end of the world". There are no buildings here, just white UNHCR tents and balloon-shaped shelters that refugees have built from sticks and bits of plastic. Everything has been blasted by red dust and nothing grows here but the ragged, thorned acacia trees. The shelters are packed so tightly together there is barely room to walk between them. A fire here would have no natural barriers and the consequences would be devastating. Yet each night hundreds of families cook on open hearths, there is no other choice.

This is just one of the nightmares that is haunting David Kangethe, a programme manager for Care International, the agency struggling to deliver basic services like water, sanitation and rubbish collection.

"Refugees are building everywhere. This place is a matchbox, if you lit it up it would just burn," Mr Kangethe sighs. There are chronic water shortages, sanitation facilities are overwhelmed and diseases like cholera are rife. The need for new land is acute but so far the Kenyan government has dragged its feet, citing complaints from the local community that they are being overwhelmed by the number of refugees. Some 70,000 people live in the surrounding area, mainly animal herders who fear the loss of grazing land and scrub forest.

What is needed, according to aid workers, are three to four new camps but negotiations with Nairobi have remained deadlocked. UNHCR has looked at what it would cost to give people the basic minimum living standard. The answer is $92m and an urgent appeal has been issued. The response has been a near-deafening silence. The UK offered £2m in new money last week. Similar small pledges are trickling in but observers believe donors are waiting for a major crisis to break out before taking real action. That may happen very soon.

"If the numbers continue to increase we're headed for a crisis," says Mr Kangethe of Care. In the meantime anti-piracy efforts will continue to dominate thinking in regard to the Somalia situation. Gerry Simpson from the New York-based Human Rights Watch says the equation is simple: "When commercial interests are at stake there's money. When it's women and children there is not."

Survivors' stories

Ahmad Abdullahi Hussein

I was part of a militia that was fighting against al-Shabaab. We had to fight them. At night I was attacked in my home. I managed to go from the window. Later I found my wife was killed and only my two children Anisa and Abdulmalik were alive. The others were dead. I couldn't do anything. No-one can do anything against them.

I brought my children here to find my mother. She is in Hagadera camp, I want to be reunited with her. The children have no mother, they need mine.

Habib Waleda

In Mogadishu bombs were coming down from the sky and hitting houses. When the mortar hit my house we all just ran away. We were separated. I had nine children. Now I don't know where my husband is or where eight of my children are. I looked for them in Mogadishu but they don't have a telephone. It's impossible to find them. I found a taxi and I offered to give him the small money I had. I gave him $150 and I told him I didn't have any more money. He brought me near to the border. I don't know where they are. All I have is to hope they are coming.

Mohamed Ali

I am 70 years old. I fled from a town called Barra. I have lost my wife and my two children. I think they have gone to Bosasso, but I have not seen them for a year. I had to walk for 15 days through the desert. It was hard for me to walk because I am blind.

I had to stop and ask people for a little food along the way. Even if I go out and walk on the streets now a member of my family could walk by me and I would not see them. I have to hope that they will see me.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Somali's other piracy
[info]thorntongate wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 07:37 am (UTC)
Reporting of both piracy in Somalia, and kidnappings in Nigeria turn complex stories into branches of the 'war on terror': simplistic reporting of selected aspects of the stories, skewed to avoid revealing the behaviours of Western governments and corporations in third world countries.

To its undying credit The Independent has broken with the pack and started to explore the real story, which also includes Somalia's other piracy: overfishing.

http://www.americanchronicle.com/articles/view/87075

http://www.eastafricaforum.net/2008/09/15/somalias-real-pirates-are-foreign-fishing-ships-eritrea/

http://wardheernews.com/Articles_09/Jan/Waldo/08_The_two_piracies_in_Somalia.html

Like a lot of third world countries, Somalia needs the one thing the West doesn't off: protectionism.
Re: Somali's other piracy
[info]uanime5 wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 11:32 am (UTC)
Why would the developed world want to fish off the coast of Somalia when they have plenty of nearer seas to fish in? These articles are nonsense that don't cite any sources.
Re: Somali's other piracy
[info]thalia83 wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 02:18 am (UTC)
Because when a local government has collapsed there are absolutely no laws limiting the amount a boat can fish, whereas the developed world has many such laws. With the Suez Canal, it's a pretty short trip for European nations to go to an area that can yield a great deal more with no repercussions. It's great business, and fairly common and well documented. The NY Times did a piece on overfishing off the west coast of africa last year, where local governments are powerless or unwilling to enforce what fishing laws they have. So imagine off the coast of a land in chaos. These waters are also known to be dumping grounds for the toxic waste of other nations.
HOW TO DESTROY A COUNTRY
[info]georgesign wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 08:00 am (UTC)
World Banks, World Industrial Powers and Developed Nations seem to have done pretty good job in destroying a country. Unsustainable loans with interest that never can be paid and that never reaches the ordinary population. So called free-trade that destroys the local economy, industrial fishing of the seas and the dumping of toxic waste. The international leaders bleat on about helping but at the same time cause the problem. To wage terror and war needs money. Now three guesses who has the money?
Think about it next time you see our wonderful leaders getting together for mutual back slapping enjoying sumptuous meals and the best the world can offer whether it be The United Nations or World Economic Summits.
Somalia
[info]gwilymr_j wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 09:46 am (UTC)
Surely there is room for all of them in Britain?
Re: Somalia
[info]corporeal4now wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 10:14 am (UTC)

Somewhat evil joke. What makes you think that everyone wants to come to the UK?

What that want is their country to stable, safe and have good prosperity - exactly what every other human wants.

If only the international powers (USA) would stop meddling in their affairs, by encouraging their neighbours to go to war with them on a regular basis, they might just get what they want.
[info]tuerke9 wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 11:06 am (UTC)
The western countries should indeed stop meddling in the affairs of Somalia. Indeed they should stop meddling with all African countries. That means no more money, no more food, no more technology.
It is time to see if these societies can exist on their own or die out as cultures. The situation now resembles a patient on Hospice. You are feeding them and reducing their pain but in the end you expect them to die. What is the point.
Human tide of misery flees the anarchy of Somalia
[info]ilmaas wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 11:09 am (UTC)
i think you have missed point or you did delibertely to mislead your western readers since they don't have any back ground the conflict of somalia.The Mojority of refuges in this camp they come during Ethiopian aaccupation in southern somalia not after they left. If someone looks close in the conclusion your article can easily sees who you want blame this human tragedy.
Survivors' stories

Ahmad Abdullahi Hussein

I was part of a militia that was fighting against al-Shabaab. We had to fight them. At night I was attacked in my home. I managed to go from the window. Later I found my wife was killed and only my two children Anisa and Abdulmalik were alive. The others were dead. I couldn't do anything. No-one can do anything against them.

I brought my children here to find my mother. She is in Hagadera camp, I want to be reunited with her. The children have no mother, they need mine.

Habib Waleda

In Mogadishu bombs were coming down from the sky and hitting houses. When the mortar hit my house we all just ran away. We were separated. I had nine children. Now I don't know where my husband is or where eight of my children are. I looked for them in Mogadishu but they don't have a telephone. It's impossible to find them. I found a taxi and I offered to give him the small money I had. I gave him $150 and I told him I didn't have any more money. He brought me near to the border. I don't know where they are. All I have is to hope they are coming.

Mohamed Ali

I am 70 years old. I fled from a town called Barra. I have lost my wife and my two children. I think they have gone to Bosasso, but I have not seen them for a year. I had to walk for 15 days through the desert. It was hard for me to walk because I am blind.

I had to stop and ask people for a little food along the way. Even if I go out and walk on the streets now a member of my family could walk by me and I would not see them. I have to hope that they will see me.
Off we go...again
[info]kodak321 wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 11:41 am (UTC)
The West is blamed for the failure of any despotic Country in Africa, or the rest of the world for that matter. The Ethiopean-Somali conflict has been going on for Centuries with substantial hostilities in the latter part of the Tewentieth Century. Africa cannot be ruled by Africans....proven time and time again. Wait for the next major conflict...it will happen...
Re: Off we go...again
[info]corporeal4now wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 12:42 pm (UTC)

Virtually every country in the world has been as war with its neighbours for centuries, including British with the Irish.

What we are talking about is the meddling by the USA by propping up Ethopia and encouraging it to fight with Somalia. This is unwanted external influence. It's in the interest of the USA.
Re: Off we go...again
[info]kodak321 wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 01:27 pm (UTC)
Yes, against militant Islamists who cannot agree with eachother and are totally incapable of forming a Government of Integrity. This is a war against Islam. And of course you forget to mention they are armed by the Arabs and Eritreans. Typical left wing, pro-Islamic (why don't you covert), US basher.
Listen: Audio feature, Accounts from Somali Refugees
[info]derringdo22 wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 01:56 pm (UTC)
Bad unicode input
[info]blastarrbxiii wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 02:09 pm (UTC)
Bad unicode input or something else??.
Come on down Mr Somalian, Come on down!.
[info]blastarrbxiii wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 02:32 pm (UTC)
I'll try again.

These Samali types are just in time, all they have to do is hang on a bit.
What with
EU Commissioner Louis Michel and his daft master plan for the mobility of workers between Africa and the EU.

Involving 'inviting' 50 Million or more Africans in to Britain and the rest of the EU.

Some of these lot could be signed up now!.

Mind you, they had best not be relocated to Portsmouth or the Dover area or we won't have any shipping going through the English Channel.

Most people empathize with their plight, I certainly do.
But Africans have been around for as long as we have.
They just do not have that 'get up and go' that the rest of the People of World have,
(could be why they stayed put!!).

We have the horror of Natural Selection on this scale taking place.
Messing about with Natural Selection isn't a good idea.

Another Country like Zimbabwe that wanted 'Independance'.
Well they both what they wanted.
Recent History
[info]falanf wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 05:29 pm (UTC)
"UN Security Council Resolution 794 was unanimously passed on December 3, 1992, which approved a coalition of United Nations peacekeepers led by the United States to form UNITAF, tasked with ensuring humanitarian aid being distributed and peace being established in Somalia. The UN humanitarian troops landed in 1993 and started a two-year effort (primarily in the south) to alleviate famine conditions.Many Somalis opposed the foreign presence. In October, several gun battles in Mogadishu between local gunmen and peacekeepers resulted in the death of 24 Pakistanis and 19 US soldiers (total US deaths were 31). Most of the Americans were killed in the Battle of Mogadishu. The UN withdrew on March 3, 1995, having suffered more significant casualties. Order in Somalia still has not been restored".
Seems as if there was a chance to improve conditions and life in Somalia but the gunmen rejected it. So perhaps there is nothing we can do - in reality, people get the governments (or lack of same) that they deserve. But if those same gunmen threaten us outside their territory, then we have to react.


What a shame on us.
[info]famulla wrote:
Friday, 17 April 2009 at 05:32 pm (UTC)
Somali pirates take ships and we sleep or at least close our eyes. We want to go to the moon and we cannot control few pirates in the dhows. We attacked Iraq, but we fail to stop the Somalis from stealing our merchandises. What a shame on us.
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla
Re: What a shame on us.
[info]falanf wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 07:22 am (UTC)
"the Somalis from stealing our merchandises". And what shame on them?
Re: What a shame on us.
[info]famulla wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 11:32 am (UTC)
Yes. We are bad, shame on us, they are proud by stealing from us, we look on the waters to give us seem solutions; we are bad, are we not?
Re: What a shame on us.
[info]falanf wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 11:59 am (UTC)
What??
Unbearable Crisis in Somalia
[info]emalhotra wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 01:44 am (UTC)
There has to be some way to get help to these people! Perhaps a grass-roots fund drive to assist UNHCR build the new camps. Isn't anyone listening?!
RE: Somalia
[info]hibaaq wrote:
Saturday, 18 April 2009 at 10:52 pm (UTC)
why are we just blaming the problem on western countries, why not on the so called somali government who rip off these peoples land and rights for the sake money and, at the end of the day how much money can humans beings spend in a lifetime to ruin these peopls lifes. As a somalian myself i blame the somali government and the so called muslim world who only back the weatern countries. How much money and power do these people need in order to destroy thier own land and people. One thing we have to think about is that long after we have destroyed our lands,blood,the world, money will still cease to exist so we have to ask our selfs is it really worth it.
[info]kees80 wrote:
Friday, 24 April 2009 at 12:05 am (UTC)
Anarchy is a political movement, founded on the ideal state as not needing government. This is far from the case in Somalia, so I assume that the Independant is referring to chaos.
natural selection?
[info]hasos wrote:
Thursday, 21 May 2009 at 05:50 pm (UTC)
its quite unfortunate for some people to use evolution
to cover and deny what their fore fathers caused...
take alook at south africa?...people denied of education
because of aparthied rule......its about survival
black people will flood to the uk wheather you
like it or not,you cant run away from your history
after all,we all like abit of blackness


Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date