Commentators

Rain (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 9°C / Lo 7°C

Malalai Joya: Don't be fooled by this democratic façade – the people are betrayed

In hiding and in fear of her life, the Afghan MP and women's rights campaigner says the warlords have already won

Like millions of Afghans, I have no hope in the results of today's election. In a country ruled by warlords, occupation forces, Taliban terrorists, drug money and guns, no one can expect a legitimate or fair vote. Even international observers have been speaking about widespread fraud and intimidation and, among the people on the street, there is a common refrain: the real winner has already been picked by the White House.

President Hamid Karzai has cemented alliances with brutal warlords and fundamentalists in order to maintain his position. Although our constitution forbids war criminals from running for office, the incumbent has named two notorious militia commanders as his vice-presidential running mates – Karim Khalili and Mohammad Qasim Fahim, both of whom stand accused of brutalities against our people.

Deals have also been made with countless fundamentalists. This week saw the return from exile of the dreaded warlord Rashid Dostum. And the pro-Iranian extremist Mohammad Mohaqiq, who has been accused of war crimes, has been promised five cabinet positions for his party in exchange for supporting Mr Karzai.

Rather than democracy, what we have in Afghanistan are back-room deals among discredited warlords who are sworn enemies of democracy and justice.

The President has also continued to absolutely betray the women of Afghanistan.

Even after massive international outcry – and brave protesters taking to the streets of Kabul – Mr Karzai implemented the infamous rape law, targeting Shia women, to gain support of the fundamentalist elements in the election. He had initially promised to review the most egregious clauses, but in the end it was passed with few amendments and the barbaric anti-women statements not removed. As Human Rights Watch recently stated: "Karzai has made an unthinkable deal to sell Afghan women out in return for the support of fundamentalists."

And the two main challengers to a continuation of the Karzai rule do not offer any change. Ashraf Ghani and Abdullah Abdullah are both former cabinet ministers in this discredited regime and neither has a real, broad footing among the people.

Mr Abdullah, as the main candidate of fundamentalist warlords, has run a wide campaign with money he is receiving from the Iranian regime. He and some of the Northern Alliance commanders supporting him have threatened unrest if he loses the vote, raising fears of a return to the rampant violence and killing that marked the civil war years of the 1990s.

All of the major candidates' speeches and policies are very similar. They make the same sweet-sounding promises, but we are not fooled. Afghans remember how Mr Karzai abandoned his campaign pledges after winning the 2005 vote.

We Afghans know that this election will change nothing and it is only part of a show of democracy put on by, and for, the West, to legitimise its future puppet in Afghanistan. It seems we are doomed to see the continuation of this failed, mafia-like, corrupt government for another term.

The people of Afghanistan are fed up with the rampant corruption of Karzai's "narco-state" (his own brother, Wali Karzai, has been linked to drug trafficking in Kandahar province) and the escalating war waged by Nato. In May of this year, US air strikes killed approximately 150 civilians in my native province, Farah.

More than ever, Afghans are faced with powerful internal enemies – fundamentalist warlords and their Taliban brothers-in-creed – and the external enemies occupying the country.

Democracy will never come to Afghanistan through the barrel of a gun, or from the cluster bombs dropped by foreign forces. The struggle will be long and difficult, but the values of real democracy, human rights and women's rights will only be won by the Afghan people themselves.

So do not be fooled by this façade of democracy. The British and other Western governments that claim to be bringing democracy to Afghanistan ignore public opinion in their own countries, where growing numbers are against the war.

In my tours to countries that have troops in Afghanistan, I've met many bereaved parents who have lost their loved ones in the war in my home. I am very sorry to see governments putting the lives of their soldiers in danger in Afghanistan in the name of bringing democracy. In fact the soldiers are serving the strategic and regional interests of the White House and the consequences of their occupation so far have been devastating for my people.

I believe that if the ordinary folk of Afghanistan and the Nato countries were able to vote, and express their wishes, this indefinite military occupation would come to an end and there would be a real chance for peace in Afghanistan. But today's election does nothing for that.

The writer is an Afghan politician. In 2005, she became the youngest person to be elected to the new parliament, representing Farah province. Her new book Raising My Voice is out now

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Tell that to the Indy - wait a minute, this IS the Indy!
[info]fin_d_empire wrote:
Thursday, 20 August 2009 at 07:16 am (UTC)
The Indy's barmy leader says: "Britain and the rest of Nato must stay the course."

The Indy practically worshipped Mamalai Joya in the past when she was good PR for the War Party's "liberating Afghan women" BS but now that she's turned anti-war her career as the West's poster girl may be over before long. Before you know it, some warlord will be told where she lives and she will get her pink slip from the barrel of an AK-47.
This world needs you, but doesn't deserve you.
[info]guayacan wrote:
Thursday, 20 August 2009 at 04:19 pm (UTC)
I am bored with the word "hero" labeled on all dead soldiers from Afghanistan (and I am ex-forces). I am also bored with the governments attempts to convince us of the need to be there. I am bored with equal pay for females.
I am distraught that drugs traffickers and mass murderers are accepted as the norm by the west (why did we go there in the first place?). This is a huge failure without precedent. Our children will read this as history. I am ashamed......and bored.
However, I do see a heroine, a female with a real mission. This woman faces more than torture or slaughter and still she protests. She actually sees both sides of the coin. What a shame the coin could not be tossed fairly, as the west had promised.
I am ashamed to be British. What an absolute disaster Tony Bliar has created. How can this man be a celebrity. How can this woman not................how bloody boring.
Johann Hari
[info]n_s_eakins wrote:
Friday, 18 September 2009 at 10:48 am (UTC)
Hi Malalai

I'm just writing to say how much I am moved by your brave, dare I say, close to suicidal stance against the thugs (Marines, exploiters, etc.) and I am heartbroken by the devastation caused to the land, the culture but above all the children of the Muslim world. From the rioting in the UK to the fighting in China to the hope that the Ombama administration can provide the security the people desperately need with the hope of progress (including justice) with an end to Israeli aggression in response to minor acts of provocation designed to fuel the polarities that besiege all we dared to consider civilised. With this in mind I'd like to confirm that regardless of the inability of the likes of Johann Hari to 'get it' or offer any kind of solidarity, encouragement or true empathy I'm writing to also confirm that I do not agree with some of your views as my father was in NY when 9/11 happened and that fund raising event was caused by a breakdown in communication between East and west. In 1993 Saddam Hussein attempted to kill ex President George Bush (snr) and given his families oil interests the invasion of Iran (then Iraq) was inevitable although the murderous stupidity of Tony Blair by turning the multicultural, none imperialist, tourist town that was the UK against itself rather than sit on the sidelines will live on the conscience of all those who demand Israel withdraws from the Golan Heights as Israel has air superiority. Salman Rushdie will always have security granted him regardless of his rather trite books, the thinking people of the UK demand no less for yourself and your hard fought victory for freedom and democracy will shine like a constellation in the never fading sky.

Columnist Comments

andrew_grice

Andrew Grice: Enough of the philosophy, Mr Cameron.

Think-tanks play an important role in politics. But they have their limits.

christina_patterson

Christina Patterson: Very nice - but forgiveness is overrated

Sometimes, as Lydon sang, in his post Sex Pistols band, 'anger is an energy.'

mary_dejevsky

Mary Dejevsky: Why not call Blair now and wrap it up?

The enquiry already seems like a sideline as the queues dwindle.


Loading...


Most popular in Opinion