Decline and fall of a book on Rome 'riddled with errors'
US edition of Robert Hughes's latest work fails to address critics' complaints
Sunday 04 December 2011
To make a mistake in a book is unfortunate. To riddle the first 200 pages of a 500-page history of Rome with howlers and then, six months later, reprint them in the US edition, looks like carelessness. But that is what has happened to the Australian writer Robert Hughes, a reviewer says.
When Rome was published here in June, reviewers said it contained so many "errors and misunderstandings" that they were surprised it hadn't been pulped. "Skip the first 200 pages," wrote Cambridge academic Mary Beard. "The first half... is little short of a disgrace – to both author and publisher. It is riddled with errors and misunderstandings that will mislead the innocent and infuriate the specialist."
Peter Stothard, editor of the TLS, said it displayed an "unsettling" kind of carelessness, "almost a vice, a show of unconcern and shallow understanding, an arrogance of a different kind, a lack of care of any kind."
You might have expected the mistakes to have been purged for the US edition, but some remain, according to US reviewer Michael Mewshaw.
While the opera Tosca is now correctly attributed to Puccini, not Verdi, and Clement V is now described as a French pope, not Italian, many basic errors about the city's topography and history apparently remain unaltered: the Stadio dei Marmi is located in the EUR district in the south of Rome, when it is in the north.
More surprising is that these mistakes have gone unremarked in the US, even by the British historian Simon Schama in Newsweek. The author of A History of Britain, makes no reference to the British outcry, instead lavishing this "exhilarating, rambunctious" book with nothing but praise.
Hughes, 73, a revered man of letters on the New York literary scene, has suffered health problems since a car crash in 1999. But the sheer number of factual mistakes in his latest book has left many dumbfounded.
Mewshaw, who has lived in Rome on and off for 40 years, yesterday described Hughes's mistakes as "flabbergasting". "These are not interpretative errors. These are straight factual errors," he said. "Hughes says he has never lived in the city; he has only visited for a week or two at a time. This puts him in the position of a bachelor who produces a marriage manual based on his experiences of speed dating."
The mistakes suggest Hughes may have been writing from memory: a piazza he describes as filled with cars has not been a car park for over 30 years. Last night Mr Hughes said: "I'm afraid I am unaware of this."
Most of the mistakes in the UK edition appeared in the section on antiquity, prompting Professor Beard to observe: "If a book about the history of the 20th century had as many mistakes as this one, I am tempted to think that it would have been pulped and corrected." Last night, she said: "I haven't seen the US edition, so can't really comment. I must say I had assumed the errors would have been corrected. I really hoped so. There were some great things in it, but the classical sections of the English edition were so loaded with mistakes as to be very misleading. My favourite was the idea that the emperor Antoninus Pius was a Christian."
Grace Dent on TV The Secret Life of the Pub is sexist, ageist and a breath of fresh air
Art Megumi Igarashi criticises Japan's 'backwards' attitude to women's sexual expression
Ray Davies' Sunny Afternoon scoops the most awardsTheatre
Grace DentChannel 4 show proves there's no app for happiness
Arts & Ents blogs
- 1 Alan Rickman admits editing 'terrible' script with friends in Pizza Hut behind backs of writers on Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves
- 2 Rarest Beanie Baby of them all could be sold for £62,500 on eBay
- 3 Professional big game hunter Ian Gibson crushed to death by elephant during hunt
- 4 Farmer told to tear down mock-Tudor castle after hiding construction behind hay bales
- 5 Rebecca Francis accuses Ricky Gervais of using 'influence' to target female hunters after receiving barrage of death threats
Better Call Saul creator Peter Gould on the creative concerns of a prequel, season 2 and the mind-numbing realities of the small courts
Game of Thrones season 5: Emilia Clarke praises characters who 'accept their femininity'
Britain's Got Talent 2015: RSPCA investigating Marc Metral's miming dog after cruelty complaints
Fifty Shades of Grey movie shows first sex scene 'after 40 minutes'
Glastonbury 2015 tickets: How to make sure you’re successful in Sunday's re-sale
If I’m being racially abused I don’t need a stranger with a saviour complex to rescue me
The only black face in the Ukip manifesto is on the page about overseas aid
Ukip is the only main political party to not address LGBT rights in its manifesto
Food banks: One million Britons will soon be using them, according to Trussell Trust
Religion isn't growing, it is becoming vigorous in its demise, says philosopher AC Grayling
BBC election debate: The one photo that summed up the whole 90-minute leaders debate