Play it by the book: One Day shows that bestsellers don't make great films

Why are we so upset when a novel fails to translate to the big screen?

The disappointment was palpable in the ladies' toilets. Straight after an early screening of One Day, the new film adapted from the bestselling book of the same name, women were moaning over the stalls to each other.

"Her accent was awful," lamented one voice.

"It just... wasn't as good as the book, was it?" the other called back.

This is a typical reaction when a bestseller is made into a film and you can expect to hear more of this whining after One Day is released in cinemas today. Hopes for this film are high; people care about this film a lot. And people care about this film so much because they care about the book: it is some time since a novel resonated with the British public as strongly as One Day.

Published in 2009, David Nicholls' love story begins on 15 July 1988. We meet Emma and Dexter on the day they graduate from university; the novel then checks up on them every 15 July for the next 20 years. Sometimes they are friends, other times they are not speaking, but the "will they won't they" aspect drives the plot forward and we are constantly kept guessing as to whether this vastly different pair will end up together.

After being published without much fanfare, to decent but far from overwhelming reviews, One Day became a word of mouth success. It has sold more than a million copies, been translated into 31 languages and spent three months on the New York Times bestseller list. It was the highest selling British novel of 2010. Seeing its celluloid potential, Nicholls (who has written episodes of the television drama Cold Feet as well as adapting another of his novels, Starter For Ten, for the big screen) began work on a screenplay soon after the book was published.

That is where the trouble starts. When it is announced that a much-loved novel is going to be made into a film, ardent admirers of the book become extremely nervous. Who will play their beloved characters? Will the film-makers capture the spirit of the novel? Can the film possibly be as good as the book?

I may not have been the biggest fan of One Day – finding it little more than a throwaway beach read – but many people have taken the novel to heart and they have been rooting for the film. So if the film turns out to be merely mediocre (which it has), they will feel let down. This happens almost every time a popular book is adapted. Have people not learnt by now? And why do people care so much?

If your favourite book is made into a lousy film, it doesn't change the book. Whingeing and moaning is futile. Of course a film is going to be different to a book – they are entirely different art forms. Sure, there have been some outstanding literary adaptations – from To Kill A Mockingbird to The Lord of the Rings trilogy – but I don't understand why people care so much when a favourite book fails to translate to inspiring cinema.

It seems to be a certain type of book that inspires this reaction. When a film presents an adaptation of a classic novel, yet another Dickens, Austen or Brontë, no-one seems to get too worked up. It is modern British hits that produce this hysterical response. Some of the biggest bestsellers of recent years – The Beach, Captain Corelli's Mandolin, Bridget Jones's Diary and Atonement – were adapted to varying degrees of success. All the films were heavily scrutinised, from casting through to release. Who can forget the stink caused after it was announced that a gaunt American, Renée Zellweger, was going to be playing the Ben & Jerry's-loving Bridget Jones? Predictably enough, the first complaints about One Day were heard at the casting stage. Jim Sturgess, who was chosen to play Dexter, escaped relatively unscathed, purely because no-one knew who he was. Casting unknowns in prominent roles is a shrewd move – they come free of baggage and without any major characters to be disassociated from. However, poor Anne Hathaway didn't escape quite so lightly when it was announced that she was to play Emma.

How was a beautiful American movie star going to portray a somewhat dowdy lass from Yorkshire? Well, by acting, presumably. But still, fans of the book were outraged. (To be fair, they may have had a point – Hathaway's accent is appalling.)

The film's director, Lone Scherfig, understood the conundrum she was caught in, telling New York magazine earlier this year: "No matter who we cast, someone would think that they knew who could play Emma Morley better. That's always the case when you work with something as loved as this book."

It just seems absurd to compare two such different art forms and feel so let down when a literary adaptation doesn't meet your expectations. In an interview, the French New Wave director François Truffaut asked Alfred Hitchcock if he would ever consider trying to adapt Dostoevsky's Crime and Punishment for the big screen.

"Well, in Dostoevsky's novel there are many, many words and all of them have a function," Hitchcock replied. "And to convey that in cinematic terms, substituting the language of the cinema for the written word, one would have to make a six- to 10-hour film. Otherwise it won't be any good."

While I am in no way suggesting that One Day should be considered as complex a masterpiece as Crime and Punishment, Hitchcock had the right idea about seeing literature and film as two very different disciplines that should be considered separately.

Any 90-minute film which attempts to recreate a work of fiction is going to struggle, something Scherfig is quick to point out: "Something will always be lost when you go from a book to a script, but I hope to give it something else that makes up for it. It is about turning [a story] into cinema."

Yes, it is possible to make a great adaptation. But before you buy your cinema ticket, just remember that if a film fails to do justice to your favourite book, it doesn't matter. Calm down and stop moaning. It won't change the connection you had with the book. What you loved about it is still there.

The words remain the same.

PROMOTED VIDEO
Arts and Entertainment
Judd Apatow’s make-it-up-as-you-go-along approach is ideal for comedies about stoners and slackers slouching towards adulthood
filmWith comedy film audiences shrinking, it’s time to move on
Arts and Entertainment
booksForget the Man Booker longlist, Literary Editor Katy Guest offers her alternative picks
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Arts and Entertainment
Off set: Bab El Hara
tvTV series are being filmed outside the country, but the influence of the regime is still being felt
Arts and Entertainment
Red Bastard: Where self-realisation is delivered through monstrous clowning and audience interaction
comedy
Arts and Entertainment
O'Shaughnessy pictured at the Unicorn Theatre in London
tvFiona O'Shaughnessy explains where she ends and her strange and wonderful character begins
Arts and Entertainment
The new characters were announced yesterday at San Diego Comic Con

TV
Arts and Entertainment
Rhino Doodle by Jim Carter (Downton Abbey)

TV
Arts and Entertainment
No Devotion's Geoff Rickly and Stuart Richardson
musicReview: No Devotion, O2 Academy Islington, London
Arts and Entertainment
Christian Grey cradles Ana in the Fifty Shades of Grey film

film
Arts and Entertainment
Comedian 'Weird Al' Yankovic

Is the comedy album making a comeback?

comedy
Arts and Entertainment
While many films were released, few managed to match the success of James Bond blockbuster 'Skyfall'
film
Arts and Entertainment
Jamie Dornan as Christian Grey in the first-look Fifty Shades of Grey movie still

film
Arts and Entertainment
Sue Perkins and Mel Giedroyc, centre, are up for Best Female TV Comic for their presenting quips on The Great British Bake Off

TV
Arts and Entertainment
Martin Freeman as Lester Nygaard in the TV adaptation of 'Fargo'

TV
Arts and Entertainment
A scene from Shakespeare in Love at the Noel Coward Theatre
theatreReview: Shakespeare in Love has moments of sheer stage poetry mixed with effervescent fun
Arts and Entertainment
Dwayne 'The Rock' Johnson stars in Hercules

film
Arts and Entertainment
Standing the test of time: Michael J Fox and Christopher Lloyd in 'Back to the Future'

film
Arts and Entertainment
<p><strong>2008</strong></p>
<p>Troubled actor Robert Downey Jr cements his comeback from drug problems by bagging the lead role in Iron Man. Two further films follow</p>

film
Arts and Entertainment

theatre
Arts and Entertainment
Tycoons' text: Warren Buffett and Bill Gates both cite John Brookes' 'Business Adventures' as their favourite book

books
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?

ES Rentals

    Independent Dating
    and  

    By clicking 'Search' you
    are agreeing to our
    Terms of Use.

    A new Russian revolution: Cracks start to appear in Putin’s Kremlin power bloc

    A new Russian revolution

    Cracks start to appear in Putin’s Kremlin power bloc
    Eugene de Kock: Apartheid’s sadistic killer that his country cannot forgive

    Apartheid’s sadistic killer that his country cannot forgive

    The debate rages in South Africa over whether Eugene de Kock should ever be released from jail
    Standing my ground: If sitting is bad for your health, what happens when you stay on your feet for a whole month?

    Standing my ground

    If sitting is bad for your health, what happens when you stay on your feet for a whole month?
    Commonwealth Games 2014: Dai Greene prays for chance to rebuild after injury agony

    Greene prays for chance to rebuild after injury agony

    Welsh hurdler was World, European and Commonwealth champion, but then the injuries crept in
    Israel-Gaza conflict: Secret report helps Israelis to hide facts

    Patrick Cockburn: Secret report helps Israel to hide facts

    The slickness of Israel's spokesmen is rooted in directions set down by pollster Frank Luntz
    The man who dared to go on holiday

    The man who dared to go on holiday

    New York's mayor has taken a vacation - in a nation that has still to enforce paid leave, it caused quite a stir, reports Rupert Cornwell
    Best comedians: How the professionals go about their funny business, from Sarah Millican to Marcus Brigstocke

    Best comedians: How the professionals go about their funny business

    For all those wanting to know how stand-ups keep standing, here are some of the best moments
    The Guest List 2014: Forget the Man Booker longlist, Literary Editor Katy Guest offers her alternative picks

    The Guest List 2014

    Forget the Man Booker longlist, Literary Editor Katy Guest offers her alternative picks
    Jokes on Hollywood: 'With comedy film audiences shrinking, it’s time to move on'

    Jokes on Hollywood

    With comedy film audiences shrinking, it’s time to move on
    It's the best of British art... but not all is on display

    It's the best of British art... but not all is on display

    Voted for by the British public, the artworks on Art Everywhere posters may be the only place where they can be seen
    Critic claims 'I was the inspiration for Blanche DuBois'

    Critic claims 'I was the inspiration for Blanche DuBois'

    Blanche Marvin reveals how Tennessee Williams used her name and an off-the-cuff remark to create an iconic character
    Sometimes it's hard to be a literary novelist

    Sometimes it's hard to be a literary novelist

    Websites offering your ebooks for nothing is only the latest disrespect the modern writer is subjected to, says DJ Taylor
    Edinburgh Fringe 2014: The comedy highlights, from Bridget Christie to Jack Dee

    Edinburgh Fringe 2014

    The comedy highlights, from Bridget Christie to Jack Dee
    Dame Jenny Abramsky: 'We have to rethink. If not, museums and parks will close'

    Dame Jenny Abramsky: 'We have to rethink. If not, museums and parks will close'

    The woman stepping down as chair of the Heritage Lottery Fund is worried