Fireflies in the Garden (15)

Click to follow
The Independent Culture

An agonisingly sincere drama of familial dysfunction, this is notable for some very basic miscasting.

First up is Ryan Reynolds as a celebrated novelist returning to his midwestern home to find that he still can't stand his tyrannical father, Willem Dafoe. Reynolds, a decent comic actor, hasn't got the chops for this sensitive misfit, and Dafoe isn't convincing as the waspy patriarch who bullied him. Julia Roberts has a supporting role as the latter's wife, but her story is undermined by casting Ioan Gruffud as her too youthful paramour. Flashbacks to the protagonist's literary indiscretion carry a whiff of Tobias Wolff's novel Old School, though it lacks the book's charm. There just isn't enough to distinguish it from dozens of other damaged-family memoirs.