Who should get credit for declining youth crime? Young people, of course

They are responsible for a record drop in the crime rate, so we should stop demonising them

 

Share

Some teenagers tried to rob me the other evening. I was walking my dog on an isolated stretch of the Manchester Cycleway between the run-down neighbourhoods of Gorton and Levenshulme around dusk.

A gang of about half a dozen boys and girls, aged around 15 and sporting urban uniform tracksuit bottoms and hoodies came towards me.

They took one look at my dog, crouched down, and said something approximating: “Oo look atchoo! What a gorgeous liddle puppy wuppy, yesh you are. I'm going to steal you and take you home with me. Come on, come with me doggie...”  

They then danced off in the opposite direction, with my pliant little mutt skipping merrily after them.  I let them escape a few yards before calling him to me. As he obediently galloped back, the young bandits gave some melodramatic wails, 'No! Come back!' then we all laughed, waved, and went our separate ways.

Not exactly Eden Lake, I know. Nonetheless, this little non-event illustrates a stark but seldom-noted truth about our young people. They are remarkably law-abiding. 

The latest statistics from the Ministry of Justice show that the number of people involved with the criminal justice system is at the lowest level since records began in 1970, and the drop is very largely driven by young people.

In 2007 there were 126,500 prosecutions of juveniles, in 2013 there were 48,000. Young people accounted for only 3% of defendants prosecuted in 2013 compared to 7% in 2007.

Over a period of time when the policy of has been to use more and longer custodial sentences, the number of young people in custody has dropped from around 3,000 in 2007/8 to an average of 1,233 last year.  

The stubborn remnants of the hell-in-a-handcart brigade will doubtless attribute this to police fiddling their figures, or insist that nobody reports crimes to the police any more.

I hate to splash sunshine on their cherished pessimism, but we see the exact same trends coming through from victim surveys, and from independent sources such as A&E admissions resulting from violent crimes. Some of the crimes which are hardest to sweep under the carpet, such as homicides and firearms offences, have shown some of the largest drops.

The Manchester Cycleway itself offers a vivid example of change.  A seven mile stretch of converted railway line, flanked by banks of nettles and far from the reach of police patrols or the panopticon gaze of CCTV.

It is the natural habitat of inner city youth, and you do still see them hanging out beneath the countless bridges. There are those who are swigging cider or rolling wobbly spliffs, but their numbers too are on the decline.

The graffiti in the underpasses has mostly been there for years with nothing added or changed. Twenty, even ten years ago I would not have dared venture there alone and on foot, for fear of the young muggers and gun-toting gangs that once made south Manchester notorious. Today it feels safe, even as night falls.

Of course it is not a utopia. In this city and every other there remain some dangerous individuals and criminal gangs. My dog and I have occasionally had to make a tactical change of route when we sense an air of hostility around the park benches or the underpasses.

Local or national headlines occasionally present us with horrific reminders of humanity's darker side, notably the recent savage killing of teacher Ann Maguire.

There are doubtless some parts of the country where the improvements to our safety lag far behind the rest. Such exceptions should not leave us blinkered to the rule.

Explanations for the dramatic change in the social landscape of Britain remain hotly debated. There are theories on the table ranging from environmental lead pollution to more effective policing and crime prevention technology, or the acceptability of physical punishment and our growing sensitivity to child abuse.

Others suggest that delinquent criminality has not gone away, but has reinvented itself in less visible incarnations. The truth is most probably a combination of all of the above. However the most obvious and simple solution may be the most significant.

It has long been said that the devil makes work for idle hands, and a lot of juvenile delinquency has always been a product of boredom.  It may simply be the case that when young people have a choice of smartphone, tablet and games console in front of them, they feel less need to get pissed on cheap cider and smash up a bus shelter.  

It’s true, but having said that, this explanation still seems a trifle churlish. As a society we have few hesitations in laying the blame on our young people when things go badly. But we should be equally quick to offer applause when things go right.

The inescapable truth is that young people today are less criminal, less violent, less dangerous than at any time in recent memory, and credit for that goes not to Sony, Apple or Microsoft, but to young people themselves.

React Now

Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
SPONSORED FEATURES
iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Female Support Worker - Bank

£10 - £12 per hour: Recruitment Genius: You will be working with a pleasant 27...

Recruitment Genius: Software Developer - C/C++/Node.js - Manchester City Centre

£30000 - £40000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A fantastic opportunity for a t...

Recruitment Genius: Business Development Executive / Sales - OTE £36,000

£20000 - £36000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This organisation is recruiting...

Recruitment Genius: Management Development Trainer

£30000 - £45000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This organisation is recruiting...

Day In a Page

Read Next
Lafayette police stand outside of the Grand Theater on July 23, 2015 in Lafayette, Louisiana.  

Louisiana shooting: The Second Amendment wasn't created so every American would fear for their life in a church or cinema

Nash Riggins
 

Everyone needs to get over catcalling

Holly Baxter
Iran – the land where some 700 souls were executed last year

Iran – where some 700 souls were executed last year

It's not surprising that hanging and beheading have become a grim feature of 'justice' in the Muslim world, says Robert Fisk
Earth 2.0: What we know about Kepler 452b, the most Earth-like planet ever discovered

Kepler 452b

8 things we know about the most Earth-like planet ever discovered
Isis in Afghanistan: Country's Taliban problem hasn't gone away – and it has new extremists to contend with

Afghanistan's Taliban problem hasn't gone away – and now Isis has arrived too

But Afghans are grateful that the two groups are focused on shooting each other, reports Kim Sengupta
Hunza Valley: Pakistan's 'real Shangri-La' is a world free from militant Islamists, poverty, pollution and a lacklustre education system

Pakistan's 'real Shangri-La' is a world with no militant Islamists

The Hunza Valley is beautiful, prosperous, and - thanks to charity funding – a bulwark against extremism
Going off-menu in a restaurant can cause problems for both kitchen and proprietor

Does the chef always know best?

Just like Sally in the movie, there will always be diners who want to play fast and loose with the lovingly created recipes on the menu. Should we let them, asks restaurateur Simonetta Wenkert?
8 best solar-powered lights

Bring day to night: 8 best solar-powered lights

Whether you want to mark-out your borders, decorate your prized plants or brighten-up your outside space, we’ve found eco-friendly illuminations for your garden
Anniversary Games: Sisters face up to biggest hurdle - beating each other

Sisters face up to biggest hurdle - beating each other

Cindy Ofili and Tiffany Porter want a 1-2 at the Anniversary Games - just in a different order
Tour de France 2015: Women's road races are struggling for status - and survival

Women's road races are struggling for survival

As the Tour de France ends, women have little to celebrate. Thanks to cycling's governing bodies, women's road races are lagging behind the men
Suruc suicide attack: Bombing shows that Turkey is being sucked into the violence in Syria

Suruc bombing shows that Turkey is being sucked into the violence in Syria

The porous border has been crucial to the growth of Isis and Jabhat al-Nusra, says Patrick Cockburn
The BBC is facing its most deadly political threat since its foundation - but its spirit should be revived, not crushed

'The BBC's spirit should be revived, not crushed'

The corporation is facing its most deadly political threat since its foundation, says Peter Oborne
Bob Smith: The strange case of the CIA agent that never was – and his hoard of 1,200 firearms

The strange case of the CIA agent that never was – and his hoard of 1,200 firearms

Mystery surrounds unidentified man who claimed to be a spy and was found in his car two weeks after he died
Social robots such as Pepper can help with household chores - but at what cost to privacy?

Social robots: The future of AI?

Japanese consumers are snapping up a humanoid-looking robot called Pepper - but at what cost to privacy, ponders Dominic Basulto
Human rights for cats and dogs: Spanish town council votes overwhelmingly in favour of defining pets as 'non-human residents'

Human rights for cats and dogs

Spanish town council votes overwhelmingly in favour of defining pets as 'non-human residents'
10 best bar stools

Find a place to perch

The 10 best bar stools
Arsene Wenger: 'Being insulted catching a train was a shock...'

'Being insulted catching a train was a shock...'

In December Arsene Wenger was booed by Arsenal fans at Stoke station, yet seven months later his team are being tipped as potential champions. He reveals how it happened – and why experience helps when the unexpected occurs