Toback cast Downey Jr in Two Girls when getting arrested was just about all he could manage. Unfazed, so Toback told the class, by the prospect of handling Downey Jr, the director nevertheless offered a glimpse of what he'd taken on. Downey, it seems, is extremely self-conscious about what he believes is his huge mouth, a fixation which crops up repeatedly in the film's mirror scene. He then riled his co-star, Heather Graham, by rewriting the bathroom scene to become "the most self-serving opening imaginable".
Toback obviously likes a challenge because, as he recounted, Downey Jr's behaviour on the shoot for Black and White grew yet stranger. Playing a gay man married to Brooke Shields, Downey Jr was required to chat up Mike Tyson (as himself) in a nightclub scene. Tyson decked Downey Jr and then proceeded to flirt with Shields. At this point Toback's improvisatory methods went to Downey Jr's head - the wayward star was spotted apparently masturbating while eyeing up Shields's and Tyson's tete-a-tete.