Yasmin Alibhai-Brown: We Muslims who despair of terrorism
Monday, 22 September 2008
The admired Scots-Pakistani novelist Suhayl Saadi and his wife, Alina Mirza, who runs a Pakistani film festival in Glasgow, are dear friends. They got married at the Marriot in Islamabad, just bombed by Islamicist murderers who sent in a delivery of lethal explosives in a lorry, during Ramadan. Nice work, guys. Allah will surely reward you aplenty for the slaughter of the blameless, sent off with less ceremony than goats and chickens who, at least, are prayed for as their throats are cut. Ah but they only razed a temple of Western decadence, and many Muslims who worked or went there weren't "real" Muslims, only Shias and disobedient women, reprobates and sinners for sure.
The couple are devastated, rendered hopeless – for the first time that I can remember. For years, in spite of Pakistan's many failures, they have kept up a fierce optimism, as if heartfelt belief would, one day, drive away the evil forces that circulate and in parts overrun their ancestral homeland.
There are many more like them, Pakistani-Britons who are proud of the culture of Pakistan, its creative movers and shakers, and millions of extraordinary, generous people. But their pride and idealism are fast draining away.
My father came from Karachi. He fled the place in the 1920s and went back only once, a fortnight before he died in 1970. He never recovered from the experience. It was as if his heart gave up. The country was in the grip of the military again and savagery ruled. It still does. I have never felt the desire to go look for cousins, aunts and uncles.
The newly elected President, Asif Zardari, husband of Benazir Bhutto, new best friend of the United States, is one of that nation's dodgiest characters. He replaced a military dictator, who replaced another allegedly corrupt politician, Nawaz Sharif, now a big player in the latest political configuration.
Armageddon is on its way as Pakistan dissolves at its north-western borders into that lawless territory that is Afghanistan. American interventions, demands and military incontinence in the region bolster Islamic reactionaries and guerrillas.
India meanwhile, with many similar endemic problems and ruthless governance in Kashmir, nevertheless flowers economically and still holds on to democracy and fundamental freedoms. Sadly Pakistan "proves" what the rest of the world believes, and not without reason, that Muslims are incapable of decent leadership or progressive politics and move instinctively to political and personal tyranny.
Look around and the evidence punches you in both eyes. Saudi Arabia, Iran and various nations in the Middle East and most "Islamic" states elsewhere are failing entities where the people are either afraid or oppressing others. I, a Muslim who fights daily against the unjust treatment of Muslims in the West, have to face the blinding truth that although we have serious external enemies, more Muslims are hurt, wounded, killed and denied by other Muslims who feel themselves to be virtuous.
Lest our detractors rub their hands with satisfaction, I tell them loud and clear, this is not exoneration of Guantanamo Bay, the destruction of Iraq, Belmarsh, Israel's criminal treatment of Palestinians in Gaza, the fascists in Cologne who tried this week to run an anti-Islam rally, the viciously anti-Muslim BNP and the many ways Europe humiliates us Muslims.
But I am saying that Muslims enthusiastically participate in "rendition", torture co-religionists in prisons, bomb fellow-worshippers from Iraq to Pakistan and beyond, subjugate their women, cut off hands and necks, keep their young cowering or brainwash them to the point when they are unfit to inhabit this century. If we respect and care for our own so little why should the rest of the world give a damn?
The night I fell in love with 'Strictly'
On Saturday, I went off to a live recording of Strictly Come Dancing. I took my teenage daughter who thinks the programme is great, as do her mates. Amazing but true. The Amy Winehouse/Kate Moss generation is turned on by men in slashed shirts and lycra, tails, stiff white collars, sequinned ball gowns and frills. I was game for a laugh, imagining giggles bubbling over as Bruce Forsyth frolicked and ballroom swirls and twirls were attempted by rough rugby sorts and the portly political journo John Sergeant, left.
Truth to tell, it was delightful. Men who were never born to dance glided about so gracefully that you wanted to be in their strong arms. Conversely, those who prickle with overconfidence, like Gary Rhodes, need more fluidity. Some judges were needlessly harsh, but there was no descent into ritual humiliation.
Such shows bring families and the nation together in front of the telly. They glamorise physical activity and awaken empathy, good things. All I want now is to put on my dancing shoes. Maybe I should ask John Sergeant for a date.
The mystery of Carla just keeps on growing
Oh, Carla Bruni is very lovely, no question, but who is she really? The chanteuse lures with her musky voice. On his show, Jools Holland was eaten like a croissant by the knowing First Lady of France. On state visits she is regal, and with the Dalai Lama or the Pope, Mme Pious materialises, in virtuous scarves and buttoned-up grey. Her ex-lover, Jean-Paul Enthoven (whom she jilted for his son, no less) has just written a fictional account of his relationship with this capricious shape-shifter. There seems to be dark matter at the centre of this phenomenon, something that's indescribable and very chilling indeed.
Oxford University, cradle of the Right
I recently took part in a mock Question Time in the famous Oxford Union debating chamber. David Dimbleby was the chairman and one other panellist was Douglas Murray, a red-faced, angry young man who runs what he says is an "anti-terrorism" think-tank and is more neo-con than Dick Cheney.
We discussed the future of Oxford, its greatness always assumed by itself and others. Until, that is, you meet Oxonians like Murray, who seems to loathe governments, diversity, human rights, equality and this newspaper. Why does Oxford produce so many of these batty right-wing braggarts? Makes you wonder what good that does the nation.
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited





Comments
109 Comments
wot?
Posted by confused | 25.09.08, 23:00 GMT
lin lee just look at china and the xiniang region learn your own history did you also know there are nearly 1 million pakistanis in uk how many chinese are there? No where near hence why you have more achievers,and for superstition tell me anything bout that on islam there is none you stone worshippers are again check your history, typical racist.
Posted by ki | 25.09.08, 22:17 GMT
lin lee just look at china and the xiniang region learn your own history did you also know there are nearly 1 million pakistanis in uk how many chinese are there? No where near hence why you have more achievers, typical racist.
Posted by ki | 25.09.08, 22:13 GMT
lin lee just look at china and the xiniang region learn your own history did you also know there are nearly 1 million pakistanis in uk how many chinese are there? No where near hence why you have more achievers, typical racist.
Posted by ki | 25.09.08, 22:13 GMT
lin lee just look at china and the xiniang region learn your own history did you also know there are nearly 1 million pakistanis in uk how many chinese are there? No where near hence why you have more achievers, typical racist.
Posted by ki | 25.09.08, 22:12 GMT
Reading the comments on her and the petulant and childish outbursts by most to make their point is quite entertaining.
I can't agree with YAB on this issue. She is behaving like an apologist for Islam. Anyone who believes in fairy tales should be in a mental institution -be they Christian, Jewish or Muslim.
As for Islamic fundementalism in Europe read this book by Alison Pargeter - the New frontiers of Jihad, Radical Islam in Europe. It is quite an eye opener and challenges conventional thinking as to the origins of the current problems in Europe. Her thesis is that the problems in Europe today spring from the fact that alleged 'learned' elders in Islam are in the main, first generation migrants who still cling to the ideals they left behind (despite the fact that in those countries and societies they left behind, the conventional thinking is beginning to change on some issues). Also most of the migrants are from conservative parts of Pakistan and India such as Lahore
Posted by Sam | 25.09.08, 13:48 GMT
Bunch of closet racists posting anonymously below me it seems?!
What do you call a chinese man who hates black people? Nothing because he isn't a racist ha ha
Posted by ha ha | 25.09.08, 12:51 GMT
Free Thinker,
Come out, come out wherever you are !! We await you next outpouring of verbal diarrhoea in the vain hope that you may, at last, have something resembling intelligent comment to make.
Posted by Shomer | 24.09.08, 23:21 GMT
Freethinker, you fell of your chair? Must have been very painful, especially as your intellect is apparently
where your rear end should be. I hate to be a pedant but as for your rather mean spirited attack on Hayleys grammar I suggested you check your own before you criticise. Of course there are many Pakistani and Muslim children that do well educationally but they are the exception rather than the rule. As a group they are at the bottom end of the attainment tables especially girls. You really dont listen do you? I didnt imply their educational failure was due to their race but rather their religion, do keep up! Your lack of rational argument, ill informed clichés and cheap insults illustrates my point perfectly. Keep supporting those who burn books and issue death threats to those who oppose their perverse world view. Chinese civilization was here a long before Islam and will be here long after Islam as superstitious nonsense is confined to the trash can of history.
Posted by Lin Lee | 24.09.08, 14:23 GMT
Alibhai-Brown is correct to point out that Muslims care for their own so little, but they care for the rest of us even less, in fact they value human life far less than we in the West, which is evidenced by their suicide bombings and barbaric honour killings. She is concerned for her fellow Muslims "humiliations" in Europe, tell it to the thousands of families around the world who have been victims of Islamic violence !
Posted by Shomer | 24.09.08, 14:23 GMT
109 Comments