Commentators

Rain (AM and PM) 3° London Hi 9°C / Lo 6°C

Dambisa Moyo: Aid dependency blights Africa. The cure is in the credit crisis

Far from being a catalyst, foreign aid inhibits the continent's growth

The credit crisis was – inevitably – the dominant theme of the annual World Economic Forum that concluded in Davos over the weekend. And while other subjects – diversity and culture, the Israel-Gaza conflict, and even Zimbabwe – did get a look-in, there was little said about the opportunity the crisis presents for aid-dependent African countries.

Setting aside the debate on how (or indeed whether) sub-Saharan Africa will be affected in the short term by the ongoing financial turmoil, there is every reason to believe that what is happening could in fact be the best thing for Africa's long-term development prospects.

The crisis presents Africa with a unique opportunity to overhaul its development strategy away from the aid-based model (which despite its over one trillion-dollar injection has achieved little in terms of delivering growth and alleviating poverty over the last 50 years) and move more aggressively towards the kind of market-driven interventions that have fundamentally transformed the fortunes of emerging countries, such as the well-known BRIC economies – Brazil, Russia, India and China – but also, closer to home, South Africa and Botswana.

In the last five years Africa's economic performance has been encouraging. Its economies have grown by an average of five per cent per year, and at the end of 2006, three out of the top 10 fastest-growing economies in the world were African (Angola, Sudan, and Mauritania). In just two decades, Africa's GDP has roughly doubled from $130bn in the 1980s to around $300bn today. The question is how best to make this development trajectory stick.

I have long believed that far from being a catalyst, foreign aid has been the biggest single inhibitor of Africa's growth. Among its shortcomings, aid is correlated with corruption, fosters dependency, and invariably instils bureaucracy that hinders the emergence of an essential entrepreneurial class. For Africa to grow in a sustained way, foreign aid will have to be dramatically reduced over time, forcing countries to adopt more transparent strategies to finance development.

What the credit crunch has effectively done is to instigate this process by default. With Western donors facing mounting fiscal pressures and gaping deficits, foreign aid flows are in inevitable decline (Italy has already cut its foreign aid budget by half), and with this comes a chance for Africa to chart a strategy that delivers long-term economic growth. This is, after all, ostensibly the goal of any individual or institution that wishes to see Africa become an equal partner in the global community.

The development finance policy that has been the hallmark of consistent growth across the world has almost universally comprised a mix of four essential elements: Trade and commerce, Foreign Direct Investment (FDI), microfinance, and access to international capital markets.

As such, despite negative headlines over China's expanding role in Africa's burgeoning economy, African governments should be minded to accelerate alliances with China and the rest of the rapidly emerging world. Rather than continue to spend millions of dollars each year attempting to gain greater access to Western trade markets, they should focus their attention on markets such as China, where, with 1.3bn people to feed and just seven per cent arable land, African produce is welcome.

And with roughly $4 trillion of foreign reserves, China is undoubtedly a better bet for much needed FDI in the foreseeable future than its Western competitors. Furthermore, the reserves profile of not just China but also the Middle East suggests a class of new investors with likely appetite to take on African risk via the bond markets.

In the past 18 months the sovereign bond issues of Ghana and Gabon (as well as a number of corporate and bank issues) have shown that innovative thinking towards more transparent methods of financing Africa's development may be catching on – but there is clearly scope for improvement.

No one can say for sure how long market-based financing would take to yield sturdy growth for Africa, but one thing is for sure, it will be faster than continuing to rely on aid. These dark economic times are just the opening Africa needs to show that it can at last contribute meaningfully to the global economy rather than perennially being viewed as a drag.

Dambisa Moyo is a former economist at Goldman Sachs and the author of 'Dead Aid: Why Aid is Not Working and How There is Another Way for Africa', to be published by Allen Lane on Thursday. www.deadaid.org

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

There are hundreds of millions of very poor people across the entire world
[info]exec_ceo wrote:
Monday, 2 February 2009 at 01:49 am (UTC)
and most of them are not terrorist-supporters like the religious radicals in the palestinian areas.
Re: There are hundreds of millions of very poor people across the entire world
[info]hkaraki wrote:
Tuesday, 3 February 2009 at 12:03 am (UTC)
exec_ceo, please keep unrelated comments like these to the appropriate articles. I don't know what your deal is but every comment you ever write seems to have the same underlying message: "Isreal is immune to mistakes and most Arabs are blood hungry radical extremists that are better off dead anyway so killing them doesn't really count". We get your message of hate, we don't agree with it, so please shut the hell up.
Saddo
[info]peds31 wrote:
Monday, 2 February 2009 at 10:50 am (UTC)
and most of them are not fascist-supporters like the religious criminals in the Israeli state.
Aid does work
[info]dcm_5 wrote:
Monday, 2 February 2009 at 11:04 am (UTC)
Aid doesn't work? Aid is an inhibitor to growth? Nonsense.

"Over the last five years, African economies have grown by an average of 5%" - so clearly Aid isn't stopping that growth.

"Fastest growing economies, Angola, Sudan and Mauritania" - Angola and Sudan's economies have grown so fast purely because of Oil, not because they have suddenly become free market economies.

Aid is linked to corruption. That depends - you can't make such a sweeping generalization. Does Botswana not receive aid - despite it using "market-based interventions"? Does Nigeria not lose its oil revenues to corruption (selling oil is good for the market right?) Corruption happens because people are poor or because people are greedy. As people get wealthier it'll reduce, as institutions develop it will reduce. Though remember Western nations aren't immune from corruption either.

Whilst I agree that trade is the way forward and that China is a huge market, if the West was more willing to allow fair trade with Africa then African economies would be far more developed than they are now. Well targeted aid, combined with trade is the answer.
[info]tamedu wrote:
Friday, 6 February 2009 at 10:15 pm (UTC)
moyo was quite right to some extent about the africa over dependency on foreign aid .these has been a major impedement on economic growth of most african countries couple with corruptions of their leaders .africa has what it take to be self dependent and self reliant with huge resources scatter accross the continent .africa needs to start exploring ways of addressing its econmicalproblems .identify the area were things have gone wrong .china ,india are the the emerging power in world dominated by west ,the reason been they are making good use of their available resourses at their disposal .

Columnist Comments

mary_dejevsky

Mary Dejevsky: Cool realism is a political virtue, too

No ideological vision could have replaced sound judgement in 1989

terence_blacker

Terence Blacker: Reality TV police shows are criminal

For half an hour, the real world is presented in black-and-white terms

dominic_lawson

Dominic Lawson: The only options are to double up in Afghanistan or leave

At a risk of sounding callous, the number of casualties is actually small for a war


Loading...


Most popular in Opinion