Robert Fisk’s World: A brave man who stood alone. If only the world had listened to him
I wish I had met Tom Hurndall, a remarkable man of remarkable principle
I don't know if I met Tom Hurndall. He was one of a bunch of "human shields" who turned up in Baghdad just before the Anglo-American invasion in 2003, the kind of folk we professional reporters make fun of. Tree huggers, that kind of thing. Now I wish I had met him because – looking back over the history of that terrible war – Hurndall's journals (soon to be published) show a remarkable man of remarkable principle. "I may not be a human shield," he wrote at 10.26 on 17 March from his Amman hotel. "And I may not adhere to the beliefs of those I have travelled with, but the way Britain and America plan to take Iraq is unnecessary and puts soldiers' lives above those of civilians. For that I hope that Bush and Blair stand trial for war crimes."
Hurndall got it about right, didn't he? It wasn't so simple as war/no war, black and white, he wrote. "Things I've heard and seen over the last few weeks proves what I already knew; neither the Iraqi regime, nor the American or British, are clean. Maybe Saddam needs to go but ... the air war that's proposed is largely unnecessary and doesn't discriminate between civilians and armed soldiers. Tens of thousands will die, maybe hundreds of thousands, just to save thousands of American soldiers having to fight honestly, hand to hand. It is wrong." Oh, how many of my professional colleagues wrote like this on the eve of war? Not many.
We pooh-poohed the Hurndalls and their friends as groupies even when they did briefly enter the South Baghdad electricity station and met one engineer, Attiah Bakir, who had been horrifyingly wounded 11 years earlier when an American bomb blew a fragment of metal into his brain. "You can see now where it struck," Hurndall wrote in an email from Baghdad, "caving in the central third of his forehead and removing the bone totally. Above the bridge of his broken nose, there is only a cavity with scarred skin covering the prominent gap..."
A picture of Attiah Bakir stares out of the book, a distinguished, brave man who refused to leave his place of work as the next war approached. He was silenced only when one of Hurndall's friends made the mistake of asking what he thought of Saddam's government. I cringed for the poor man. "Minders" were everywhere in those early days. Talking to any civilian was almost criminally foolish. Iraqis were forbidden from talking to foreigners. Hence all those bloody "minders" (many of whom, of course, ended up working for Baghdad journalists after Saddam's overthrow).
Hurndall had a dispassionate eye. "Nowhere in the world have I ever seen so many stars as now in the western deserts of Iraq," he wrote on 22 February. "How can somewhere so beautiful be so wrought with terror and war as it is soon to be?" In answer to the questions asked of them by the BBC, ITV, WBO, CNN, al-Jazeera and others, Hurndall had no single reply. "I don't think there could be one, two or 100 responses," he wrote. "To each of us our own, but not one of us wants to die." Prophetic words for Tom to have written.
You can see him smiling selflessly in several snapshots. He went to cover the refugee complex at Al-Rowaishid and moved inexorably towards Gaza where he was confronted by the massive tragedy of the Palestinians. "I woke up at about eight in my bed in Jerusalem and lay in until 9.30," he wrote. "We left at 10.00... Since then, I have been shot at, gassed, chased by soldiers, had sound grenades thrown within metres of me, been hit by falling debris..."
Hurndall was trying to save Palestinian homes and infrastructure but frequently came under Israeli fire and seemed to have lost his fear of death. "While approaching the area, they (the Israelis) continually fired one- to two-second bursts from what I could see was a Bradley fighting vehicle... It was strange that as we approached and the guns were firing, it sent shivers down my spine, but nothing more than that. We walked down the middle of the street, wearing bright orange, and one of us shouted through a loudspeaker, 'We are International volunteers. Don't shoot!' That was followed by another volley of fire, though I can't be sure where from..."
Tom Hurndall had stayed in Rafah. He was only 21 where – in his mother's words – he lost his life through a single, selfless, human act. "Tom was shot in the head as he carried a single Palestinian child out of the range of an Israeli army sniper." Mrs Hurndall asked me to write a preface to Tom's book and this article is his preface, for a brave man who stood alone and showed more courage than most if us dreamed of. Forget tree huggers. Hurndall was one good man and true.
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited


Comments
He was, he is...
Best wishes, as always,
Federico Antin
Finally, all decent human beings should be proud of Tom Hurndall and Rachel Corrie and cherish their memories forever. They were real heroes who sacrificed their young lives for humanity and just cause.
Shakespeare said that cowards die many times before their deaths,
The valiant never taste of death but once. Tom and Rachel tasted death but once unlike the Israelis.
Some say: This is one ward you say ;if you did not say it you are dead,if you say it you are dead too.
SO SAY IT AND DIE IN Dignity
our current politician like kids,one time talk from head one time talk from bottom end.
I saw 2 years old boy,putting easy up pamers one head other day on the bottom.
For more about Rachel Corrie, go here: http://theunpeople.blogspot.com/sea
For more about the most recent ISM casualty, Tristan Anderson, go here: http://theunpeople.blogspot.com/sea
You only care about any American who dies in a situation that can be blamed on Israel.
If some American died in an arab or muslim country while protesting something, you'd not give a crap.
Fake peace activists who are really just out to demonize Israel.
Instead, people like that are just pawns for nutty radicals.
Just like if arab countries near Israel really cared about the palestinians, they'd offer the palestinians citizenship.
But, they don't really care about the palestinians, so they just urge the palestinians to keep attacking Israel.
My father had to stand up in court and explain that his religious beliefs lead him to believe it was wrong to kill others just because they were of another nation. My father became a doctor and healer and to save life was his mission.
Many thousands have been killed in the Iraq conflict, and Tom Hurndall stood up for the many victims who wanted no part in it. He was a brave man and we should honour him.
There is something special about standing up for an actual good belief.
Standing up in favor of crazy radical islamic fundamentalists isn't a good belief.
It is people like exec_ceo who blindly support a racist ideology, Zionism, that are just plain evil and must be fought against.
What self righteous, pompous bollocks, the conspiracy theories have been voiced before, by like minded bigots, so you had nothing new to say. The one point on which there can be no disagreement, is that Fisk is a voice in the wilderness, long may he remain so !
2. Hurndall in his own words is now a military expert who knows how best the war in Iraq should be fought
3. Like many journalists (and soldiers) he got a high defying death
4. The international volunteers who act as human shields to protect rock andmolitov bottle throwers are well aware of what they are doing and risking.
He may have meant well and was a good man but thats it.
He had the option of leaving if his courage ran out the children in sederot have to lose their legs (oshri aged 8) because of the rockets .
I SUPPOSE OUR GREAT HUMANIST WOULD HAVE SUPPORTED ISRAEL SUPPLYING THE PALESTINIANS WITH FERTILISER AND METAL TUBES THAT CAN BE CONVERTED TO EXPLOSIVES AND ROCKETS.
Likewise i have no feelings of being a victim despite the efforts of some of my neighbours.
For the record my family origins are Iranian and the family left for the , at the time ,turkish occupied Israel after the patraich of the family was murdered in the 1880s for being a jew.
I do not relish the loss of life but surely there must be a place for Common Sense. but then, Tom Hurndall was aware of this so it makes him braver in some people's eyes.
The Israeli State faces a hostile and cunning enemy all around its borders. 8,000 rockets in a few years amounts to far more provocation than any European country would tolerate. The argument is often posted that Israeli Jews should 'go back where they came from'. Would the same people who propose this agree that all non W.A.S.P. immigrants into Europe during the past 60 years be sent 'back to where they came from' ???
I think not ! It's high time to stop the hypocrisy that surrounds the Arab/Israeli conflict.
And why are the Arabs "cunning"?
You appear to be on this site quite a lot and at various times. I read the Independent during my lunch break at work and never get time to post as I'm back doing my job with 45 minutes. As I'm off today I wanted to respond to your tripe. I conclude that your volume of contributions are due to one of the following:
You do not have a job? Are you someone who preoccupies his time with onanism, eating processed potato products and typing utter asinine drivel? Perhaps you should use this internet time to gain meaningful employment; use it to search for a job and stop being a drain on the good people of your country! For their efforts and work ethic are paying for your benefits - you are a parasite who steals their hard earned money with every welfare payment you receive.
You are in employment but spend too much time writing such nonsense? Your employer will be paying you a salary and will expect a return on this, but yet you're always on this website commenting with fundamentalist claptrap. This is a form of theft; you're cheating your company and adversely damaging their business. In a time of global recession this is shocking behaviour.
You are someone who has combined his vocation with his hobbies. You are employed by the Israeli Government (or a Pro-Israeli group) to search for sites and act as an archetypal Pro-Israeli apologist to deflect criticism? You are no different from the fundamentalists that you purport to condemn for you are the propagandist that justifies Israeli actions regardless of what has occurred. Did you attend the Goebbels school of doublethink?
So which one is it?
I await your glib diatribe with glee you fakir!
Toodle pip!
The point is not whether we care about americans or not. Your comment serves only to stop any serious discussion about the behaviour of the Israeli army in the Occupied Territories.
If your beloved wonderful cuddly palestinians ever declare permanent peace with israel, israel won't have to do anything and israel can focus full time in doing what it does best, develop tech companies, make advances in science, and enjoy life 24/7
1) If you care about the palestinians, you should urge them to declare a permanent peace with Israel, instead of watching them continue to try destroy Israel, only to fail badly, and only to get smacked around in response.
2) If you care about the palestinians, you should wonder why all the arab countries that surround the palestinians don't offer them citizenship and instaed just urge them to keep attacking Israel, kknowing it will only result in more losing.
3) I want peace for both israel and palestinians and feel that can never happen as long as lunatics like hamas are the role models and leaders for the palestinians.
4) For people who rant day and night about history, well, palestine was just a territory, not a country, and 80% of palestine became Jordan in the early 1900's, and the only people who pretend that israel is half or most of what palestine was are either MISINFORMED or LIARS.
5) It's 2009 now. Israel exists. It isn't leaving. The radical islamic fundamentalist world still doesn't seem to grasp this.
If what I want happened, palsetinans and israelis would have peace, and the palestinians would get their own (second) state on the vast majority of the land they claim they want (the land they HAD in 1967 yet chose not to form a state on).
THe people who insult me here are almost always people who don't REALLY care about the palestinians, and don't REALLY care about peace, and just want to demonize Israel. ANd 99% of the time they're people who also rant looney stuff about zionism and make it clear their REAL GOAL is just to undo the very existence of israel.
Deal.
Walk it off.
Ever see those maps from the 1920s? Notice how the British Mandate comprised a) "Palestine" and b) "Trans-Jordan"?
It indicates that the two are mutually exclusive.
Whether you're aware of the above or not, the impresion you give is that Israel should expand to include the occupied territories. Nasty stuff.
You must be done-in from all that posting. Or are you just copying and pasting from one of your "standard rant" word documents?
The main message of my opponents is that israel should be destroyed or has no right to even exist.
Those are the sides.
Israel was created illegally because of German atrocities and Western guilt. Only the Palestinian Jews (Mizrahi) have the right to be there. All others especially the Ashkenazi Jews from Europe and North America have no right whatsoever to be there. In fact, the Ashkenazi Jews are not Semitic unlike Arabs or Palestinian Jews who belong to the Semitic race. People like you who condemn selfless heroes like Tom Hurndall and Rachel Corrie are simply vile and immoral. All you want is to force everyone in the world to accept the German atrocities against the Ashkenazi Jews, but you do not want us to condemn the Israeli atrocities against defenseless Palestinians including women and children which are committed in front of live cameras. The Israeli atrocities are worst than the Nazis because they shamelessly commit them in front of live cameras without shame or remorse.
Israel was created as legally as most countries on this planet.
Once again, the Jewish side did themselves no favours. Time and again, he kept throwing out talking points (approved in advance by the Foreign Ministry) and tried to shout down the attorney. Do any Israeli supprters realize that this does nothing to help their cause?
No. Instead, it's the same standby lines. How dare you talk to me about suffering? Were 6 million of your people killed? What the hell do YOU know about "suffering"?
Since when do all Zionists have a monopoly on suffering? The cynical part of me knows that in this global soundbite age, various governments will spew this stuff out. On the other hand, if they actually stopped to listen and have a real debate about this, wouldn't that help both sides? But do the Zionists listen? No. And meanwhile the same people have the same pointless "debates" that the MSM promotes as REAL TV!
No it's not. http://globalcomedy.wordpress.com has some good ideas about this. I found it pretty enlightening.
That's fascinating. I'm sure Press TV, an Iranian news outlet, is very fair and unbiased.
It's very sad to hear of Tom Hurndall's death. But he knew full well the danger of colluding with militants and stone throwers, lived a very risky life knowing full well the dangers. The soldier who shot him, an Israeli Bedouin, was convicted for manslaughter and sent to prison.
Mr Fisk has a very high sensitivity for Palestinians, pro-Palestinians, and members of the press. And that's fine.
But I'd also like to hear from him, once, ONCE, about Israelis who threw themselves at suicide bombers to save those around them, about families that lost their loved ones to terror and expressed their support for the peace process and for reaching out to the Palestinians. About the hundreds of victim of Hamas and Hizbolla terror who Fisk blatantly ignores, week after week, year after year.
"If only the world had listened to him." But what was he saying? Really?